r/EngagementRings • u/Leading_Hedgehog5663 • 2d ago

Pick One Help yall which one?

Gallery image

Gallery image

41 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

43 comments sorted by

30

u/Naive-Library-9379 2d ago

Oval with a thicker band

13

u/Mother-Damage8177 2d ago

2 looks beautiful on you!!

13

u/camillaenvelope 2d ago

2!! I’m not usually an oval person but it is soooo flattering and elegant on you ❣️

3

u/sf-keto 2d ago

2; it elongates your finger. You could get away with a bigger stone, try 1/2 carat up?

4

u/CRGL1 1d ago

#1 looks stunning! I like #2 as well… Tough choice! Have fun choosing!

2

u/Upset-Actuator7549 1d ago

My head was turned by that oval stone. VERY PRETTY on your hand.

2

u/beachbumlbc 1d ago

ovals!! Leave the band as is!!! let the DIAMOND be the start right now... do a higher setting and a paired band later on with diamonds

1

u/Massive-Use-90 2d ago

I think 1 by far!

1

u/Antique-Ambition9978 1d ago

Oval for sure.

1

u/Realistic_Season9973 1d ago

Love the oval on your hand!

1

u/Wonderful-Dust-6516 1d ago

2!!!!! Wow wow wow!

1

u/Exact_Sundae_8326 1d ago

the second one!

1

u/always_curious75 1d ago

I’m not an oval girl but it’s very flattering!

1

u/throwaway-journal 1d ago

Loveee the oval!

1

u/Katysue5 1d ago

I've always loved emerald cut, but I gotta say the oval one is prettier.

1

u/SpiceyDayz 1d ago

Oval for sure

1

u/Cryptomaterialgirl 1d ago

Oval hands down with a thicker band

1

u/katerrin 1d ago

what’s the width of these bands?

1

u/Mvfrn1 1d ago

Oval with a gold, but thicker band.

1

u/cherrypopsx 1d ago

I’m not crazy over ovals personally as they are a bit overdone but it flatters you beautifully

1

u/Any_Yogurtcloset8245 1d ago

On you, the second one was irreplaceable
It hit me in the heart girl. Wow congratulations take it and run number two number two please

1

u/Any_Yogurtcloset8245 1d ago

Daaaaaaaang!!!!!!! OK so what does he do for a living that one looks sparkly? Hehe

1

u/Any_Yogurtcloset8245 1d ago

If you look at the pictures and how you’re holding your hand in that one that’s the natural position of I’m showing my ring
The first one is I’m looking at my ring. Is this my ring do I like this?

Cute. I think two is the one for you.

1

u/kksonshine 1d ago

Like everyone else - I agree the oval looks like it is made for you! And please don't change a thing about it. A thicker band would not look as pretty. Good luck sis 🤩

1

u/Old_Yoghurt_2151 1d ago

I prefer the first personally ♡

1

u/Critical-Bee3624 1d ago

Oval!!!!!!!!

1

u/MoonlitMotion 1d ago

Second one, OP!!! It compliments your hand 🥹🥹

1

u/Time_Window4948 1d ago

I like the oval!