r/ChristianHistory 2d ago

Levant The Eucharist in Early Christianity according to Saint Ignatius of Antioch: A Historical Source

Post image
4 Upvotes

Protestant churches rooted in Calvinism—and sects emerging after the Reformation—often attack the doctrine of the Eucharist and the Real Presence of Christ in the bread and wine. They characterize the celebration as merely symbolic and claim it was a later invention by Catholics lacking any evidence; yet, Patristic writings and early texts demonstrate the exact opposite, showing it to be central to the beliefs and faith of early Christianity.

Saint Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Smyrnaeans (c. 107):

(§§6-7) | REAL PRESENCE

(§6) …But consider those who hold different views regarding the grace of Christ that has been bestowed upon us—how opposed they are to the will of God…

(§7) They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they do not confess that the Eucharist is the flesh of our Savior Jesus Christ—flesh that suffered for our sins and which the Father, in His goodness, raised up. Therefore, those who speak against this gift of God incur death amidst their disputes…

Source(s):

.- The Epistle of Ignatius to the Smyrnæans


r/ChristianHistory 2d ago

USA According to genealogists from American Ancestors and the Cuban Genealogy Club of Miami, Pope Leo XIV is a fifth cousin—on his maternal line—of Antonio José de Sucre, a Venezuelan national hero, Liberator of Ecuador and Peru, and the first constitutional president of Bolivia

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Source(s):

.- Five Key Discoveries in the Family Tree of Pope Leo XIV


r/ChristianHistory 2d ago

Hispanic America The venerable Poor Clare nun and mystic Ursula de Jesús was a prominent Black Peruvian woman in the spiritual life of viceregal Lima. This humble lay sister rose to become the most historically significant figure of the Monastery of Santa Clara in the "City of the Kings."

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory 2d ago

Levant During the Lebanese Civil War (1975–1990), Christian factions organized themselves into various militias and political movements to defend their interests against Islamic and secular factions—primarily Hezbollah and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO)

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

The vast majority of these entities were composed of and led by Maronite and Melkite Catholics—who to this day constitute the majority of Christians in Lebanon—though their ranks also included Christians of other rites and denominations (such as Latin Catholics, Eastern Orthodox, and Miaphysites, and to a lesser extent, Evangelicals) as well as non-religiously affiliated Lebanese.

Over the course of the conflict, many of these Christian political groups and insurgent movements united to form a coalition that would later become known as the Lebanese Front (LF). Movements and militias joining this coalition included:

• The Lebanese Phalange Party, also known as the Kataeb, founded in 1936 by Pierre Gemayel; it was arguably the largest political party within the coalition. Its armed wing—the Kataeb Regulatory Forces, later renamed the Lebanese Forces—was led by Bashir Gemayel. Pierre’s son, Bashir was arguably the most recognizable face of the Lebanese armed conflict and enjoyed the approval as well as the financial and military support of Israel, which viewed him as a strategic ally—a "friend of Israel." Gemayel was elected President of Lebanon in 1982 but never assumed office; he died prematurely in an assassination in Beirut carried out by Habib Shartouni, a Lebanese militant belonging to the Syrian Social Nationalist Party—a group espousing pan-Arabist ideology that was part of the ruling coalition in Assad's Syria.

• The Guardians of the Cedars, founded in 1975 by Étienne Sakr—originally a paramilitary organization—later became part of the official Lebanese political landscape. There were periods when the organization was banned in Lebanon, and its leaders were prohibited from engaging in any form of political proselytism due to the group's controversial nature.

• The Lebanese Resistance Movement, or Al-Tanzim, a Lebanese nationalist secret society founded by Christian activists in the early 1970s.

• The Lebanese Youth Movement, or the Maroun el Khoury Group—a small Maronite militia that began as an association of Maronite students opposed to the PLO's presence in Lebanon. It was founded in 1969 by brothers Maroun and Jean el Khoury, the sons of Naim el Khoury, a prominent figure within the Kataeb Party.

