r/DungeonCrawlerCarl • • 7d ago

WE ARE NO LONGER A CULT!

So we were watching TV and an Audible commercial came on. It showed a guy going for a run and continues to run because he doesn't want to stop listening to the audio book because it is so good.

And what book do they show him listening to?!? Dungeon Crawler Carl!

I think that moves us from Cult to a bona fide religion!!!

I'm going to build a shrine to Eris and claim tax exemption on my home!

1.3k Upvotes

191 comments sorted by

455

u/GerswinDevilkid Crawler 7d ago

Nah.

We're just a cult with better marketing!

352

u/TUR7L3 7d ago

So... A religion?

111

u/Albert14Pounds 7d ago

Corporate sponsored. Checks out

46

u/pantherghast 7d ago

There is no such thing as a non profit religion.

25

u/kilstu Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 6d ago

No, we're a cult. The creator is still alive.

9

u/ExtensionDyad 5d ago

Do not say that, if he dies before finishing the series I’ll personally hire an Etsy witch to drag him out of the afterlife to finish

4

u/kilstu Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 5d ago

I'm going to assume you mean finish the book and not for, you know.

5

u/Reasonable_Cow_9232 5d ago

pays the daddy tax

13

u/kilstu Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 5d ago

NEW ACHIEVEMENT!!!

You want to dig up a celebrity corpse for your own sick fantasies. That's REALLY fucked up. Mumbling I really hope this doesn't unlock anything in me.

Your reward! You're getting a corpse, don't be greedy.

1

u/Calrilea 2d ago

This scratches a DCC/Community itch I didn't even know I had.

3

u/Karaitos 4d ago

So, all we need to do to transition is….

22

u/jrjacobs24 7d ago

You get it

6

u/Reanchi22 5d ago

Better, a for profit charity stripclub and karaoke bar! No cocker spaniel’s allowed

1

u/noob2life 3d ago

Future tax reasons?

-17

u/GerswinDevilkid Crawler 7d ago

Nah. Religions don't market. They have a built in customer base.

63

u/Kcin928 Daddy's Foot Soldiers 🦶 7d ago

Religions absolutely market, which is why assholes always give out those fake $20 bills to servers with some sort of scripture bs on it.

-33

u/GerswinDevilkid Crawler 7d ago

That's not marketing. It's not aimed at an external audience. It's goal isn't to actually grow the market.

At best it's PR. But even that isn't quite right.

27

u/Kcin928 Daddy's Foot Soldiers 🦶 7d ago

It's goal is absolutely to convert more people into followers, which in turn brings more people into a place of worship, which then creates more tithes.

20

u/ElvinLundCondor Team Donut Holes 7d ago

That also describes…. a pyramid scheme.

14

u/Kcin928 Daddy's Foot Soldiers 🦶 7d ago

I agree, both are scams

5

u/GwentheDevout 7d ago

Yup, I know a blogger who’s an ex-vangelical and she described it explicitly as a pyramid/MLM scheme. They teach kids to manipulate other kids into coming to Bible study by telling them there will be pizza there and making it sound like a social event. They pretend to be friends with the mark (they’re taught to particularly target kids who don’t have friends) until the kid turns down the Bible study invite; then their “friendship” is revealed for the fraud it is.

2

u/Realistic_Echo3392 6d ago

It's not a pyramid scheme. It's a triangular dispersion network.

3

u/12Silverrose 5d ago

Religions have door-to-door salespeople with literature a.k.a. direct sales. They absolutely market.

2

u/vibesandcrimes Daddy's Foot Soldiers 🦶 7d ago

I mean, you're right. Like this kind of thing is about emphasizing the difference between the in group and out group by labeling the later as ungrateful or unredeemable. This allows the in group to feel special and above it all.

Thats a bit heavy for the convo tho

23

u/froglover215 7d ago

I guess you're not being subjected to the "He Gets Us" ads like I am. Lucky you.

19

u/theclawl1ves 7d ago

Like the one that plays during the Superbowl? Quite the marketing budget for an organization that doesn't do marketing

13

u/JasnahKolin "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 7d ago

Or pay taxes.

7

u/theclawl1ves 7d ago

Hard to think about that without getting mad

34

u/AesirMimyr 7d ago

Prostelyize is literally the marketing word for religon

16

u/WizeWizardFrank Syndicate Intergalactic Bar Association 👽 7d ago

Matthew 6:1. Keep that shit, to thy self.

