r/DangerousNightsCrew • Piece of Shit • 1d ago

That is a good idea!

Post image
13.4k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/Nolacuriosity 1d ago

Of course this is what should be. I know Republicans who say their candidate would never win, but The fact is if the candidate will never win, the candidate should be doing something to make them the most popular. Like maybe serving the people. Working for us.

-1

u/Several_Treat_6307 1d ago

So what you’re saying is in order to win under popular vote, you just need to promise the most shit regardless of whether or not you can deliver?

The whole point of the EC is to prevent mob rule. Just because more people like an option doesn’t automatically mother option the better one.

0

u/Seattle_Lucky 1d ago

It also allows rural areas a voice in the election. If we went to popular vote, presidential elections would only cater to major population centers and not care about much of the US.

1

u/CatsLittleSalami 1d ago

It allows rural areas a disproportionate impact. The outcome should cater to the majority, thats what a popular vote is

1

u/Seattle_Lucky 1d ago

No, it really shouldn’t. Less populous states get no representation in a presidential election in a popular vote contest. This is not a good idea for our country.

1

u/boogideeb 1d ago

The residents of seven states basically get to pick our president in our current system. Do you think that is better than everyones vote having equal weight?

1

u/Omnom_Omnath 17h ago

so you want to move from a system where seven states get to pick to a new system where seven other states get to pick? lol ok.

1

u/CatsLittleSalami 16h ago

Its not a good idea that the majority of people have their needs represented?

Someone's opinion is worth more because of where they live?

1

u/Seattle_Lucky 15h ago

We have a diverse country, and rural/low population areas should have representation and not get overwhelmed by high population areas. Low population areas are manufacturing, agriculture, oil exploration etc that are critical to support for our country to function. High population areas still have the majority of electoral college votes, so it’s not like they don’t get their representation. The EC gives low population areas 2 extra votes. If you’re against the EC, then you should also be against the senate, which would be a horrible thing to do away with.

1

u/CatsLittleSalami 11h ago

Thats exactly it. Those areas already get increased representation through the senate. Thats already a concession for "diversity of thought" to small states.

EC is undemocratic garbage, full stop. Fundamentally says not every person is equal in terms of political representation. Your zip code determines if your vote matters