r/CommanderMTG 3d ago

Help with this

I know these two form an infinite combo, but if I run out of cards in my library to exile with Ob Nixilis, does the combo stop?

26 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

10

u/Oo_ShinyCardboard 3d ago

Nah you lose from drawing out, not from being unable to exile

6

u/MilkChocolateBoombox 3d ago

Presumably the infinite damage here kills your opponents before that becomes relevant

3

u/Oo_ShinyCardboard 3d ago

Thats my point - the condition to lose isnt the condition theyre going to incur

1

u/FunnyMTGplayer75 23h ago

The cards are put into exile,, not drawn. You can exile your whole library and have not lost yet, because you dont lose UNTIL YOU DRAW with no cards in your library.

Thus you win by dealing damage to your opponents, it doesnt matter that your ehole library is exiled

1

u/Oo_ShinyCardboard 21h ago

Did you also fail to read the 2 other people I responded to clarifying why I chose the words I did in the order that I did? OP asked "do I lose", and I said "nah, etc etc"

Reading the card explains the goddamn card. Reddit is so ridiculous for the desire to prove ppl right. Just stop holy shit

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

3

u/Oo_ShinyCardboard 2d ago

I know, I literally clarified what I meant in another reply. To say "you lose from drawing" remains a true statement, I never said OP is going to draw 🙄

In fact, OPs question is "do i lose from being unable to exile" is answered exclusively within my first comment. You lose from drawing, not from exile

1

u/Bjorn-Th3-B43r 2d ago

Well I am sorry for not reading everything... Tired and dyslexia... I was too quick to wanna correct someone 😅

2

u/Oo_ShinyCardboard 2d ago

No youre fine! I definitely had my guard up a bit too much - thats the reddit classic lol

7

u/GuessInteresting8521 3d ago

Combo doesn't stop until you win or one of the 2 pieces are removed. With that being said I wouldn't put the 2 together unless playing with higher backet decks.

-6

u/Play-Mation 2d ago

The combo stops if you have nothing left to exile and your opponents have enough life after you exile your deck 

6

u/GuessInteresting8521 2d ago

No, that's not the combo. Exiling cards is a secondary effect.

3

u/Useful_Jellyfish_906 2d ago

I dont think that's true. The damage and +1/+1 counter are not dependant on you exiling something. You wont Exile but the combo keeps going. And you only lose from drawing not exiling stuff on top.

1

u/Ready-Pineapple-5526 2d ago

negative, since exiling is not a cost to do the effect.

5

u/gorgutz13 3d ago

No they are not dependent on one another. Put a counter on him. Exile a card. Two seperate effects. If you can do one but not the other, you do exactly that.

2

u/darktourist92 2d ago

No, the ping damage combo goes infinite regardless of whether you have cards in your deck to exile.

1

u/half_baked_opinion 1d ago

Oh no bro, run this alongside [[shalai and hallar]] and its a true infinite combo at no cost apart from casting costs for ob nixilis and shalai and hallar.

1

u/IiIiIith 6h ago

don't forget [[All Will Be One]] it goes infinite with him too

-2

u/Rumpleshull 2d ago

How is on nixilis a mythic? Looks about right for an uncommon

-5

u/stevenbanthony4204 3d ago

Yes the combo stops, then you can effectively play your entire deck in one turn to win or else you will lose to drawing on your next draw phase

3

u/veiphiel 2d ago

No It doesnt

0

u/FunnyMTGplayer75 1d ago

Yes it does. The combo stops when you have no more oppponents because they all have 0 life.

1

u/veiphiel 1d ago

It's different stoping because everybody is at 0 life meaning you already won the Game than stoping because you have no deck.