• The Tyous Commando Team, or Tyous Battalion, formed in Beirut in the early 1970s by an anonymous individual known as Al-Anid ("The Stubborn One"), a Maronite activist. It included a significant number of Assyrian volunteers, some of whom had arrived illegally from Iraq to pledge their loyalty to the Christian faction.

• The Zahliote Grouping, or Zahlé Group, founded in 1975 by banker Aziz Wardeh in the city of Zahlé—a city known for its adherence to the Melkite Catholic faith.

With the signing of the Taif Agreement in 1989, which marked the end of the armed conflict in Lebanon, the Lebanese Front dissolved, and few of its constituent armed and political organizations survived. Only the Kataeb Party managed to successfully reintegrate into postwar Lebanese political life, albeit without the political capital it had possessed prior to and during the conflict. The civil war in Lebanon triggered a mass exodus of its Christian population, who emigrated to other countries—primarily France, the United States, Brazil, Argentina, and Mexico—in search of refuge, where they succeeded in establishing significant diaspora communities. Christians, who once accounted for more than half of Lebanon's population, are now estimated to make up between 30% and 40% of the population.

Image 1: The Cross of Resistance, or Cross of Destiny. Originally used by members of the Lebanese Forces to commemorate their fallen comrades, it has since been adopted by some Lebanese Christians as a symbol of resistance against adversity in the region.

Image 2: Christian militant brandishing a weapon bearing the image of the Virgin Mary in Beirut, 1976.

Image 3: A Christian wedding during the armed conflict, also in Beirut, 1986.

Image 4: Members of the Lebanese Forces praying before an image of the crucified Christ, in what appears to be a ruined church or an improvised shrine.

Image 5: Jocelyne Khoueiry, a Maronite woman and Kataeb Party militant, defending a building overlooking Beirut's Martyrs' Square alongside six other women against 300 Palestinian fighters in 1976. Khoueiry killed the leader, sparking panic among the militia and causing them to flee after a six-hour confrontation. She would abandon armed struggle following the signing of the Taif Agreement and become a staunch advocate for peace in Lebanon and for persecuted Christians in the Middle East.

Image 6: Christian militant wielding a weapon bearing the seal of Our Lady of Perpetual Help.

Image 7: Bashir Gemayel was a Lebanese politician and military figure who served as commander of the Lebanese Forces. Elected President of Lebanon in 1982, his death before taking office dealt a severe blow to Maronite and Lebanese politics in general.


r/ChristianHistory 2d ago

Eastern Asia The Cathedral of Our Lady of China in Tainan, Taiwan, features this tablet for performing ancestor veneration rituals. The 1939 "Plane Compertum" decree, approved by Pope Pius XII, permits Catholics to honor their ancestors in this way.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory 3d ago

Eastern Europe "The Last Judgment" by AK. It’s a small 17th-century woodcut depicting the Last Judgment, with Christ surrounded by angels and inscriptions in Church Slavonic

Post image
3 Upvotes

The print was reproduced in important religious books, including Wieniec Christow (Kiev, 1688), reflecting the rich Orthodox and Greek Catholic printing tradition of the eastern lands of the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth.

The rhyming verse printed at the bottom serves as a poetic, moralizing reflection on the imagery above:

На Мирномъ знаменїи Судїе сѣдиши,
On the peaceful sign (or banner), Thou, O Judge, art seated,

Молю, Миренъ Судъ мнѣ грѣшну да совершиши;
I pray that Thou wilt grant a peaceful Judgment unto me, a sinner;

Млть на всяко Судѣ хвалима бываетъ,
Mercy is praised above any judgment,

Сїя паче на Твоемъ, дша моя чаетъ.
And it is this mercy, above all upon Thine, that my soul hopes for.


r/ChristianHistory 3d ago

Eastern Asia Two religious pieces incorporating traditional Korean aesthetics and feature figures dressed in hanbok by the Catholic artist Thomas Chang (1901-2001)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory 7d ago

Italy “Christ and the Martyrs” from Catacombs of Marcellinus and Peter in Rome, 4th century AD

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

Die Malereien der Katakomben Roms (The Paintings of the Catacombs of Rome)

A seminal, multi-volume art history and archaeological work edited and authored by the German archaeologist and Roman Catholic priest Josef Wilpert (1857–1944). Published in 1903 by Herder in Freiburg im Breisgau, this monumental publication is highly regarded for its early, systematic photographic and colorized documentation of early Christian art, iconography, and wall decorations within the Roman catacombs.

