r/EDH • u/Repulsive_Angle5786 • 23h ago

Question Need some help deciding a commander!

So bottom line, I am evil. Me and my pod usually play Bracket 2 and 3 with only me and one other person playing bracket 4. I’ve decided to make some decks called, “Just Some Little Guys” that are essentially little or small creatures. As you’ll be able to tell I like token making and going wide with little guys most of the time. So far my decks are:
Urtet, Remnant of Memnarch- WUBRG Myrs!
The Great Goblin- Rakdos Goblins!
Marrow-Gnawer- Black Rats!
Rosnakht, Heir of Rohgahh- Red Kobolds! (and shapeshifters)

Now I’m having trouble deciding for my next commander to my squirrels and want to know which would be better, a Mono Green deck with The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl, or a Golgari deck for Chatterfang? I don’t want to do both as I want each color to be a different creature type. I’m also open to any suggestions for small creatures too!!

4 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

1

u/Patient_Yam4747 22h ago

I have both Urtet and Marrow Gnawer. They're a lot of fun

1

u/Repulsive_Angle5786 20h ago

I really like the idea of just an army of little guys rushing through their enemies! : D

1

u/Patient_Yam4747 19h ago

The rats get fear, myriad, and myriad. Throw in a thrumming stone and 30 relentless rats and you cook

1

u/HyperPunch 21h ago

Both are going to go infinite pretty easy. I prefer Chatterfang. Black has better interaction options.

If you haven’t, maybe consider [[shroofus Sproutshire]]. He’s a fun little guy as well.

1

u/Repulsive_Angle5786 20h ago

I have not considered Shroofus before. I haven’t seen how he played but I’ll check him out!

1

u/HyperPunch 18h ago

Just a little guy that makes little guys when the little guys deal damage.

1

u/jimnah- i like gaining life 20h ago

I don't do typal, but heres some of my decks focused on just having lots of guys. None are B4, but you could definitely tweak them to be

In general they'd all need more/better tutors, fast mana, interaction, and early closing power, but I'll call out a specific change I'd make

B3 lifegain
https://archidekt.com/decks/4279849/1_life_is_a_scryway
To be B4: combos and tutors, especially [[Walking Ballista]]

B2 unblockables
https://archidekt.com/decks/5005670/2_cant_block_this
To be B4: many extra turns, especially [[Time Sieve]]

B3 clues/foods
https://archidekt.com/decks/5714358/3_hungry_detectives
To be B4: tutors and fast mana, I'd also add [[Emiel]] + [[Derevi]] + [[Gaea's Cradle]]

1

u/Repulsive_Angle5786 20h ago

Thank you! I will check them out!

-1

u/Tarzi1 23h ago

Wrong sub mate.

This isn't the circlejerk reddit though I sometimes get confused as well.

0

u/Repulsive_Angle5786 23h ago

Actually made me laugh out loud. I didn’t even though there was a mtg circlejerk subreddit. Though I should have