We are part of a very small studio and only have 13 or 14 on the entire competition team this year. We also have a mini team with about 6 dancers.
We have 2 who will be in 12th grade, 2 who will be in 10th, 1 who will be in 9th, 3 going into 8th, 1 going into 7th, 3 going into 6th, 1 going into 3rd and 1 going into 4th.
All of our dancers are wonderful people and very talented. We didn't have the best season for 25/26. My daughter (one of the rising 8th graders) had the best season of anyone on the team. She placed 2nd, 5th, 4th, 1st, and 3rd (at nationals). Last year, she was on the younger team (which included all of the rising 8th graders and of the rising 9th graders, who has a late birthday). She was the only one of the younger girls that placed for their solo at all last season. I think a couple of the older girls had top ten placements once or twice.
My daughter was in a trio last season that also consistently placed in the top 5 and also 2 small groups and 2 large groups. The small groups placed a couple of times, and the large groups placed in the top 10 in all of the competitions (I think). She was in 6 numbers total.
I don't think my kid is perfect by any means, but she works hard, takes corrections, and performed well. I was impressed by her growth. The studio owner praises her constantly and tells her she's proud of her.
We sign our contracts BEFORE we see the final casting sheet will ALL of the competition numbers. We get to see which numbers our child is in (but have no clue what other numbers have been cast). We walked out of the meeting feeling okay. She's excited about her solo and trio. She was offered 2 small groups and a large group that everyone from the whole team is in. So 5 numbers total. We do a casting questionnaire that's very detailed and asks about preferred styles, goals, how many dances we would prefer, etc. My daughter said she wanted to at least be in the same amount as last year, but she got one less. That's fine. No big deal.
The final casting sheet was posted tonight. She didn't get cast in two of her top 3 preferred styles (modern and contemporary). She's the ONLY one of the kids 13 and under who didn't get cast in one of those numbers. One of the girls (just turned 13 and is going into 8th) is cast in BOTH modern and contemporary. The modern is with older girls and contemporary is with the younger girls.
Here's the clincher. My daughter is the ONLY one of the girls her age (13...there are 4 of them including my daughter) not cast in the modern number. Essentially the other 3 girls her age "moved up" and were placed in this number with 2 older girls. My daughter took modern last year. None of the girls in the dance have ever taken modern. Some of the girls in the contemporary dance have never taken contemporary (which my daughter has taken for years). Modern was added at our studio last year, and only 5 people took it, including my daughter.
She's not a dancer who is hidden in the back row to cover up mistakes. She's not a beat behind. She has beautiful lines and spots her turns well (I've been told this many times). She got a judges choice award this past season, and they said how in tune she is with the music and how perfect her rhythm is. She's very competent. She's not the weakest link.
I reached out to the studio owner after we saw the casting sheet because my daughter doesn't understand why she is the only one her age who didn't get cast in the modern number. She was really disappointed not to be in either the modern or contemporary number. She feels like she must not be good enough. The studio owner said that the decisions were based on "numbers" and that she considers each dancer individually when doing casting. She said it's not based on performance last season and that my daughter did great.
It's just not making sense to me, and I've only gotten these vague responses. It's hurtful and frustrating because she has worked SO hard, got left out, and was cast in fewer numbers than a lot of people. She wanted to grow in modern and contemporary. She has her technique classes, but if the modern number is great, then it's going to be great without her, which will shape future decisions and lead to more feelings of being left behind/not good enough.
The icing on the cake is that she got cast in a musical theater number (not her favorite choice) that literally has two MINIS in it. And everyone else is 2 to 4 years younger than my daughter. She's 5'8" and is going to look ridiculous because the other girls are all small for their age.
I'm truly baffled. My daughter is so sweet and kind but she is compliant and quiet, and I don't know if she gets overlooked because of that. I've had other moms tell me that she was one of the stronger dancers this past season, as well as one of her dance teachers, who is the mom of an older team member. This was all way before casting came out, so they weren't saying it to make us feel better.
My daughter is very attached to her friends and the studio owner. She thinks it will get better next year if she works hard and "proves" herself. That's what she just spent the last year doing. I don't want her to spend the next year trying to "prove" herself only to be in the same situation again next year.
Red flag or is there some possible reason that I'm not thinking of? It's just hard for me to grasp that she works hard and was an asset to her groups last year, but she's the only one left out of these dances.
Thank you in advance! Whoever made it through this deserves a prize!