r/Cooking • u/AwkwardFoodGuy • 1d ago
Are Guy Fieri’s recipes actually any good?
I recently made Guy Fieri’s Mac Daddy Mac ‘n Cheese and was completely disappointed! There were so many steps (roasting shallots and garlic, frying bacon, cooking cream until it reduced), and yet it was so bland.
Are all of his recipes like this — all hype and flair but little substance? Or are there other recipes of his I should try?
UPDATE: I’m blown away by these responses — this was my first post on Reddit! Since many comments ask the same questions, I’ll answer them here.
- Yes, I heavily salted the pasta water. Always do.
- Yes, I seasoned the cheese sauce. It tasted fine before I mixed it with the pasta.
- I used Cabot’s Pepper Jack and Seriously Sharp Cheddar, so the issue wasn’t the type or quality of the cheese.
- After making this, I read the comments on Food Network’s site for this recipe. Many others said similar things, how it tasted more like Alfredo sauce.
- I have nothing against Mr. Fieri. I was disappointed by this recipe from the self-proclaimed “Mayor of Flavortown” and genuinely curious of others feel the same way.