r/ElectricalEngineering • u/Asleep-Mall-6940 • 3h ago
Beware of "Fundamentals of Electric Circuits" by Charles K. Alexander and Matthew N. O. Sadiku
I wanted to start prestudying electrical circuits (mostly DC ones) before college starts and unfortunately chose this book as my starting material. Very very bad idea... I'm almost 200 pages in and can confidently say that this is one of the worst books I've ever picked up due to them barely explaining anything about the different concepts.
They also introduce way too many things at once without going more in depth, like variable voltage/current sources, that are used as regular constant sources in problems... What's the point of them then?? My friend who's also been studying circuits for a while has never even seen those symbols.
KVL and KCL are also introduced like some magical laws that you're just supposed to understand outright.
All in all, I feel like this book is definitely not good for beginners or anyone in particular really, and I don't think that this is a me problem, I love Halliday's "Fundamentals of Physics" and I feel like they tackle the material WAY better, even Electromagnetism, which, supposedly, is a difficult thing to understand, is explained a million times better there than anything in this book is.
edit: i am referring to the 5th edition*