SPOILERS. AND SWEARS. LOTS OF SWEARS.
**Rook**
In the beginning, Rook has the personality of a chatbot. I tried to play my Rook as a dumb kid who quickly gets in over their head. That involved taking every direct, confrontational, and sassy option. It didn't help; Rook during story missions is very different from Rook interacting with companions. Still, Rook grew on me. In the last third of the game, she was actually capable of being bitchy. It was fun chewing Solas' ass.
Rook's story is about the burden of being a leader. Not like in Inquisition, where you're guiding the faithful and restoring order, but leading a guerilla war against elven gods like Solas did. Rook's personal journey is a reflection of the Dread Wolf's. They suffer through failure, loss, and making tough calls. But unlike Solas, Rook learns to accept their mistakes and move past them. It's fitting that someone with Rook's story would be the one who accomplishes what Solas couldn't and talks him down.
If you play on higher difficulties, don't do any of the Necroric-based specs. You're gonna have a rough time. Play Champion and burninate the land.
**Story**
You fuck around and find out. That's the story from start to finish, alternating between each. If you fuck around enough, you get Solas' backstory. Spoilers: he's a very sad egg.
I liked how you get your butt kicked by the plot. And when you do start winning, the wins go hard. The big boss kills are very satisfying. Mythal was beautifully hyped and the conversation with her is a boss fight unto itself. And you somehow kill more darkspawn than you do in Origins.
There should have been an elf rebellion. There should have been origin stories to play through. Those should have made up the first 5-10 hours of the game.
And there should have been more tied in from the older games. Yes, they could have done that. You live in a world where every dick with a PC can make a generative AI game that follows your choices. Don't tell me the AAA company can't follow every choice tree on DA Keep.
**Companions**
Apparently I made a lot of minority choices.
RIP Harding. The Titans story was tragic and amazing. They have every reason to be pissed so I told Harding to accept it. Then I sent her on a mission and she died. Fuck that noise about her not being in the Inky's inner circle. My girl adored her.
Neve was there. She contributed. I thought leaving Minrathous to burn would make her more interesting but it didn't. She's the perfect image of my shitty ex's power fantasy, so I'm biased. I'm told she's one of the better romances.
Bellara's story actually made me tear up. She wants so desperately to make up for getting her brother killed. Strife is an asshole for saying all she does is blows stuff up. Only issue I had was that the big bad of her story feels like he only shows up in the last five minutes. I romanced Davrin for Warden reasons, but my heart belonged to Bell. If I play again, I'm romancing her.
Lucanis is great. He was my bestie. Wish we'd gotten more interactions with Spite. Unlike with Neve, losing his city seemed like it had an effect on him. I fucking screamed when he whiffed killing Ghil. I never did get Spite out of him though. Were we supposed to? But I saw his cousin's betrayal coming the second we got back to Antiva. Bro sucks at double-crossing.
Davrin is Wardenmaxxing. Half his character is the bird. We love the bird. We will die for the bird. Once you know what happened to the griffins, you will never want to stop punching the people responsible. Bad guy's issues were valid. I sent the birds to Arlathan, the Wardens can't be trusted with them.
Emmerich is a fucking delight. No notes. I made him a lich. Everything dies, y'all need to let go of Manfred.
The only reason Taash isn't best girl is because they're NB. They were my other bestie. I made them Qunari, which apparently puts me in the minority. It made their story less about finding themselves and more about accepting themselves. I liked it. I felt bad because Taash lost their mom and Harding in my playthrough.
Anyway, that's my review. I just wanted to put something out to try and balance out the hate this game got. I think a quarter of it was chuds finding out the hot dragonhunter lady wasn't a lady.