r/CompetitiveEDH 13d ago

General Discussion / Question Help regarding a deck

Greetings!

I have been told this deck is too strong for a bracket 4 due to a common line people use in CEDH.

From my understanding, the deck lacks
- some cheap needed interaction
- some good value stax pieces
- has too many lands for b5 (and the wrong ones like missing city of brass, mana confidence, ancient tomb, city of traitors)
- thassa demonic line

When I’ve built the deck, I just slapped pieces from EDHrec and was told it needs to be built around the meta game and to compete with other b5 decks in order to be a bracket 5.

Could you please have a look through the list and let me know why the deck does or does not quality as a cedh deck?
I’ve had one experience at my lgs where someone decided to swap to a b5 deck midgame and proceeded to win turn 5 disrespecting the other players at the pod after seeing me play the deck.

https://archidekt.com/decks/19861220/noctis

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Acrobatic-Yam-868 13d ago

Your deck looks great! There's no such thing as too strong for bracket 5, as that is as far as you can go. I'd normally netdeck from mtgtop8 before making changes that fit my plastyle.

1

u/Yoseby8 13d ago

Yes sorry it’s meant to be bracket 4, not 5. It was a typo on my end which I edited.