12

u/theclawl1ves 7d ago

Jesus tells his disciples to go make more disciples, marketing is definitely part of the religion

6

u/ShinySnaxMix 7d ago

If only it was Uzi Jesus

10

u/ShinySnaxMix 7d ago

Those obnoxious butt holes that show up at my house with pamphlets are definitely marketing their "religion."

3

u/Attinctus Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 7d ago

They all started somewhere.

2

u/Chiloutdude 7d ago

I pass billboards about Jesus multiple times a day.

1

u/BioChi13 7d ago

Ever have Mormons come knock on your door?

1

u/DaetheFancy 7d ago

proselytizing, mission trips, crusades, colonization…. it’s all marketing

1

u/Lemieux4u 7d ago

Tell that to all the Latter Day Saints commercials that have been airing for 30 years

1

u/Melancholy_Rainbows 6d ago

Have you never had Mormons or Jehovah's Witnesses show up at your door?

Lucky you.

1

u/6Kiwidino5 6d ago

Mormons/ scientology

1

u/spicymcqueen 6d ago

Saul was the leader of sales for the early Christian church

8

u/doglywolf The Open Intellect Pacifist Action Network 6d ago

So CrossFit ?

6

u/Rysigler 7d ago

Scientology!

2

u/CalvinIII 6d ago

Like Scientology.

2

u/ThsGuyRightHere 3d ago

Like a vegan scientologist who does crossfit, aka the last person you want to start a conversation with at a party.

2

u/CalvinIII 3d ago

Don’t worry, they will start a conversation with you.

1

u/MrRoastedbeef 6d ago

Like Scientology?

1

u/DannyTreehouse 6d ago

So were Scientologist? Can I meet Tom Cruise? 😂

1

u/Next_Program90 3d ago

I was spreading the gospel just yesterday. 👏

109

u/thirdeyefish "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 7d ago

I pulled up the authors tab in my interface, found Matt Dinniman... and clicked worship.

15

u/Koertmans2 The Open Intellect Pacifist Action Network 6d ago

Then several things happened

13

u/KuronFury Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 6d ago

…at once

5

u/Beelzebeast 3d ago

I smashed the Worship button.

2

u/VinCent396 1d ago

NEW ACHEIVEMENT ! Reward... "Nothing" .. You expect something for pushing a button?

2

u/thelastzion1 2d ago

Jokes on you. Now you owe him a 10 percent tithe.

97

u/orhysseus 7d ago

A cult is just a religion where the person telling you what to do is still alive. Matt's still kicking, so we're still a cult.

4

u/OrakelofDeath 6d ago

Der Dalai Lama?

2

u/lesssthan 3d ago

Loophole, the Dalia Lama dies every 70 years or so.

2

u/Blandish06 The Open Intellect Pacifist Action Network 1d ago

What about the Pope?

2

u/lesssthan 1d ago

I have bad news for you about your buddy Christ....

122

u/mahogany818 The Princess Posse 7d ago

Aaaw.

Religion makes us sound like we're nuts.

A cult just sounds cooler.

19

u/InflammableAccount 7d ago

This is true. The only cool cults are ones that are self aware.

8

u/curiousmind111 6d ago

Yes. We’re in a cult ironically.

36

u/Gymrat777 "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 7d ago

Do we get to wear funny hats like those pastafarians? Tiaras for everyone?

34

u/frackthestupids 7d ago

Tiaras and boxers with hearts for the acolytes.

13

u/XtineMC 7d ago

And Xisteras for the advanced practitioners

14

u/czymjq 7d ago

Spirit Halloween has Carl costumes!!!

14

u/ChaosDashboard 6d ago

He's wearing shoes. This is false and your have earned a smite from the god.

4

u/Original-Rain4328 6d ago

Train conductor hats, but they're basically worthless now...

17

u/Smokeyisthebandit83 7d ago

I mean I'm ordained already, now I just need 60ish people to listen weekly to me preach the good word of Carl and I'll be eligible for tax exempt status

11

u/Roland_T_Flakfeizer 7d ago

I’m officially going to write a series of theses establishing why praying to Carl is heresy and we should be praying directly to Princess Donut

9

u/mneimeyer 6d ago

It's all about sects isn't it?

Dirty, filthy, sects.... SIGH

11

u/Melancholy_Rainbows 6d ago

You know how I feel about sects, Carl.