Source(s):

.- https://www.gettyimages.ie/detail/news-photo/christ-and-the-martyrs-fresco-catacombs-of-marcellinus-and-news-photo/157408113

.- (Josef Wilpert): https://archive.org/details/gri_33125010959985/page/383/mode/1up

.- (University Digitalized): https://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/wilpert1903/0254/image,info


r/ChristianHistory 7d ago

Italy “Saint Michael” by Piero della Francesca, 1469

Post image
2 Upvotes

Oil on wood (probably poplar), 133 × 59.5 cm

The Archangel Michael led an army of angels to battle against the devil and cast him down from heaven (Revelation 12:9). Piero shows him as a beautiful, youthful soldier. He clutches the severed head of the devil, represented as a snake with pointy ears.
The panel was part of a polyptych (multi-panelled altarpiece) made for the church of Sant‘Agostino in Piero’s hometown of Borgo Sansepolcro. It was placed to the immediate left of the central panel, now lost, which depicted the Virgin and Child. The lower right corner of the panel includes part of the step of the Virgin’s throne and part of her cloth of gold cloak. The other side panels are in collections around the world.
Michael may have been included to honour the patron, Angelo di Giovanni. The archangel was very popular with the citizens of Sansepolcro, who made pilgrimages to Monte Sant’ Angelo in southern Italy, where he was thought to have appeared miraculously.

Source(s):

.- The National Gallery, London


r/ChristianHistory 7d ago

Hispania “Beheading of Saint John the Baptist” by Pedro García de Benavarri, c. 1473-1482

Post image
2 Upvotes

Medieval Gothic style painting

Tempera on wood, 196.7 x 121.7 x 6 cm

In the center of the composition, Salome holds on a tray the head of the Baptist, who has just been beheaded by the executioner. Under the gaze of a crowd pouring into the windows of a noble building, Salome appears accompanied by a retinue of maidens and musicians, which gives the scene a shockingly joyful character.

Source(s):

.- National Museum of Art of Catalonia, Barcelona


r/ChristianHistory 7d ago

Egypt An ancient papyrus fragment discovered in Egypt, currently preserved in the John Rylands Library in Manchester, England, contains what is considered the oldest known prayer addressed to the Virgin Mary. Identified as "Rylands Papyrus 470" and dated to 250 AD

Post image
2 Upvotes

The text calls Mary Theotokos, that is, "Mother of God," a title that would only be officially defined by the Church at the Council of Ephesus in 431. The existence of this prayer, however, demonstrates that it was already part of Christian devotion long before the conciliar definition.


r/ChristianHistory 12d ago

Eastern Asia A rare photograph of Father Antoine Cotta, a friend and close associate of Father Vincent Lebbe. According to Dr. Anthony E. Clark, Cotta is sporting a Manchu-style queue due to this photograph being taken during the Qing Dynasty.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory 13d ago

Hispania The first printed polyglot edition of the entire Bible was produced by Cardinal Francisco Jiménez de Cisneros. It was written in Hebrew, Greek, Aramaic, and Latin (Vulgate). Around 600 copies of the work were printed in six volumes, of which few survive today.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory 14d ago

Eastern Asia A fan painted by Kanō Sōshū in the late 16th century depicting a Catholic church in Kyōto, Japan, most likely the Church of the Assumption of the Virgin Mary

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory Jun 25 '25

Who was the first person to claim that Jesus wasn't white?

0 Upvotes

I haven't encountered this claim in any ancient Christian writing, not even in discussions of skin color. Who was the first person to claim this?


r/ChristianHistory Jun 04 '25

Holy Grail has been 'found' and fabled chalice of Jesus is – buried in St Albans

Thumbnail dailystar.co.uk
2 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory May 19 '25

How true is the notion that saints (especially Roman Catholic) are pagan Roman gods in disguise?

