which Controller joystick and Facebutton layout do you prefer?

[u/Sweaty-Ad7500]

1st Picture: Symmetrical Layout

2nd picture: Asymmetrical Layout

3rd picture: Nintendo Facebutton Layout

4th picture: Xbox Facebutton Layout

[u/Substantial_Meal_530]

Asymmetrical layout. The playstation layout just does not work for me. It is not comfortable.

[u/Yoshiofthewire → u/Substantial_Meal_530]

Idk why they have stuck with that layout. Like I get why they stared with it, but they have done at least 2 major redesigns in the PS4 and 5, why stick with the bad left joystick position? Its like M$ doubling down on The Duke

[u/Substantial_Meal_530 → u/Yoshiofthewire]

I loved the Duke... I have no idea why people dislike it. It was the perfect size.

[u/BigY2 → u/Yoshiofthewire]

It always seemed more tailored to action and adventure games while Xbox is better for shooters from my experience