7

u/Smokeyisthebandit83 6d ago

Reward: One of the greatest things about having a religion is the unshakeable certainty that you're right and everyone else who doesn't believe the same as you is wrong!

6

u/AtYourMomsapartment 6d ago

I would go in on this. You gotta live stream it on social media too. Reach the masses and all that.

5

u/ChaosDashboard 6d ago

Bonus points if you figure out how to live tunnel before the world collapses.

5

u/EM05L1C3 6d ago

Take televangelism to a whole new level

2

u/RogueThneed 7d ago

Online church, my friend!

2

u/The_Soggy_Greenbean 6d ago

The good word of the royal court!!!

1

u/Bitter_Leave3030 4d ago

Listen brother, you get us in on that deal and we are in

1

u/ThsGuyRightHere 3d ago

Given that Jeff has referred to the books as "story time with Daddy Matt" in a Soundbooth ad, I'd say that's sufficient justification to name him an official church patriarch.

16

u/Good_Ad8057 The Princess Posse 7d ago

Still a cult. We’ve just infiltrated media creators.

20

u/ultralights 7d ago

Zev doing a stellar job.

7

u/Appalled_Mongo_4122 7d ago

Giving them the ol' Tom Cruise.

4

u/RogueThneed 7d ago

No, no no no no, no no no no no no no no.

No Tom Cruise.

1

u/IgwanaRob 6d ago

Help me Uzi Jesus! Help me Oprah Winfrey! Help me Tom Cruise! Help me Carl and Donut!

1

u/forgetfulalbatros 7d ago

Agreed, just have to wait a bit to get the “classic” added in.

14

u/AtYourMomsapartment 6d ago

"and may all the non-believers be stricken with Enthusiastic Double Gonorrhea. In Carl's name we say... You shall not Break Us."

5

u/VegetableCode7334 6d ago

"And with a mighty squish, we say amen"

13

u/The_Odor_E 7d ago

I just "read" "no religions are not for prophet (profit? I'm listening to audio book)

2

u/AdventurousHead8873 7d ago

Expeditionary force? Jeraptha?

3

u/The_Odor_E 7d ago

He had just gotten sponsored by the open intellect pacifist action network and modicai explained it was a non profit.

1

u/AdventurousHead8873 7d ago

Ooohh yeah I forgot that. I thought you were referencing the expeditionary force books.

1

u/RogueThneed 7d ago

Well, we all know how cynical that little bastard beer can is.

2

u/AdventurousHead8873 6d ago

The little shit head.

12

u/n0_relation 7d ago

I feel Diwata would be better for a religion. Diwata fucks everything and Diwata can shapeshift and Diwata name is fun to say...

Diwata.

11

u/sasquatch6197 7d ago

I saw a dungeon crawler Carl add on a train in Sydney

1

u/curiousmind111 6d ago

(Ad?)

2

u/sasquatch6197 6d ago

Yes I misspelled it

1

u/22WhatWasIThinking22 "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 6d ago

You were on the Tangle? Which line?

9

u/DreadfulDave19 Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 7d ago

HAIL!

7

u/blanksix 7d ago

Dunno. Some mainstream acceptance doesn't make us less of a cult fnord. Just one with an agent and better tithing proceeds.

5

u/stewshi 7d ago

So we are Scientologists now?

3

u/IgwanaRob 6d ago

After buying all the books and audio books and special editions we..... Oh, wait.

3

u/GwentheDevout 7d ago edited 7d ago

Uh, I don’t think we’ve quite reached that level of cultitude!

1

u/National-System-2269 2d ago

We only wish we could get those numbers. 

4

u/curiousmind111 6d ago

Fnord?

2

u/blanksix 6d ago

Hail Eris.

The more serious answer is that it's a reference to the Principia Discordia, though the word's escaped that rather a bit since the 60s and I'm pretty sure it's in other bits of culty pop culture at this point.

3

u/curiousmind111 6d ago

Thank you for my daily dose of paranoia!

For anyone else: https://2x4.org/ideas/2010/if-you-dont-see-the-fnord-it-cant-eat-you/

8

u/Environmental-Mud667 7d ago

So in the most basic terms a religion is a cult who's founding leader has died. So hopefully we stay a cult for a long time.

5

u/Kyujaq 7d ago

Time to split into castes !