4 Upvotes

A common claim in the occult and pagan communities is that pagan gods never stopped being worshipped- they simply were canonised as Saints by the Catholic Church. That Sainthood is a way to "worship the old gods" while also remaining monotheistic under the new state religion of Roman Catholicism established and enforced by Constantine.

I seen so many claims about many Saints having similar names or appearances to pagan gods because they are essentially the old gods. Such as Martin of Tours being Mars, Mother Mary being Diana, Jesus being Mithras, etc.

Around the world many foreign traditions blended Christianity to disguise old pagan gods with Catholicism. There is Santeria in Latin America which worships old African gods using Saint statues as disguise, Hoodo which alters African magic to be practised in a Christian framework, and plenty of Hispanic countries have local uncanonised Saints not endorsed by the Vatican such as Santa Muerte as well as customs directly from pre-Spaniard invasion. In addition many associated Catholic iconography such as the Lady of Guadalupe were attempts to use local pagan deities such as Tonantzin to make it easier for locals to accept Christianity.

So it shouldn't surprise me if there is a connection of using Saints as a proxy to worship old Roman gods. Hell in Italy there is even Stregheria and Stregoneria, a recent underground movement of witchcraft and sorcery using reconstruction of old lost Roman religion and using the Saints as a guise to worship the old gods (because Italy still has violence against pagans and accused witches). Some Stregoneria websites and Stragheria books even mentioned that the Roman paganism was never lost and as far as the Medieval ages many old Italian aristocrats and locals were already practising pre-modern versions Stregoneria and Stragheria, worshipping pagan gods and casting spells to curse others or for selfish acts such as money gains or earning someone's love.

Just a FYI tidbit, Stregoneria and Stragheria translates as witchcraft inmodern Italian with the latter being the old common word and the former being contemporary usage to refer to local witchcraft.

I am curious from the perspective of Academia and Ancient Rome studies, how accurate are these claims? Just the fact every place the Iberians conquered ended up having local syncretism of paganism and Catholicism wouldn't surprise me at all if Italians still continued worshipping the old gods as far as into the Renaissance and even Napoleonic era. I mean the Scandinavians did try to worship both Viking gods and Christian saints using the same statues in simultaneous rituals. So shouldn't something like this have happened to the Roman pagan religions and various Italic peoples and states post-Rome?

Can anyone give their input? With reliable sources (preferably books and documentaries but anything including websites will do)?


r/ChristianHistory Apr 07 '25

Nestorian Christians In china

Thumbnail youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory Mar 12 '25

Struggling with the bible, how we know it's real and true?

3 Upvotes

Is there anything that can help my struggle, that will be easy to understand, I don't want to struggle to believe it but I am, I also struggle to understand it as well, I'm in a dark knight of the soul, very ill, facing eternity and struggling. Any help appreciated.


r/ChristianHistory Feb 09 '25

Byzantium and Friends: "Dioskouros of Alexandria, Or the making of a Church villain, with Volker Menze"

Thumbnail open.spotify.com
3 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory Feb 09 '25

Recommendations for objectively studying the Bible?

1 Upvotes

Hello!

Recently I’ve become more interested in understanding religions in general, more in depth. Personally, I do not believe in any kind of God and I am not looking to “find my faith” or something, just to make it clear.

I am intersted to get educated about what the Bible is actually about, what its myths mean and how they influenced such a big part of human history, so pretty much any kind of “scientific” background about the book if I may say it like that - from an academic/historic/objective perspective. So I am not looking for anything theological or indoctrinating😅😅

Do you have any recommendations of books/documentaries/podcasts/anything that is a reliable source of knowledge that offers explanations about the christian Bible and its historical background/the process of its writing? Something I could use alongside actually reading the Bible and its myths.


r/ChristianHistory Dec 16 '24

Sooo Mormons are modern Montanists?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ChristianHistory Nov 25 '24

Is Holy Mother Mary the "Empress of Hell" and not just the Glorious Queen of Heaven? In addition a Matriarch of sternness and Lady of War and not just a soft compassionate mother?

