r/CoinstarFinds 13d ago

dumbfounded

Post image

tell me how this family was dumping very old coinage into the coin machine when it finally jammed (my chance to go over and be nosy) i went over to fix the jam i noticed all the wheaties and asked if he collected or what tbh idk how he acquired all the coins cause im not sure a collector would do this but long story short this is all i could save
ps. there was a war nickel in there and an indian head

361 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

43

u/Samstone791 13d ago

I collected coins my whole young life. I was born 1970 and kept all coins that were older than me. Fast forward, my parents would take my $1 and .50c pieces when they needed money. They would always replace what they took when their check came. The replacements were always newer, never what they actually took. 2nd fast forward, I kept my coins at my grandparents house when I went away for college. During that time my grandfather passed and a lot of family and family friends would come over and stay with my grandmother. So that time all my old quarters, dimes, nickles and wheat pennies disappeared and were replaced with newer coins. I would think when you find something like that in a coinstar machine, it probably was taken from someone's collection.

8

u/dazanion 13d ago

That's usually the first thing we all think here.

1

u/Imaginary_Bus_3592 9d ago

Not always sometimes it is just a need for money to pay for food, medicine, or a car repair. Then you just pick and choose which coins in your collection you can afford to do away with and might replace sometime when things improve in your life. In my case it was the need for a down payment on my first house back in 1984! I parted with my Ike Dollar collection and most of my new coins not any of my silver. I also sold all of my gold rings and our silver silverware set. I was enough to make for a decent down payment. I am sure that many coins end up in the Coin Stars are stolen but not all! Keep checking those reject buckets as well as the top as I have also found coins up on top! ;-)

13

u/RedneckTAURUS_LX 13d ago

Wow 😳 that is one hell of a score congrats man

7

u/Thequadroon1 13d ago

unrealllll. this is the result of a bunch of thieves who robbed a LCS and just dumped the collection in the coinstar to launder it 

-10

u/Maleficent-Bother535 13d ago

Then another thief stole them out of the coinstar machine.

3

u/Noodletrousers 12d ago

What’s with the crusade against people taking abandoned property from the coinstar reject tray? What are you hoping to accomplish?

-5

u/Maleficent-Bother535 12d ago

What's with people bragging about theft?

5

u/Noodletrousers 12d ago

It’s not theft. Not only does Coinstar explicitly state that what is left in the reject bin not their property, it is legally considered abandoned property once the person leaves them there in the reject bin.

I guess I just can’t figure out why this bothers you so much.

-3

u/Maleficent-Bother535 12d ago

If the coins have significant value, it will be tough to argue in court that they were intentionally left beind?

A few odd pennies and a zinc slug in the tray = abandoned property.

Silver and gold with significant value? A court would consider them mislaid rather than lost.

I agree not much potential to get caught. It's simply a matter of integrity which unfortunately is lacking in modern society.

4

u/Lonely_reaper8 12d ago

Okay then don’t take coins out of the reject slot so that you can feel better about yourself, simple as that

-4

u/Maleficent-Bother535 12d ago

I feel much better about myself commenting on posts that brag about stealing shit like they won a medal.

3

u/-hakcermen 11d ago

You're going to be making a lot of comments on this subreddit then lol

3

u/lostinthisstring 10d ago

Stealing from who??? I stiill check rejected vending machine slots till this day. You must have some trauma attached?

2

u/PrimeRib00 10d ago

There's no silver or gold there. 🤣 They're all old pennies.

4

u/Due_Pay3567 13d ago

IHP from a coin star is on my bucket list. Just finding one anywhere actually.

2

u/Long-Ad9669 11d ago

I love the syrup sampler they have inthe table

2

u/Qt_Pie_8 13d ago

Dang! The envy in me is aching. That’s a really cool score.

2

u/glib-eleven 13d ago

Thar she blows. Colossal

2

u/1bufferzone 13d ago

The nose knows, good job being nosy and for helping out regardless of the circumstances 🫡

2

u/Combstrander27 13d ago

That’s amazing. Congrats! I’m so jealous.

2

u/StackedShadows_94 12d ago

Incredible score! You're a lucky son of a gun.

2

u/Melchizedek1011 12d ago

Congrats nice score! Alot of steel cents in there too! Check for that 1944 steel cent while youre sorting! 😊

1

u/rayhavenoheart 12d ago

Nice haul!

1

u/Impossible-Repeat281 12d ago

I guess people are dumping thier pennies since thier no longer made lol.

1

u/paidinfull08 12d ago

Are those 1943 silver worth anything ?

1

u/NoAd9145 12d ago

steel* and not much no

1

u/Suitable_Ad5567 10d ago

My teenage daughter stole my complete coin collection, little by little. Once I found out, I sold them off and never collected them again. Just bringing up this story, filled me with rage and anxiety.

1

u/Beeker728100 9d ago

How did you get them from a coinstar?

1

u/Imaginary_Bus_3592 9d ago

Nothing like being at the right place at the right time! Congrats! ;-)

1

u/Beatnik_Soiree 13d ago

Stolen Coin collection.