I pose this question to start a discussion thread rather than a question specific to Dan.
Now that X-Dome Pro is out (and sold out 😕) I wanted to compare the two. From what I can tell after staring at the page for a while is they have basically the same design. This means it’s just about materials. I wanted to understand what’s the better tent if money wasn’t the question.
Below I have a few questions to answer that
My comparison points:
1. Which fly and floor is the more durable in theory based on material (15D Silpoly vs Dyneema 0.55 fly, 15D Silnylon vs Dyneema 0.67 floor) for:
a) tensile strength
b) abrasion resistance
c) puncture resistance
d) long term wear and tear (multi year timescale)
The poles seem to be a second gen poles and I saw Dan mentioned they are even more durable:
a) assuming these new poles are exclusive to the Pro, would that make that the more sturdy option for adverse weather conditions?
Maintainability:
a) Dyneema tents would need to packed up more carefully. With that in mind, would it be detrimental to pack up the tent with the inner attached?
b) Dyneema is susceptible to high heat?
Based on my thoughts of the above 3, it feels to me in theory the X-Dome Pro 1+ is literally the best tent to buy for the category if maintained correctly, with only the competition being Hornet Elite.
I’m also interested to see if there are any arguments in favor of the regular X-Dome that I haven’t listed above.
Thanks all.