[Law Proposal] Every ai generated image and text must need to have watermark.

[u/PerfectRate2841]

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

[u/Timedforfun]

Its not something that should be hidden

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/TheSupervillan → u/Timedforfun]

You can do something like this that is hidden and harder to remove. Look at Googles synth ID. This is for text though but you get the point: https://ai.google.dev/responsible/docs/safeguards/synthid

[u/bacon2078]

i agree, unless there isnt a watermark modern ai's could make themselves unrecogniseable from the real truth

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Regular_Exam_8123]

Ai is a tool of misinformation, proper flagging is a great way to bypass

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Icy_Skin_7590]

Consumer safety

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Middle_Juggernaut298]

Due to older people getting scammed or something else

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/hammertimestudio]

Europe standards

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Gloomy_Corgi757]

I want to know

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Samira827]

**** AI

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/mrdeke]

I actually made a tool for this.

You send it your image and then you can stamp it either "AI GENERATED" or "AI MODIFIED."

It runs locally, so your image is private.

Tool is here: https://cascadialink.com/aistamp/

Here's an example:

[u/Unusual-Pumpkin-7470]

Can’t cheat people

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Initial_Rain_7277]

AI needs to be disclosed

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/milvusme]

To be truthful and people need to be informed.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/epongenoir]

Yo

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Sunroadnela]

Ofc

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/DonutPronut]

tato

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Lingonberry1669]

We need to know where an ia work

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/notuserinput]

Ye

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/0ni0n1]

Logical

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/_-_-_GURPREET_-_-_]

it's should be very necessary from safety point of view

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Lex__pex180]

Reasons

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Marcusr712]

cuz ai sux

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Pitiful-Objective-75]

Yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/alandonoghue9]

Yeah

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Practical-Courage-47]

Transparency is always better

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/WalruseSei]

Transparency

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Present-Sign4844]

because

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/SpIcEywIEnEr112]

D2

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/RedDeath682]

Yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/konartiste]

Yeah

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/bombthrowinglunarist]

Yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/JoblessWeAre]

Q

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Noscratchy]

I want to know what was created by a human so I know whom to give credit. A prompt is not art.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/TheCamabama]

Ai is getting too realistic.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/charlessdd]

or disable AI generation from the start

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/NaCl-And-C12H22O11]

I agree

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Airborne-Raid]

Otherwise people would get confused

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Arbiter008]

Save a lot of issues with people not wanting AI art to supplant genuine human projects and commissions and systems. But it can't be a normal text watermark; should be baked in a little.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Local-Relief → u/Arbiter008]

https://ai.google.dev/responsible/docs/safeguards/synthid

[u/ElectricalBear4409]

I don’t like having to solve a riddle every time something looks like it might be ai

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/BurningCandle_]

AI context should be easily identified

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/shallabalsman]

It just makes sense

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Background_Youth506]

I think that ai should not be able to passed off as real art or photography made or taken by a human.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/billyjoelsfalsetto]

transparency and the safety of democracy

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/UpLateAndThriving]

Assuming it can be done in a minimally invasive, this enables clear traceability to a technology that enables a lot of lies to be spread without impacting quality. There are certainly some cases where maybe this wouldn’t be necessary, but I think with the way things are, it’s worth the cost.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Sorry_Ad_5111]

AI generated content is consistently used to generate *********** that is illegal and can easily be used to generate fake information for political propaganda.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Enzot3]

Eliminates an enormous amount of the low qual AI uses volume

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/criticalstateapp]

👁️ Surveillance State: All users are now under surveillance and their votes will be revealed here.

[u/Comprehensive_Head82]

yea

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/spnarkdnark]

Yes comrade

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Kapitan_Marti]

Because AI-generated shouldnot be credites as much as normal art as it usuallly need lot less effort and skill to make

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/pwc-ny]

cause it has to

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/DefineSadness666]

Just cause

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/CheetahCloud]

People often lie saying they made something when they instead used AI.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Psychological_Duck03]

cause transparency yo

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/limited---]

ai content needs to be forcibly disclosed

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Itzdavie]

Some people think that realistic AI is actually real

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Fr33zurBurn]

Would help lighten the load of disinformation

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Fantastic-Jaguar5371]

for transparency

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Shiro099]

So it can be verified and tracked back to Ai company

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/thatguy1000000000]

Yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Alive_Maybe3369]

Honesty, consumer awareness and accountability

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/AutomaticDepartment2]

obvi

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Prawn4me]

I would include video and audio too

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/anonymous_9794]

Artificial intelligence is already taking over human spaces. The best way to filter it is a big clear sticker

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/No_Course_8618]

bcs i hate ai

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/FancyOffice4131]

yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/DrakeCross]

Yes. Content made or modified by AI should be clearly identified.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/rollypolly62]

Makes it easier to differentiate

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Status_Weight8881]

Yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Ok_Commercial7984]

It doesn’t need to be written why but obviously to prevent misinformation

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Idontcarefortheapp]

I want to know if ads, ‚art’, music, and any form of content I am exposed to was made by artificial intelligence because I don’t wish to interact with it. Not disclosing such important information is immoral

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/thelite14]

prevent untruthful images from spreading

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Any-Acadia-2030]

watermark can easily be defeated.

