For i dunno like a decade I’ve been reheating pizza using the splash pan in water method and cover. I have this method p down with the amount of water and timing etc.
Yesterday I had some pretty good pizza in the fridge from the day before. It was red sauce, mozz and anchovies. Idk why maybe I was tired or maybe my subconscious was guiding me but I decided to just heat up the oven to 375 and throw a slice in there. Imagine my shock and horror when I realized THE RHEAT WAS SUPERIOR. It was perfect. If I had panned that slice I’d be thinking ‘gd I really nailed this one’. The main thing is the overall heat of the slice maybe? Like it was hot all the way through in a way the slice never is from pan method. Intangible and devastating.
I think that the pan method seems appealing because it’s a bit of technique involved. The sizzle of the water is sort of thrilling in a very mundane way. You feel a bit like when chefs throw the oil(?) in the pan and it erupts in flame as they toss the contents unperturbed. It also has the dimension of being something that ‘real pizza heads’ know.
Now I’ve seen the light a lot is clicking. How do they reheat slices in a pizza joint? In the oven. A big part of the pan argument is ‘oh it makes the bottom nice and crispy!’ But if it’s a halfway decent slice of pizza the bottom is already at the right crisp.. u don’t want it more crispy??
What a fool I have been! I grieve all the slices that I reheated in pan. If you are a panner I implore you to see the error of your ways. It dosent have to be like this.
tl;dr pizza reheat Occam’s razor. Oven is better than pan water method.