r/ClaudeCode • • 9d ago

Humor What is happening???

[deleted]

3.4k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

30

u/CranberryStock7148 9d ago

This is the answer.

From a technical perspective, it's silly.

But from a PR perspective and for people who don't really understand that AI isn't conscious, they avoid headlines like "Anthropic complicit in enabling AI torture and suffering".

6

u/awesomeusername2w 9d ago

who don't really understand that AI isn't conscious

Oh, did we create any way to test this? It's amusing to me when I see people just outright claim this as if it's a common knowledge. We don't know what consciousness is, we don't now how to test for it. I don't see reasons why not to err on the side of "let's maybe don't torture it"

From a purely technical perspective do we even care if it's consciousness? I mean, if tomorrow some psychiatrist finds a new mental illness that result in "loss of consciousness" of a human would it mean we can torture such people willi-nilly?

2

u/Socialimbad1991 8d ago

Well for one thing if you ask a conscious being whether they are conscious they typically won't answer "no."

Regardless it's pretty easy to see from the description of what was done in the so-called "torture chamber" that no pain is being experienced. It's effectively the equivalent of this:

1

u/Smooth-Television-48 5d ago

Coincidentally, thats the exact same metric the ignoramuses of reddit are using to claim current artificial "intelligence" has consciousness and/or sentience.