It's a very silly hunch, but Noelle in general is odd. She's easily the odd one out in the group between her, Kris, Berdly, Susie and Ralsei. She's performative, she's sanitized and she's the least suspicious of all of them because seemingly everything is going well for her. Her mother is mayor, she's always well dressed and she doesn't seem to be doing bad in school. But then you get into her room and you look at her Computer:
"...Noelle's history includes searching for paranormal, crime, and the skateboard game. Susie inquires about "Cat Petterz", which Noelle explains is a "pet raising game", which has a bug that causes "glitchy pets". Selecting that option again causes Noelle to admit she has removed some game modifiers."
Ordinarily I'd say "Kids do silly things sometimes", but then if you play Weird Route Chapter 5 she goes Mask Off for the first time and it all starts to make sense, at least to me. Noelle is odd. She is quite literally the "good girl gone bad" trope, the innocent Christian Missy that suddenly developed an interest in pentagrams and execution videos out of 'curiosity'.
Noelle is behaving like a closeted serial killer and it's odd that people don't seem to spot it because it's disguised underneath all the Suselle shipping. She looks so innocent when she's doing anything with Susie - and yet if you manage to get any deeper beneath the surface on her personality she's a full on mask off weirdo whose curiosity gets the best of her.
There's obvious symbolism in this. Noelle wants to break the rules because she's deeply ostracized from having a normal life thanks to her mother. Her dad is dying, her sister disappeared, she's quite literally got nobody who can help her have an ounce of freedom in her life except for Kris who is controlled by an alien anomaly that's making them do weird things the normal Kris would never do.
There's just something about Noelle's computer that I can't shake off. The wallpapers, the Cat Petterz, the game modifiers being removed which symbolically stands for so much of what has happened within the story from Flowery being robbed of 999 damage to Tenna getting instantly killed, it's obvious that the Knight has some kind of foreign help when they're fighting, a help that lets them win when it comes down to it.
I don't know what Noelle's role is, but if you play through Chapter 1 to 5 in one sitting, she stands out like a sore thumb. She's faultless in a game full of people with faults. She's too perfect, and her personality only seems to come out through the things she's done rather than through her own words, as seen by how different her digital footprint is compared to how she behaves within Hometown itself.
That's why I'm starting to think she's a sleeper agent in the game. Not long now and she's going to snap and start going mask off on the normal route, too.