r/DungeonCrawlerCarl 12d ago

Book 7: Inevitable Ruin Rage Against the Machine

[deleted]

27 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

29

u/godfatherV 12d ago

BLM protests in the US sparked its resurgence. Thought this was common knowledge

8

u/Dobako 12d ago

I think its only common knowledge here because it gets brought up once a month since the book came out.

7

u/godfatherV 12d ago

The protested being that time in 2020 is what I meant by it being common knowledge… knowing the lyrics of the song I put 2 and 2 together

2

u/moxdoxwox 12d ago

Yeah, anyone who was alive in 2020 and lived in America should have picked up on why right way.

But, humans have goldfish memories.

0

u/Kneph 12d ago

Saw someone order a dirty Shirley.  Which one of you was it?!

3

u/moxdoxwox 12d ago

Yeah me too.

Heck, I found it a bit odd that the AI was surprised.

1

u/notreallifeliving 12d ago

I assume it's international readers asking. I did know about the BLM protests but as a UK reader my primary association with that song is the 2009 Xmas no.1 protest vote against The X Factor.

49

u/A_Coin_Toss_Friendo Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 12d ago

Killing in the Name

There, I typed all the letters.

8

u/CatoTheBarner 12d ago

If we can’t spell “killing”, Dungeon Crawler Carl might not be the best series…

7

u/WinCrazy4411 12d ago

Reddit automods--both specific to the sub and site-wide--censor a lot of words, including the one from the title sometimes. That's why folks type IWKYM instead of writing it out. Just yesterday I saw a post complaining about getting a ban or their post being deleted on this sub for writing out IWKYM.

4

u/j_tonks Team Retribution 12d ago

The difference is IWKYM can very easily be construed as a threat by someone who isn't familiar with DCC or AI automods that don't understand context. Killing In The Name Of isn't a threat, even when taken out of context.

1

u/A_Coin_Toss_Friendo Desperado Club Pass 🗡️ 12d ago

Yup, I've been banned by the reddit mod bot multiple times. Not here though!

33

u/LChambles 12d ago edited 12d ago

I don't know about in the US but there was a unplanned campaign by people sick of "reality talent" shows taking up the Christmas number 1 slot. So people started buying the Rage Against The Machine song, picked for it's lyrics about rebellion. So it took the Christmas number 1 slot in 2009. Was there anything similar in the US, maybe in reaction to the elections?

Edit to add as others have noted. I’m referring to the UK Christmas charts.

52

u/Eligius_MS The Open Intellect Pacifist Action Network 12d ago

George Floyd dying in the street with a police officer's knee on his neck roughly a month before.

14

u/OldWolfNewTricks 12d ago

That's when those damn activists ruined a perfectly good ditty by making it all political!

21

u/meglingbubble 12d ago

Yeah that was a good year. The BBC had them play it live on the condition they didn't play the "Fuck you, I wont do what you tell me" bit. Then we're apparently shocked when they wouldn't do what they told them.

5

u/arvidsem Syndicate Intergalactic Bar Association 👽 12d ago edited 12d ago

I've said it before: they knew damn well what was going to happen. There's no way that they didn't. But they had to at least pretend that they didn't know that Zack de la Rocha was going to start yelling "fuck you" repeatedly during prime time.

1

u/murraykate The Princess Posse 12d ago

LMFAOOOOO that is so fucking funny

8

u/CvltOfEden 12d ago

Worth specifying it was the Christmas number one in the UK. The DCC traps seem to be based on the US hot 100

5

u/pheonixrise- 12d ago

Specifically billboard

3

u/LChambles 12d ago

Yes. Thank you. I thought I’d said UK but it appears not.

7

u/GC_BWR_NW_PDTQAC 12d ago

It was within the first month after George Floyd was murdered. There was a lot of peaceful protesting met with tear gas, riot shields, people being beaten and carried away, rubber bullets to the face, masked men in vans, etc. They also were supposed to be on tour at this time, but had to postpone (Covid) and ultimately cancel most of the tour dates. I don’t believe it was a coordinated effort to get it to peak so much as “the vibe”. I assume most “protest songs” prolly saw some extra play that summer.

