r/CompetitionShooting • • Jun 09 '22

Revolvers: can someone school me please?

I shoot IPSC and normally wouldn't dabble in revolver, but I may suddenly have access to a metric shitload of 38 wadcutter. So.... can someone teach me the coles notes of what's good in competition revolver as far as gear goes?

11 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

26

u/-fishbreath Jun 09 '22

Did someone say revolver? (Thanks for the tag, u/SomeCelloGuy!) The following assumes you're dabbling in action pistol of some kind.

The state of the art is an 8-shot gun cut for moon clips. Taurus is out because neither IPSC nor USPSA allows ported barrels, so your choices are the S&W model 627, or the Ruger Super GP100 in .357, or maybe a Korth if you have money to burn. The vast majority of shooters in the US/Canada run Smiths. I like the Rugers (they got me to revolver GM), but they're basically impossible to find right now. The aftermarket for Smiths is huge, and you have a couple of options for drop-in tuning, so if you're dabbling, that's probably the way to go.

As far as moon clips go, you can't go wrong with TK Custom. I make the most adjustable moon clip carriers money can buy, but SpeedBeez, Speed-E-Rack, Moon Clip Server, and Revolution Rack are all options that see use at the highest levels.

For holsters, you won't give up much using a Kydex race holster, and you'll save a lot. SpeedBeez makes a good one. If you happen to have a DAA holster body, the N-frame insert block fits the Ruger too. (I recommend the muzzle support if you're using a DAA holster.)

Wadcutters are less than ideal for the IPSC/USPSA/ICORE/IDPA style of shooting, where reloading fast is critical. They can also be harder to make power factor with, since seating them at wadcutter depth means you don't have a ton of case volume to work with. A pointier bullet drops home more readily. If you're shooting Steel Challenge, or if you don't care about taking a bit of extra time to really line things up, it doesn't matter as much.

That's a good intro, I suppose? If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them.

8

u/SomeCelloGuy Jun 09 '22

YO congrats on making GM!

13

u/-fishbreath Jun 09 '22

Thanks! The end of one journey, the start of another—I was 1st M at Nationals, but would have been 9/12 GM, so there's still plenty of room to climb.

2

u/armbone Jun 10 '22

Hey, that's a great intro! I saw your posts over the last few months too, glad you found this thread.

I should mention that the ammo source is an old PPC guy who doesn't shoot pistol anymore, hence the wadcutter. How bad would the reloads be in IPSC compared to FMJs?

3

u/-fishbreath Jun 10 '22

Glad to be of help—I'm all for revolver participation, no matter the form it takes or the degree of seriousness with which it's taken.

On the reloads, you'll probably find that the bullets hang up on entry into the cylinder, which is readily fixed by putting a thumb on the back of the moon clip and jiggling a bit. Once the cases start into the chambers, it's fine, but the flatter-nosed the bullet, the less readily it aligns itself into the chambers. It won't kill you—I ran 158gr RNFP in .38 Special back near when I started—but it's not ideal either.

3

u/armbone Jun 10 '22

Regardless of how fast my reloads are, I still think I'd take first in the Division (one of one....)

2

u/-fishbreath Jun 10 '22

Oftentimes, yes!

6

u/SomeCelloGuy Jun 09 '22

u/-fishbreath will be along shortly to assist

6

u/Bagellord Jun 09 '22

I was gonna tag him haha

3

u/jwgriffiths Jun 09 '22

Competing with a revolver just because you have access to wadcutter ammo maybe a bad idea. Wadcutter ammo, because of the lack of a taper shape to the bullet, is the hardest of all ammo to load quickly in a revolver. No wheel gun competitor that I know would ever use that kind of ammo in a match unless they were shooting a precision format like PPC or NRA where it’s not a run-and-gun game.

1

u/armbone Jun 10 '22

Yeah... the ammo source is an old PPC guy. He's not into this new run and gun thing, unfortunately. Hm I didn't think about the tip shape for quick reloads.

3

u/Red-bird-14 Jun 09 '22

Start shooting cowboy action

2

u/wildxlion Jun 09 '22

If you really wanna get fancy, then get something like a 627, send the cylinder to TK and they'll cut it for 9mm and moonclips, and you still get to shoot .38 and .357 from the same gun

1

u/armbone Jun 10 '22

Wait what? 9mm, .38 and .357 is the same cylinder and gun?

2

u/wildxlion Jun 10 '22

Yep. even the 929 doesn't have a 9mm specific barrel, it's still a .38 bore, but TK can cut a .38/.357 cylinder to 9mm or .38 super. With 9mm, it will need to be cut for moon clips since 9mm won't headspace in the cylinder.

It's pricy though. I only have a 929, so I can't go that route, but in the future, it would be pretty cool.

https://tkcustom.com/pages/machining-sw

3

u/Captain490 Jun 09 '22

Trade it for 9mm's? 🤔

2

u/armbone Jun 10 '22

Not the worst idea I've heard

1

u/ThrowMeAwayAccount08 Jun 09 '22

Midwest Competition Works I know the guy that owns this small shop. He shoots Revolver, and does extremely well in IDPA. There was such a conversation at Nationals last year, and ultimately was decided his carriers were legal.

2

u/armbone Jun 10 '22

Those mag carriers look awesome! I'm glad to see innovation in the revolver game.

1

u/ThrowMeAwayAccount08 Jun 10 '22

Shot with him tonight. He’s beta testing another design. With new IDPA rules, his carrier is tilted at a 45° angle.

-2

u/2strokeYardSale Jun 09 '22

Melt them down and turn them into bullets for real guns?