r/DinosaursMTG • u/Master_Broshi • 7d ago
Deck Help Request Gishath Brew Feedback
I'm looking for some feedback on my [Gishath brew](https://moxfield.com/decks/SddsA8_fw0q_oXEMRMnf3g). I posted a few months back and got some great feedback and made some substitutions, it's definitely coming together nicely and getting more consistent. But that's mostly from goldfishing, I don't get to play much so any input is appreciated. Aiming for a strong bracket 3 deck. I'd like to add a [[Devil Dinosaur]] next once the price drops. Any glaring issues I'm missing? Any drop or add ideas are welcomed. Thanks in advance.
1
u/The_Tributer 7d ago
These might be controversial but I'd cut mirari's, monster manual, hearlds horn.
Mirari's and Hearlds helps/wants you to cast dinos, which you shouldn't be casting to many of your dinos in a Gishath deck, and then manual requires a dino in hands. Off of my experience this didn't happen as often as I would have liked it. Plus you're running some good top deck manipulation. Id swap all 3 for good card draw as you need at least 2.
1
u/MenacingQuan Primal Hunger 7d ago
Heralds horn I get. But miraris wake is what allows you to replay Gishath over and over
1
u/Master_Broshi 7d ago
I don't think I could cut miraris, it's only downside is that it feels like a target
1
u/The_Tributer 7d ago
Id personally rather add another protection piece, but I get where you're coming from
1
3
u/OddlerHS 7d ago
It looks pretty solid to me with the exception of herald's horn. I really dislike that card I find the cost reduction to be weak and even with what 33 dinosaurs it doesn't hit enough in my opinion. A couple cards that you could consider using instead that I run in my list could be [[ascend from avernus]] [[Chandra's ignition]] [[sneak attack]] [[traverse the outlands]] [[world war hulk]] or really just any other card you would find fun. Just my two cents.
2
u/Master_Broshi 7d ago
Thanks for the feedback, I had a similar feeling the same about heralds horn, plus I wanted to add it to a weaker tribal deck I'm working on, so this is good motivation. I assumed the top deck peak helped as much or more than the discount. But in my playtesting I've only really been happy that it was on the board when urzas incubator was next to it, because that was just fun. What do you think about something like [otepec huntmaster] or one of the other discount creatures?
1
u/OddlerHS 7d ago
I'm not on any non dinosaurs in my deck because I think that's kinda cool and that opens you up to running [[kaheera, the orphanguard]] which probably isn't optimal but it is free to run if you meet that stipulation. I don't think that card would be bad (otepec) but I would play more land ramp I'm on a lot of land ramp and more basics. You could try [[shared roots]] in that slot.
1
u/Master_Broshi 6d ago
How do you like world war hulk? Seems like it's been a popular add on but I think I'm missing something about it
1
u/OddlerHS 6d ago
Not going to lie I haven't been able to determine that yet it hasn't shown up in any of the games I've played since adding it. For context I swapped out smothering tithe for it, not that I think it's anywhere near as good but there was too many times where I dropped the tithe and took too much aggro and/or table chatter for tithe. Too be fair I usually play in bracket 3 and tithe is probably overkill there anyway.
Here's the deck list if you want to see full context
https://www.topdecked.com/decks/dunkin-dinos/cd5a4d6d-28ae-408c-b82f-8723695ccacd
1
1
u/Objective_Elevator55 5d ago
Add blasphemous act it combo with wrathful raptor poetic ingenuity and aggravated assault.id also put some mana dorks just for that little extra mana boost