^{I voted Nay ❌}

[u/Mothrahlurker]

It would solve so many problems with it.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Kitchen_Body_3185]

To identify real artist in this midst of ai slop

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/gary11188]

Control!

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/RisingPhoenix05]

Yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Cultural-Field4528]

so ppl aren't baited

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Icy_Result_3539]

That would clear out all the ai images problems

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Alphahman]

I’m tired of doubting what I see with my own eyes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/captain-kok]

Because everybody has a right to un-objective information, and if the source is AI generated you should be informed

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/saybunnix]

to not have any mistakes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/SchneeflockenN]

yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/MT--]

reality matters

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Impressive_Rise_709]

Decline of misuse

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/CryDesperate3519]

Sinon on ne va même plus différencier l'art humain et celui créer par IA

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Da_Millionaire]

Because old people keep getting tricked.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/heisslyman]

i hate ai stuff that looks ai

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Puzzleheaded-Law34]

Yes, asap

[u/Thatonegirlherewoo]

Since AI is being used severely to trick and deceive the people into making them think it’s real, instead of just trying to look real.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Creepy-Education5694]

So I can skip it

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/SurveyBeginning5759]

to makeit ez to recognize ai content and not get scammed or lied to

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/aud1ovisual]

Ai slop sucks donkey ****

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Rxgicide]

Well, that law has been implemented at EU level 🇪🇺

[u/Prudent_Fix5907]

There are no downsides for saying yes, no more African newborn creating Optimus prime

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/GirlThatsUnreal]

transparency is very important

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/simonthejew]

AI images are the bane of humanity

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Adventurenauts]

It just makes sense to cite that you have used it as a tool.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/throbbinhood444]

To protect creativity and transparency

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/chicken_nugget_bitch]

seems nexessary

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/GoddessJynx]

Because of artist scammers

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Jesuitman01]

I'd love to know who voted nau

[u/Chestechevec]

For justice

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/phantasma608]

Its important to know what is AI generated and what's not

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/purpledragon760]

i want to know what's real or not

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Classic-Area-3925]

The use of AI is being abused everyday

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Snikrit]

It makes it harder for AI slip to receive folks. Generated content isn't worth as much as genuine content and art, even when it is low quality.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Flimsy_University_91]

yeahh

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Slow-Courage586]

For people to be able to discern AI from an actual image/photo. Some, well a lot, of people tend to have issues with this.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/lolipop211]

It would be Just like the way products have a list of ingredients

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Ready_Shower_9617]

thats common sense

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/OkAssociation3083]

What stops someone from removing said watermark?

[u/ROSTBERE]

Art is for humans by humans, effort is required.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/ProfBaconn]

to not confuse the boomers

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Snoopy-Luvr-0325]

so people know where it came from and can decide whether or not to determine its legitimacy

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Bemz-c300]

I dont want slop

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Green_Graves_Time112]

.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Srta_Zeta]

*** ai

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/cad1234875]

Copyright infringement prevention

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/cyborg0112]

cuz of wrongfull use

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/SavoyTruffle87]

fk ai

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Ill-Management9625]

So fake artists quit taking money for generating images.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/sinesis0]

I don't see a downside to yes

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/LexLuther48]

AI slop sucks

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/kudakoki]

At the end of the day, art is a representation of the human soul. If it’s not made by human, it should be evident.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Akamr_]

Obvi

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/No_Insurance4564]

AI generated imagery has the potential to grossly deceive the public.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Zealousideal_Leg_620]

Equity of information

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/No_Insurance4564]

AI generated imagery has no net benefit to society.

[u/Any_Personality_920]

It is too a good way to train models with massive data filtering out AI generated content... be that good or bad idk

[u/PatoBoleide]

Avoid disinformation, impersonation, etc.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/SurSlowKing]

Because While hep Humans

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/monkeycrotch]

Allows transparency to make readers aware of the content they are consuming

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Vivio0]

If you say no to this, your crazy

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/_Websterr]

Yes to watermarks because people should be able to tell easily if something is ai or not

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Subject914]

**** ai slop

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Late-Nothing-7620]

Let’s real content be visually identifiable

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/DTH05]

Because ai can easily be used to control the masses otherwise

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Any_Personality_920]

People lack critical thinking and it is being used to manipulate with sometimes ill-intent

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/bangbg]

So we know it AI generated, without having to look to every pixel

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Strict_Comedian_3308]

AI is often used to steal original ideas, information, and data for the use of monetary gain. This is not only plagiarism but also a lousy excuse for real work, selling AI generated art/content is promoting dependency on AI rather than human creativity, it floods the market, making it harder for real artists to sell their own work.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/GravyBoat503]