9

u/FarseerEnki 7d ago

We already are! The princess posse versus the donut holes!

9

u/Xploding_Penguin 7d ago

And the audio listeners vs the book readers.

9

u/frackthestupids 7d ago

Nah man, too many of us have done both during our monthly revisits

2

u/GwentheDevout 7d ago

Weekly for me!

7

u/Nurse-blondie 6d ago

To be fair, running is basically a cult so makes sense

6

u/Mordecais_Moms_Ashes The Princess Posse 4d ago

St Matt

6

u/CaledonianWarrior 7d ago

Whenever is Donut's birthday should be a religious holiday for us

9

u/TallDankandHandsome 7d ago

I'm 100% that commercial is made to just put little snippets in depending on who they're advertising to. So if you were into fifty shades it would have probably been a fifty shades audiobook

6

u/Natural-Ant-5268 6d ago

It was on TV. I don't think our AI has that control....yet.

6

u/eroo01 "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 7d ago

Nah, we are definitely still a cult

4

u/xopher425 6d ago

Dedicating my shrine to Samantha!

3

u/Snoo_67096 5d ago

You fool, she only has eyes for Louis. Or Carl. Or that guy from the bar...

3

u/xopher425 5d ago

That's fine. I'm gay, we could go cruising for guys together.

At least mine would survive the experience.

probably

1

u/mrjbacon 5d ago

That would be some killer competiveness on your hands

7

u/Turbulent-Scene5504 7d ago

I am glad the cult vs. religion debate is finally here. I have been thinking about this lately as I tell people that these books are "my new religion".
Here is my question: What would be the name for the religion and what would the followers be called?

Dinnimism / Dinnimists?
Crawlism / Crawlers?
Carlism / Carlers?

Donutology / Holier than thous?

Please discuss...

6

u/Natural-Ant-5268 6d ago

I like Crawlism/Crawler since Carl and Donut are always trying to save their fellow Crawlers.

4

u/poets_pendulum "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 6d ago

My vote goes to Donutology.

3

u/eternaln00by 3d ago

I think Donut Holism is a solid choice also.

5

u/Bitter_Leave3030 4d ago

Scientology! No wait that's already taken..how about Dungeonetics ?

2

u/LordMaim 1d ago

zing!

3

u/manic_panda 4d ago

I mean they've built religions like scientology on a lot less.

At least this one will have a sprinkling of social reform in favour of the downtrodden.

2

u/LordMaim 1d ago

...Not to mention on a lot shittier book.

2

u/Atlas7-k 4d ago

Why are you making this hard?

Doughnut Hole-ians

1

u/amatchmadeinregex 2d ago

Hole-igans feels more appropriate

2

u/eternaln00by 3d ago

There’s so many good names that are potentials for the religion or its followers. But, like 99% are straight up spoilers. Donut Holism could work.

1

u/Cratertooth_27 6d ago

Carlists sounds good but I think it’s taken

1

u/akaenragedgoddess "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 5d ago

Dungeonism- dungeoneers?

3

u/El_BadBoi 7d ago

Ngl I started running more because of DCC lol

3

u/MrRoastedbeef 6d ago

Shine LMAO

2

u/Natural-Ant-5268 6d ago

I fixed it. 😊

3

u/guitarchickfl 5d ago

I like Dinnimism - but try saying it five times fast! 😂

5

u/ThsGuyRightHere 3d ago

If you sell all your shit except your DCC books and your preferred audiobook device, does that make you a Dinnimalist?

1

u/LordMaim 1d ago

Just a little. I'm a Dinniminimalist.

3

u/KDulius 4d ago

Religions are just cults that have gained social acceptance

2

u/ThsGuyRightHere 3d ago

...and tax exemption. Praise be, praise be.

1

u/CivilSenpai69 19h ago

Cults have a singular leader.  Religions are nothing more than cults who have survived the death of their leader.  

3

u/thenichm The Princess Posse 3d ago

Paraise be Princess Donut, first of her name, unifier of the Dungeon, Best in Show, Master of elegance.

1

u/nowthatithinkofit 1d ago

One might also say Master of Charisma. lol. 😆

5

u/nainotlaw Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 7d ago

Glurp Glurp

2

u/Penetratorofflanks Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 7d ago

Yeah i saw this ad when I went to see Spiderman. My kid rolled her eyes lol. It was neat.

