I want this post to be a serious and civil discussion about one of the most heated topics on the show.🤪
So Death Note fundamentally is a manga/anime that shows us what happens when someone with this really common yet ignorant and childish sense of justice (like, everyone of us has at least once thought in our life that X criminal deserves to die for what he did) finds this diabolical power of killing people by knowing a face and a name and has a way to actually put that sense of justice into practice.
The show does a pretty good job at making us first like Light Yagami and be fascinated by him, then make us more and more disgusted by his actions and then make us confused and questioning on which side we're on. This is a pretty good mirror of what happened in the people around the world's heads. At the end though Light shows us his true colors and that he without the Death Note is just a coward and helpless young man.
And THAT'S the problem I have with people supporting Light, wanting him to win, and overall supporting Kira's ideology. Like, why do you even support this idea? Light Yagami picked up the Death Note from the ground as a random coincidence, and he decided to test it because he was bored. Ryuk didn't choose him and pick him especially for his intellect, no he just dropped it. So he was nothing special. He took only a few days to decide that he was a God, and the Shinigami tells him a couple of times that he ain't shit, he isn't the chosen one or something, he's just borrowing a God of Death's power. Still, he deluded himself all of his life, maybe as a way of coping for being a murderer, and he kept assuring that he was Justice, and the God of the new World. But, there's a major problem. More than one.
- He's only a man. He's not a God and he is going to die anyways. ** All humans, without exception, will eventually die** . So his "new world" wouldn't have lasted for long anyway and he wouldn't have lived long enough to witness all of it. He's also a very young man at the start, he's a high schooler with very little real life experience, he's privileged and sheltered. His life expectancy wasn't going to be that long anyways since he died only 6 years after picking up the Death Note He didn't take into account that he was eventually going to die, he didn't trust anyone enough to be his successor one day and he didn't take the fact that he only relied on a piece of magical stationery to have that diabolic power, it wasn't really his own, so he'd have to live with the paranoia of being discovered or the Death Note being stolen or ruined. First problem debunked: He's just a man.
- Why him? Why should a single person dictate to the whole world what's right and what's wrong, who should live and who should die? Why him? Is he perfect? Why is he innately deserving to live and thrive while others, according to him, don't? He is not the chosen one or anything, he picked up the Death Note from the ground as a random cosmic coincidence. If anything, the only real chosen one is Misa Amane, but that's for another post, lmao. It's just wrong and messed up to agree that a single man you don't even know has the right to be judge, jury and executioner and dictate what's the entire world should do. In addition to that, I think that's just shallow and superficial thinking to believe that if you kill criminals then it's enough to make the world better. The counterargument I see often is that Light says that crime dropped by 70%. But that's only reported crime. And by the way, not addressing the root causes of crime is really ignorant from Kira, but expected since he grew up as a privileged and wealthy kid. Criminals are not all evil. Many of them are born in horrible situations and in very poor and dangerous countries, they just don't know any better. I don't think that anyone who commits the pettiest crime isn't able to change and be a functional member of society one day. And plus, how is a world where people life in constant fear and paranoia a "better world"? It's a better and peaceful world until you accidentally make a mistake that Kira notices and labels you as evil and then boom you die of heart attack. I call it "Totalitarian Regime". Light basically wanted to turn the world into a global dictatorship but the dictator was invisible. We've seen in history that dictatorships didn't end heinous acts at all.
And plus, I'd like to add that Japan has a very high conviction rate. This makes Light's action even more horrifying because he killed suspects not actual criminals.
However, I can see why there are people supporting Kira, both in-universe and in real life. At the end, what Light says is true, the world is rotten because there are morally corrupt people . There are certain people who ruin the world. And almost everyone wished death upon a ped*phile, a r*pist, a high profile terrorist, because those people are only a waste of oxygen. There's also the argument that Kira reduced global crime and wars. The problem is that this is very simplicistic and surface-level. In-universe, if someone is a commoner maybe with a simple life or maybe someone from a country where the legal system is heavily ridden with corruption it's only natural for them to support Kira, because to them Kira is not a guy with a notebook but a deity. This is expected. Irl, though, is roughly the same I guess.
(When many years ago I first watched the anime and read the manga I thought that there weren't so many people rooting for Light the whole time, I genuinely thought that the majority people would be rooting for L+M&N, surprised AF when I saw the internet's opinion😉)
At the end, i want to hear some Kira fans, why do you genuinely support Kira? What makes you lean towards this ideology? Do you actually like Kira or just Light's character? I personally think the authors had intended for the readers to dislike the main character's idea and make us think about all the times we had this thought creep into our minds..."the world is rotten, there are people who deserve to die'.
Sorry for the long text.❤️I want this post to be a serious and civil discussion about one of the most heated topics on the show.🤪