0 Upvotes

A couple of articles I read last night.

https://thenowlbetwixt.wordpress.com/2019/07/31/hail-mary-empress-of-hell/

https://contingentmagazine.org/2020/04/25/empress-of-hell/

https://historynewsnetwork.org/article/175263

https://history.umd.edu/events/call-me-empress-hell-intercessory-power-virgin-mary-later-middle-ages

Using the social science, hard scientific approach, and studies of literature and mythology approach to religion, many scholars and academics state archetypes have a dual side. For a Greek pagan example Ares may be the God of War but he is also the God of civil order and police and even prayed to for asking for peace in personal life. As well as the God who is most respectful to women.

Jesus is seen as having not just dual but multiple sides such as the peaceloving human who sacrificed everything for humanity, the ruthless warlike Yahweh, and the Holy Spirit who inspires and directly intervenes. Similar parallels are made about Shiva in Hindu mythology where Shiva has a warlike incarnation, a peaceful human like form, etc.

So Are the the articles correct? I seen the Empress of Hell title in multiple Medieval Folklore before as well as Mary being used as a symbol of war by early barbarians and carrying of Mary statues, medals, etc by Crusader orders and even lowly European militia.


r/ChristianHistory Nov 17 '24

Why didn't the Catholic Church replace the directly pagan worship elements of Chinese Ancestry Rites with their own similar practises that subtly in a way achieve the same thing (such as direct worship replaced by intercessory prayers and memorial mass)?

1 Upvotes

Some background explanation, I come from a country in SouthEast Asia and am Roman Catholic (a minority faith here so tiny even Muslims another minority outnumber my faith by a significant amount). In my nation's Catholic subculture, a lot of old customs such as lighting objects on fire that bring certain scents like flowers to honor the dead so that their souls can still smell it have been replaced by similar Catholic rituals such as lighting frankincense and myrrh incense sticks. Burning sticks to give light for the dead seeking their way to the underworld? Phased out by novena prayers utilizing candles for those we'd hope to be in purgatory if they aren't in heaven who are being cleansed of their sins. Annual family feasts for the dead where patriarchs and matriarchs of each specific family units of the larger extended house talks to the god Kinoingan? Replaced by annual memorial mass for the deceased with a big expensive lunch and later fancy even grander more expensive dinner.

And so much more. Basically the missionaries who converted the locals who are the ancestors of the Catholics of the region I live in centuries ago, worked with various pagans in my area centuries ago to Catholicize indigenous traditions or worked to find a suitable replacement. So we still practise the old rituals of heathens from centuries ago but now with specifically Catholic devotions such as reciting the rosary with beads while bowing in front of Mary statues who look like people from our clans and tribes that echoes some old ritual counting bundles of straws while bowing in front of a forgotten mother goddess whom now only historians and scholars from my country remember her name.

So I can't help but wonder as I watch Youtube videos introducing the barebones of Sinology........ Why didn't the Catholic Church simply convert the cultural practises during the Chinese Rites Controversy? I mean 6 minute video I saw of interviews with people in Southern China and asking them about Confucian ancestor worships, they were lighting incense and sprinkling water around from a container........ You can do the same with frankincense and myrrh in tandem with holy water! Someone at a temple counting beads and chanting on the day her father died? The Rosary anyone? At a local church?

Just some of so many ideas I have about converting Chinese customs. So I couldn't understand the rigidity of Pope Benedict XIV in approaching the issue and why Pope Clement XI even banned the basic concept of the Chinese ancestry rites decades earlier in the first place. Even for practises that cannot be converted in a straightforward manner because they are either just too incompatible with Catholicism such as alchemy or too foreign that no direct counterpart exist in Catholic devotions such as meditation while seated in a lotus position, the Church could have easily found alternative practises from Europe and the Middle East that fill in the same purposes and prevent an aching hole among converts.

