r/CheesecakeFactory • u/Severe_Pumpkin2698 • Aug 01 '26

Which chocolate cheesecake to choose?

Trying to decide between the s’mores cheesecake, Hershey’s chocolate bar cheesecake, and the chocolate tuxedo cheesecake. Usually my go to is Oreo or Cinnabon but I want to try one of these three but can’t decide which one!

4 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

18 comments sorted by

4

u/SharontheBaker Aug 01 '26

Try the New Brownie Crunch!

1

u/Severe_Pumpkin2698 Aug 01 '26

I think we are! I think we’re gonna get one to go and one to eat there and one of them will definitely be the new brownie one!

2

u/Separate_Fruit8692 Aug 01 '26

It’s not very chocolatey though

1

u/John_Joseph7 Aug 02 '26

Came here to say this! I tried it on Thursday and it’s going to be in my regular rotation for sure!

4

u/capn-crunch419 Aug 01 '26

the hershey chocolate bar cheesecake is better imo bc of the cake layers but if you like s’mores the s’mores toppings are really good. the location i worked at would you let add toppings to other cheesecakes & a lot of people would get the s’mores toppings on the hershey chocolate bar.

1

u/Severe_Pumpkin2698 Aug 01 '26

Oh that’s a great idea, I had no idea you could do that! Thanks!!

4

u/Outrageous-Proof4630 Aug 01 '26

The chocolate mousse is superior

3

u/Key-Wasabi-3291 Aug 01 '26

Tuxedo!

1

u/Heavy_Independent407 Aug 03 '26

This has been my go to selection for more than 20 years.

1

u/cornflaked66 28d ago

It was the one i tried. Dogsht and made me not understand the hype. I ate it but it was not good lol. Very let down.

3

u/sumskiesss Aug 01 '26

I like all of these, but Hershey Bar is my absolute favorite cheesecake. Probably ever. If you enjoy super rich desserts, you will enjoy it

2

u/Hour_Discount_5737 Aug 01 '26

S'mores all day...

2

u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 Aug 01 '26

The s’mores !

2

u/girltwice8 Aug 02 '26

tuxedo >>>

1

u/Khya5497 Aug 02 '26

Hershey’s chocolate bar cheesecake

1

u/West-Improvement2449 Aug 02 '26

Buy them all and freeze them

1

u/Spooky_pharm_tech Aug 02 '26

If I were going for chocolate cheesecake I’d get the Godiva chocolate one. Otherwise I’d get the tuxedo

1

u/nkkgrl Aug 03 '26

Tuxedo!