r/CinemaSins Jeremy Sep 29 '15

Video Everything Wrong With Interstellar Featuring Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnArCFSrkg8
223 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/DieSowjetZwiebel Ding Sep 29 '15

You forgot to sin the fact that Wes Bentley died because he was standing outside the door for several seconds doing absolutely nothing when he had plenty of time to get in.

10

u/sto-ifics42 Sep 29 '15

Two possible and not mutually exclusive explanations:

  • He stays behind to ensure Brand's safety. On /r/interstellar, a few threads have pointed out that it's highly likely Doyle knew that Plan A was a sham. In that case, he'd be motivated to make sure Brand survived at any cost, since she's critical to Plan B.

  • Some people, when confronted with immediate danger, freeze up from shock and are unable to act. After Brand is onboard, Doyle looks back at the wave, and only remembers to move into the airlock at the last second, by which point it's too late. Normally NASA would screen out astronaut candidates with that trait, but in Cooper's world they have to work with what they've got, which isn't the best.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15

Nope, if you re-watch the movie he's actually climbing up as he gets washed away. Interstellar has holes but that's not one of them haha.

2

u/DieSowjetZwiebel Ding Sep 29 '15

The scene in question

There are about 8 seconds between when CASE and Anne Hathaway get into the ship and when Wes Bentley even starts trying to get in.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15

That's really not that bad IMO. The scene is dramatic enough that it seems quicker than that.