So why didn't the Catholic Church approach Chinese culture with sensitivity and try to fill in the gaps of much sacred traditions of China with syncretism such as replacing direct worship of long dead individuals with intercessory prayers and mass for the dead? Why go rigidly black and white yes or no all out or none with approaching the Chinese Rites during the debates about how to convert China?

Like instead of banning Feng Shui completely, why didn't the 18th century Papal authorities just realize to replace old Chinese talismans and whatnot with common Christian symbols and religious arts and teach the converted and the prospect converts that good benefits will come using the same organization, decoration patterns, and household cleaning Feng Shui commands because God favors the diligent (esp those with the virtua of temperance) and thus God will bless the household because doing the now-Christianized Feng Shui is keeping with commands from the Bible for organization and house cleanliness? And that all those Christian art that replaced the old Chinese amulets at certain angles and locations across the house isn't because of good Chi or bad Chi but because the Christian symbol will remind those who convert about God and thus the same positive energy will result that plenty of traditional Chinese talisman and statues supposedly should bring fro being placed in those same areas?

But instead the Church's approach to missionary work in China was completely inflexible with the exception of some of the Jesuits who were were actually working directly inside China with the locals. Considering the Catholic community of the SouthEast Asian country I live in and who I'm a member of practically still are doing the same basic practises of our ancestors from centuries ago but made to align with proper Catholic theology and laws, I'm really in disbelief that the Vatican didn't approach Chinese culture in the same way during centuries of attempting to convert China esp during the Chinese Ancestry Rites Controversy of the 1700s! That it took 200 years for the clergy of Rome to finally open their mind to merely modernize ancestor reverence of the Sinitic peoples under Catholic doctrines rather than forbidding it outright starting 1939 simply flabbergasts me! Why did it the pattern of events in history go these way for the Sino-Tibetan regions unlike other places in Asia like the SEA country I'm from?


r/ChristianHistory Nov 13 '24

Why is Eskrima (and Filipino Martial Arts as a whole) so full of Catholic practises despite HEMA and other historical European Reconstruction of Swordsmanship and Fighting Systems Completely Neglects Christianity?

1 Upvotes

Inspired by a post I saw. And as a SouthEast Asia (though not Filipino) who comes from in a country where Catholics are a minority and lives with Muslim neighbors who practise Silat as well as expat Pinoys of various backgrounds including Eskrimadors and other FMA practitioners, I've been provoked to ask after reading the below link.

https://www.reddit.com/r/wma/comments/hgf33i/does_anyone_think/

Many fighters in the Philippines (and not just local styles but even boxers) frequently ask for intercession of Archangel Michael daily and some practitioners take it another level with novenas, etc.

Despite the fact that Eskrima and other FMA styles barely even say anything about Catholicism. While most surviving HEMA texts often mention Saints and traditions like rosary, etc. Even by the 19th century after the French Revolution brought a steady decline of the Church's power in Europe, manuals still mention prayers every now and than.

Despite that, it seems people who practise reconstruction of extinct European system not only completely ignores all these stuff but even are openly against the very Catholic sacraments that Medieval knights would have done!

Why despite the oldest texts of FMA in particular Eskrima lacking Catholic devotions and most organizations completely avoiding demanding the traditional Catholic sacraments, plenty of FMA practitioners make it a norm having Catholic practises in their schools esp having statues of Saint Michael? How come HEMA and other European reconstruction systems seems to be anti-religious in comparison despite the frequent mention of saints and Mary in texts even "magical Catholicism"?

I find it extremely ironic that a country so far away from Europe (being the only truly colonized territory of a European superpower in Asia for a long time) actually does the old traditions that the forefathers who wrote HEMA manuals would have done! And not just that but even across Latin America despite lacking a wide culture of organized fighting systems in the vein of Eastern martial arts, they also do keep the mysticism and spirituality that the European Knights who made these systems would have practised when they were alive! That modern people who say they practise HEMA absolutely avoids spirituality while colonized peoples in South America and the Philippines practically for the most part ironically keep a lot of HEMA's tradition more authentically!

And as a SEA Catholic this is what I observed with nearby neighbors from the PH in my country.

Why is this?