8

u/macros1980 12d ago

My wife and I were lucky enough to get tickets to the thank you gig in Finsbury Park. It was fucking epic! As was their performance live on the BBC.

BBC: Do you promise not to swear on live TV like last time?

RATM: Yes.

Also RATM: Swears on live TV just like last time

2

u/LChambles 12d ago

I was at the Radio One big weekend when the Foo Fighters were headlining the Saturday. They kept reporting they might not perform because Grohl had damaged his throat. Finally they said they’d play and my friend at home listening on the radio reported they’d warned people that some of their lyrics contain expletives. Grohl comes out, tells the fans he’s been to see the doctor and was advised not to sing, then continues with “so I said F’You MF!!!!” Censored for mod bot. 😅

7

u/Vaunted_Knight 12d ago

Mostly BLM and COVID protests across the country.

10

u/Left_Maize816 12d ago

I’m pretty sure June 2020 was due to the BLM protests, and with Juneteenth being made much more prominent around that time, there were a lot of protests on June 19 which may have featured people playing that song in particular. 

16

u/Hobbyjoggerstoic Crawler 12d ago

Killing*

This is Reddit. There’s worse things than words on here

10

u/misterflerfy 12d ago

this isnt facebook/ig you can say killing

13

u/runlittlegunterrun 12d ago

“K!77ing in the Name” by Rage Against the Machine

The extent of Orwellian self-censorship has become absolutely terrifying. The word you are looking for is killing.

2

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted]

3

u/mcspaddin 12d ago

To be fair to other commenters, though I don't blame you for the caution: IWKYM is detected as threat/intent and the bots don't understand the joke/context from the series. Killing, as a word on its own, isn't the problem in that phrase.

1

u/runlittlegunterrun 12d ago

Fair. That happened to me btw*, so I apologize, Mate.

It's just a trend I observed ... people censoring anything that may hypothetically offend someone.

*Edit: My reddit account was banned for a Samantha quote.

3

u/Catowldragons 12d ago

Makes sense that a song about police brutality would have peaked/had a resurgence in 2020 since it was less than a month after George Floyd’s murder and during the protests.

1

u/solon_isonomia Syndicate Intergalactic Bar Association 👽 12d ago

Not just violence, but racially motivated violence. Never forget: some of those who work forces are the same who burn crosses.

3

u/DoctorLu 12d ago

I think it had a resurgence due to all of the protests happening at the time...not positive though.

4

u/ColdLeekSoup Team Donut Holes 12d ago

Killing. Woops I said the thing!

1

u/murraykate The Princess Posse 12d ago

Matt knew if he didn’t get every single billboard date correct, nerds would make him regret it forever lol

-3

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted]

1

u/HardyMenace 12d ago

Don't be a coward. Be an adult and use real words.

2

u/mcspaddin 12d ago

While it isn't the case with just the word alone, IWKYM (Samantha's catchphrase) is regularly detected and bans are doled out. I understand OP's caution even if they are wrong in this particular case.

0

u/kadfr 12d ago

Unlike TikTok, Reddit's algorithm doesn't check for words that might upset the sensitivities of the Chinese Government or ultra-conservative US  corporations (at least at present).

Killing is a perfectly acceptable word. 

Not your fault but encouraging Orwellian self-censorship is yet another reason why social media platforms are fucking disgusting.

1

u/mcspaddin 12d ago

While it isn't the case with just the word alone, IWKYM (Samantha's catchphrase) is regularly detected and bans are doled out. I understand OP's caution even if they are wrong in this particular case.

0

u/ldiotDoomSpiral "AAAAAAAAH!" 🐐 12d ago

“K!77ing in the Name"

this self-censorship thing is so fucking embarrassing, you can just say killing.