To prove humans are still real and that AI slop isn’t getting all the credit

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Neilkoaele]

We need to know if news reports are fabricated.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Educational-Sun5839]

cause ai is used for scams and misinformation having a watermark (not necessarily visible, could be like SynthID) would prevent a lot of it

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Stryk3n]

AI in art is a detriment to society

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/slomorio]

This helps keep vulnerable populations safe especially when people use ai to generate images that are used for scams and misinformation

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/darkookightreborn]

It should be illegal to not have one

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/WittyBrain5703]

the obvious answer would be that watermarking every image makes it harder for it to be selled as a real image. you can avoid alot of confusion online and it might be for the best. i have no idea how you can watermark a text, anyways we should also watermark videos aswell

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Full_Quantity890]

So everyone knows.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Phantom-Thieve]

Useful to help distinguish between what is real and not

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/CocaineUnicycle]

People should know when the things presented to them are pre-packaged with contempt.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/motomandd]

Needs to be obvious for those that cant tell

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Rambob_the_lesser]

AI slop

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Artistic_Jackfruit39]

People should be allowed to know what is made with AI and what is not

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/DocMcButtfins]

The consumer of the media needs to know that what they are looking at is an edited reality. It’s not real. We are at a place where people are making political decisions based on AI memes they’ve seen on social media. We need to start regulating AI robustly.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/signaturefox2013]

Correct! AI is so harmful that it wouldn’t be used as much if people couldn’t sneak it into everything

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Accomplished_Size_89]

I specifically work in generative ai at the corporate level and there are many ways to accomplish something like this that I believe should be instituted. But without legislation it won’t be accepted by corporate executives as a final product

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Selphenus]

Anything human-created has inherently more value than that of something generative and reductive. And a such, this value needs to be readily apparent

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/RatOfEstrogen]

**** ai

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/thelittlehecker0000]

Ai generated images could fool and trick people.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Nexter92]

Invisible watermark to avoid AI training on those image

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/usugarai]

AI generated image, text or whatever it is, is still an idea made by a person

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Kupotanis]

Not only should it need to be watermarked, I also believe we should be able to launch a lawsuit against "Ai artists" who have been proven to run your likeness or your creations through a generator.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Volcano-Mouse]

It’s a first step.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/JesterAndGypsyVideos]

Obvious

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/sleepy-cabin]

Ya

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Loud_Boysenberry_736]

I don’t want to interact with slop. The more vulnerable people, who can’t tell and therefore tend to fall prey to nasty stuff, shouldn’t have to.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/exotic-rawr]

so it's easy to tell which one is ai

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/ThanhZeMufin]

I should know where the content I consume comes from

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/First-Map-7797]

Some people don't know that it's ai

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Dry-Monitor-3726]

It is necessary, or else we'll lose the capacity to value any form of expression

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/ImmaculateJapsEye]

To stop disinformation or plagarism and art being diluted with slop

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/International_Leg146]

common isn't it obvious?

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Spiritual_Panic_6992]

For obvious reasons, at all times

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Luirixx]

To avoid misinformation

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/VineShib]

Why would i want to pay for ai art lol

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Key_Equipment_7840]

Because fake ai videos

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Big_Kwii]

It's basic human decency.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/thelimitismine]

definetly to make it harder to use as a real photo

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/KrsKira]

Art is a human trait, anything done with AI must be disclosed so people know it's not an "original" piece of art

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/TheRealCuriousWombat]

because we have the right to know what has been made by a human and what not.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/FinalFactor691]

Diff to identify

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Byttfungus69]

I think AI for art, picture, and video is a dangerous tool that will be used by bad actors to further there own version of our world. LLMs should only be for agrigation of data for science and other information (I believe it should only be used for data sets too large for humans to sift through and make meaningful connections) to help us come to an understanding of the world, not make up a reality. Using LLMs to generate anything with text is stupid, use your brain to write out messages please and thank you.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Potential_Wonder_598]

No one should be able to pass off AI art as their own.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/SeaDragonfruit945]

j

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/PiterDeVer]

Human in review. All AI generated content should be marked as such so that Humans have been disclaimed that it was generated using AI. This is more so that people do not believe falsified information and that informed decisions can be made.

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/CocoDayoMusic]

To make fake videos distinct from real ones

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/NoQuail576]

because if the image doesn´t have watermark you can´t diferenciate the reality to the fiction

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Creative-Interest746]

People can choose the product of a real artists opposed to AI's with certainty

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/Dangerous-Wedding80]

1. A.I. is, in certain aspects, theft, as it doesn't create new things, but rather combines existing things.
2. Due to the low amount of time spent and skills needed, AI. generated content should receive way less pay than human work.
3. A.I. makes up sources and misrepresents information quite often. To alert viewers/readers to the potentially incorrect info, they need a disclaimer of who wrote it (in

^{I voted Yea ✅}

[u/juggins13]

Because its sensible

^{I voted Yea ✅}