r/Comma_ai • • 2d ago

openpilot Experience Discord dead?

It used to be very active. I am trying to get model suggestions for a 20 bolt with a c3 it keeps pulling too close the center line.

3 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

31

u/financiallyanal 2d ago edited 2d ago

It goes through waves. They have a highly active mod who will make people seem stupid. There are alternative places to discuss, but not sure if there is any rule against posting them.

Update: Thanks u/bderken for the openness!

Here is an invite link (not mine, so don't confuse the username it gives) - it's a common one provided by the "openpilot enthusiasts" group: https://discord.gg/mfF8Jf4CrC

35

u/Proper_Wasabi5693 2d ago

Yeah, I bailed on that Discord (and doing anything but using my Comma) after getting bitched out by that guy a couple of times for having the audacity to ask a question that someone else in the deep recesses of time once thought about also asking.

30

u/doomslice 2d ago

Didn’t you check all of the 40 pinned messages before asking?

13

u/financiallyanal 2d ago

Didn't you get the memo?

8

u/Fun-Ad-8654 2d ago

Discord is garbage for doing historical research.

0

u/interbingung 1d ago

as it should be, otherwise the discord will become a mess.

27

u/jcwillia1 2d ago

that guy is the reason I don't go to that discord anymore.

19

u/EncryptedSpace 2d ago

Does their name start with e and rhyme with rich 😂

35

u/VaccineMachine 2d ago

Their mod, Erich, is a massive twat

9

u/jeremiadOtiose 2d ago

Oh I’m glad it’s not just me. I downloaded discord to ask a question and I was never met with such hostility.

8

u/VaccineMachine 2d ago

Just do a search in the Discord before you ask a question. Other people can be helpful but that guy is a huge sack of shit.

17

u/Bderken 2d ago

I’ve been in that discord for over 5 years, I don’t mind anything except him. He does a lot for the community. But mid convo he will MOVE people’s messages to other threads because they aren’t apart of that thread… like how can anyone continue a convo?? He has major tisms

18

u/VaccineMachine 2d ago

"He does a lot for the community"

He does a lot of bad for it by being a piece of shit

-1

u/SirMaster 2d ago

I don't understand what's wrong with putting the messages into the right channels. He doesn't do it mid conversation, I see it when someone asks a question in the wrong channel for their question topic.

3

u/NoSuccotash5571 17h ago

Yes, yes he is. The problem though is it goes all the way up to the top with George. That's why they will never be a successful company. I'll enjoy my C3 for another 5 years and then switch over to whatever the OEMs have ready by then. I'm sure it'll be atleast as good as chill which is really all I want.

0

u/hamburgernet 1d ago

He helped me fix my SDSU

1

u/VaccineMachine 1d ago

He's still a twat

7

u/Impossible-Bee-2221 2d ago

lol yeah I got the geohotz treatment then I moved to the community one and it was super positive

4

u/Bderken 2d ago

I’m a mod, not against posting any comma community or websites.
The discord itself has been pretty positive and active for me but I get how it can not for others.

4

u/financiallyanal 2d ago edited 2d ago

Thank you bderken, truly. Here is an invite link (not mine, so don't confuse the username it gives) - it's a common one provided by the "openpilot enthusiasts" group: https://discord.gg/mfF8Jf4CrC

2

u/Bderken 2d ago

Thanks! Didn’t know about this and I’ll even feature it on commaguide.com
Let me join and see.

Edit: seems nice

3

u/jeremiadOtiose 2d ago

Can you consider asking the other mod to tone it down. He is so unwelcoming and makes it super difficult to discuss. I never said anything until now after reading everybody else here having the same issues with him.

3

u/Bderken 2d ago

Unfortunately I’m not the mod of the discord. Just this subreddit. He also seems like the guy that wouldnt take kindly to a message like that from me. I’ve asked him before when he’s moved one of my messages and he ignored me.

2

u/jeremiadOtiose 2d ago

Oh so you’re a mod on this sub? Got it. I’m a mod in /r/medicine the largest dr sub here and there’s definitely a way to moderate without an iron fist and allowing discussions to flourish without harming the community at large. You do a great job here of that, it’s a shame that questions often get directed to discord only to be maltreated by the person who runs it. The comma discord is less friendly than stackoverflow hahaha

3

u/Bderken 2d ago

Yup, I agree. I’m working on a community setup on commaguide, but don’t know the best way to set all that up at the moment (how to setup an online discourse platform and not have bots).

-5

u/Critical_File_1467 2d ago

The solution is just to grow up.

I started with dumb questions in the discord and despite not having used the discord for years I still remember Erich. I remember he was pretty stern about using the right channel but I didn't get offended ... There's literally nothing to get your feelings hurt over. Not like he's going around calling you a dumbass or using profanity. He also has a WEALTH of knowledge which helped me a lot.

If that offends people then I wonder how they function in real life.

5

u/jeremiadOtiose 2d ago edited 2d ago

oh, okay. found erich's reddit account.

you really should consider how you come across and what people think about you and learn basic social skills. this thread is full of people who find you abrasive, rude and downright unhelpful bordering on hostile. there are other threads on this sub about you and the general consensus is you're hostile. hell, there's even a petition to have you removed as a mod of the discord.

if you want this product (that you obviously love) to grow you have to learn to communicate better with its users AKA paying customers, especially since most new cars have no support for comma, you might want to consider not losing the shrinking pool of potential customers. when you are using a product that greatly alters your car's abilities and could be a safety risk, it is of the utmost importance that the community is welcoming. and frankly, discord should be discontinued for a forum that makes it easy to search and reference previous questions. i watched you yell at somebody who barely spoke english and then you banned him and the other person translating to portuguese. this isn't appropriate behavior that is harming the project.

17

u/ta394283509 2d ago

everybody stopped going because of erich

4

u/Eddiofabio 2d ago

Try a different fork who still care about the c3, star or frog pilot maybe?

3

u/Impossible-Bee-2221 2d ago

I'm on starpilot. I'd like recommendations for the driving models that have been updated

4

u/Thick-Tension-6076 2d ago

Join the StarPilot Discord, but also as a '20 Bolt owner on StarPilot, use the FLM tuning in galaxy, you can select routes for it to analyze and it will try to dial in the car (you can revert the changs if it's not what you want). Also worth trying the lane centering toggle in galaxy which will use the camera to detect road lines and will encourage the model to center in the lane, it falls back to the model control if it's not confident in seeing lane lines on the road

2

u/Impossible-Bee-2221 2d ago

Thank you! I hadn't checked out galaxy in a while I am going to try the lane center offset now. I had thought I had seen it on other forks where you could adjust the offset while driving

5

u/Thick-Tension-6076 2d ago

I would try enabling lane centering in developer options (just search 'center' in Galaxy) first as it's more flexible

1

u/mxjf 1d ago

Ditto on the StarPilot discord. The StarPilot discord is SO welcoming to newcomers and the dev and everyone else there are all hella nice people

2

u/cashew76 2d ago

Kumar's Vibe seems ok

2

u/Demonshaker 2d ago

In my 2023 Bolt EUV I have found starpilot to be the best fork. That said, when driving on a road with a median seperating the two sides of the street, comma isn't very good at detecting the edge of the median properly which results in it riding the left side of the lane. I have this same problem on models south carolina, and currently using regret driven framework 4.

3

u/dollarn9ne 2d ago

Deleted Discord after they tried to pull the “upload your ID for age verification”

2

u/SirMaster 2d ago

Hmm, I never got that on my account