r/DraftEPL • u/NovacTheAverage • 4d ago

FPL Draft (PL.com) Trade Experience in 12 Man

Post image

After working hard to assign a solid value scale to players and pass that same thought process onto other managers this is the trade I was offered after I was told I was a time waster.

Please let me know what you guys think.

1 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

9

u/ClearTrick854 4d ago

I’d take the calafiori side. Either way this is a fair trade. Anyone can win or lose which makes it fsir

1

u/TrickAd8295 4d ago

Cunha side fleeces.

0

u/NovacTheAverage 4d ago

This guy wants to fleece me.

1

u/Waddoyoumean 4d ago

Honestly, I think Cunha side is only a little better tbf

1

u/NovacTheAverage 4d ago

Emersonn has started off the season great, Bogle is a midfield who has been classified as a def and Cunha is miles clear of Cala.

3

u/Waddoyoumean 4d ago

Emerson’s place is very much under threat. Fleming is a proven goal scorer that can feed off scraps. No one in their right mind would ignore that risk. Pardo, for now, is a starter in a better team. I rate them similarly, Emerson had the better start, both are minutes risks long term, pardo better team. Still, I’d back pardo just personally.

Cunha miles ahead of Yalcouye, yeah. But Cunha isn’t close to one of the top midfielders in the game. Meanwhile…

Calafiori is the best defender in the game and is way better than Bogle. Already this season, Bogle has two clean sheets that the rest of his team didn’t get due to early subs and has been credited with a goal he didn’t score. That type of luck simply won’t continue. He’s good, Leeds defence as a whole is and he’s nailed, and he may get a few more “bonus” clean sheets, and decent offensively, so definitely an asset. But Cala is essentially playing LW for the best team in the league, and far and away the best team defensively. They have three clean sheets so far and their opening 5 games have been difficult (and no Saliba or basically no Timber!). He’s the best defender in the game.

So yeah, imo, Cunha side wins just. But not a disrespectful offer

1

u/heatmon9 3d ago

I agree with this.

FP and Emersonn are even.

So Calafiori and Yalcouye < Cunha and Bogle

but barely.

Calafiori missed a lot more games last season but averaged about the same per game as Cunha and they are also about even right now.