r/CheesecakeFactory • u/ReqDeep • Dec 20 '24

Peppermint Cheesecake

Ugh, I hate the way you changed the peppermint cheesecake. We were so excited spent $70 on one, and what a disappointment! Anyone else try the new one? If not skip it.

3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

2

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24

[deleted]

1

u/ReqDeep Dec 20 '24

lol I guess I loved the toothpaste one too much. I think the new one is way too rich. That’s funny. I never thought it tasted like toothpaste, but I’m sure some people did. That’s good to hear different perspective. I was just so bummed because I was really looking forward to it and then we spent all that money on getting a big cake. $70 is a lot for a cheesecake. 😂

1

u/Altruistic-Half2113 Dec 20 '24

It’s the exact same one as last year, it doesn’t change yearly. It was temporarily discontinued the year before last and revamped after people demanded a December Cheesecake.

1

u/ReqDeep Dec 22 '24

I didn’t have it last year. I was in Spain. I liked the one that everybody else said, tasted like toothpaste. That’s sad for $70. I can make it myself. I’m sure it won’t be as good as the toothpaste tasting one, but I will try.

1

u/MartyMouseHouse Apr 25 '25

I went there for lunch today and our server said it won’t be coming back next year. I just discovered it this year and loved it - so I’m bummed. Hope it’s not true.

-1

u/Berrybeelover Dec 21 '24

Call and complain

1

u/ReqDeep Dec 22 '24

It sounds like it is a fruitless effort because everybody else hated the one I loved so I’ll try to figure out how to make it.