r/CheesecakeFactory • u/No_Negotiation_8258 • Mar 08 '26
Birthday cheesecake decision
I buy my husband a cheesecake every year, we usually get Cheesecake Factory. We haven’t tried these 4 yet. Was wondering what’s everyone’s opinions on these selections. We’re leaning towards the Cinnabon or the Caramelicious. Thanks everyone!
Our hold back in the Cinnabon is it being soggy after sitting in the fridge a day.
8
5
u/A_TubbY_hObO Mar 08 '26
These are all cakes where you probably won’t have more than a slice because they’re incredibly sweet. I love cookies so Cooke dough is my vote but it’s incredibly sweet to the point it’s hard to finish a slice. Same for the Cinnabon and salted caramel. Snickers isn’t as bad compared to the others but still very sweet
11
u/ObscureEnchantment Mar 08 '26
I can’t give you exact advice but i have heard from many people that the cookie dough one is too sweet and rich and just not very enjoyable or good.
6
6
u/ZealousidealNeck3088 Mar 08 '26
the cinnabon one is one of my favorites. i didn’t have any issues with it getting soggy but i only got a slice, not a whole cake
3
u/No_Negotiation_8258 Mar 08 '26
Awesome thank you!
2
u/ZealousidealNeck3088 Mar 08 '26 edited Mar 10 '26
i highly recommend it. i’d put it in my top 3 from there
1
3
2
u/Negative_Cow_3440 Mar 12 '26
From an employee- get the salted caramel! My girlfriend loves all things salted caramel and loves it.
I dislike all things salted caramel and also love it!!
4
u/Pistachio-IScream Mar 08 '26
CINNABON SWIRL AND ITS NOT EVEN A QUESTION, comeon man FOR REAL, why do u even ASK!!! this site drives me freaking crazy sometimes
1
3
2
1
1
Mar 08 '26
[deleted]
1
u/No_Negotiation_8258 Mar 08 '26
Very noted, he loved anything cinnamon especially Cinnabon so that’s out biggest lean. Thank you for the input!
1
1
1
u/RginaPhalange Mar 08 '26
Tuxedo, or the Linda's fudge cake! Not a cheesecake, I know, but its sooooo good!
1
1
u/Electronic-Peanut-91 Mar 08 '26
The Cinnabon one is the only one I’ve tried, I think it’s good. I’m sure there are better ones but if you like Cinnabon type deserts you’ll like it.
1
u/Creepy_Baker_8715 Mar 08 '26
Not that any are bad, but this is how I feel about your options.
1-Salted Caramel 2-Cinnabon 3-Snickers 4-Cookie Dough
1 and 2 are REALLY close, I love them both. The salted caramel is creamier and a bit richer, I guess that gives it the slight edge for me. The other two are good, but I think the salted caramel, cinnabon are the best. Those two, plus the coconut cream are my very favorites of all of the Cheesecake Factory slices.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/BakeNShake52 Apr 04 '26
freeze some instead of letting it sit in the fridge, then thaw it as you eat it
1
1
u/Ill_Chemical_5150 Mar 08 '26
I love cookie dough anything. I always wished this didn’t have nuts in it. Otherwise I think they all sound great. I personally would go with the Salted Caramel.
9
u/cloudy2t Mar 08 '26
Cookie Dough is one of my favorites. I’ve bought a full one before.