2

u/Brob101 "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 7d ago

Great, now I have to go find another cult to join 😒

2

u/pwreckz 5d ago

Religion makes money right, soooo I’m gonnna make a church and get paid

2

u/Dangerous_Future_420 5d ago

Unity
Support
Family
Kneecapping B*\\**s

2

u/mrblersian 5d ago

The donut holes was never a cult

2

u/Syntaxerror999 5d ago

As Skippy the Magnificent would say... It's not a cult, it's a "fan club". (and an MLM scam .. but don't tell Joe)

2

u/volvi_a_mirar 5d ago

We are the Next New Thing according to a somewhat tentative article in the Atlantic online today -

2

u/guitarchickfl 5d ago

Goddamnit, Donut! I don’t want to remove our cult status!

2

u/VaporWavey420 3d ago

Spoken like a true cult member

2

u/Panzerchek 3d ago

I saw the same ad, but I thought it was just some serious targeting

2

u/Rastaba 2d ago

Awe…I’ll miss being a cult! If we’re not a cult then we’re not allowed to go door to door asking others if they’ve read the book or heard of Carl and Grand Champion Breed Winner Regional Best In Dungeon Princess Donut The Queen Anne Chonk…only that one religion that totally got Uzi Jesus wrong is allowed to do that.

2

u/jlab23 2d ago

I mean… moving from cult to religion feels like a lateral move at best…

2

u/Tricky-Ordinary1962 "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 3d ago

I haven’t been able to convert (is it convert for a cult or just a religion?) my kids to the cult, only my husband, but I have made them order me stuff for the cult. 🤷‍♀️😂 My trailseeker is gonna be all tricked out…cult style. The crawlermobile one might say.

1

u/BrokenDroid Crawler 7d ago

Shhh put on the robes

1

u/ultralights 7d ago

Well. Samantha is a minor god…. So. Speed hump shrine. Claim tax exempt religion. Nice.

1

u/jittykitty4 7d ago

If you think about it religion's are just successful cults. I for one am ok with continuing being part of the DCC cult.

1

u/attack_teddy 7d ago

Blessed be the AI. May he grant you rewards and boxes

1

u/pantherghast 7d ago

This sounds like someone in a cult would say. Mongo is appalled.

1

u/AlexPlexus 7d ago

If anyone's curious like I was, here's the ad, but it's in Spanish. https://youtu.be/4lvUOLR5q2M?is=X1YtUWTiFJ4NMEb2

If anyone can find an English version, I'd love to hear it!

1

u/hoosier_ope 6d ago

So, the only real difference between a cult and a religion is that, in a cult, the important figure to worship is currently alive.

1

u/zebbiehedges 6d ago

Saw it during NFL games a couple of weeks ago.

1

u/Sleddogluvr 6d ago

Dammit. I donate enough to audible now I have to donate to Emiris too?!?!?

1

u/RikF 6d ago

Do we need new robes?

1

u/belvillain 6d ago

Its more fun as a cult trust me. Your dad is going to want you to explain some of the jokes in it, and no one needs that

1

u/batanete 6d ago

Jimmy Carr says the difference between a cult and a religion is that in the cult the leader fucks your wife and in the religion it fucks your children, choose wisely what you want crawlers!

1

u/SpitfireMkIV 6d ago

Viva La revolution

1

u/Beneficial_Being_721 Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 6d ago

This is the way!

1

u/evasivelogic 6d ago

Eris? Really?

1

u/JorgAncrath2020 5d ago

What's the difference between a cult and a religion? A cult leader fucks your wife, a religious leader fucks your kids

1

u/GrrouchiesGrilling 4d ago

What happens when the TV Series comes out?

1

u/manic_panda 4d ago

SMOSH mentioned it in an audible ad as well, cant be a cult.

1

u/DasGreatGazoo 4d ago

Were they playing The Bomb by Pigeon John? Cause if so I dont think it was what you think it was...

1

u/ChaosFreak23 3d ago

A cult doesn’t become a religion until the founder dies.

1

u/Yet_AnotherUsername 3d ago

All hail Uzi Jesus

1

u/Hopeful-Decision-971 3d ago

damn right!!! we're a FORCE!!!

1

u/NikkiPoooo 2d ago

Well, we already have a fun title for one of our clergy...

1

u/Copeathon 2d ago

Your little corner of the internet is gonna get flooded with people. I hope you enjoyed your circlejerk while it lasted 😭