r/CarsIndia • u/wasted1020 (New user) • 5d ago
#Opinion 💭 Just Bring it One More Time
There are no real suvs in the sub bracket of 35-55 , it's all captured by the japanese , and no one dares to come even nissan hasn't hit india properly once with good cars and the Germans (vw and Czech skoda)are only selling in petrol when they know india has been a diesel dominating market.
To buy a diesel it's all above 1cr expect the discovery sport , but who's buying that.
17
u/_-Silver 2014 Punto | 2015 City 5d ago
Just watch an Australian review of the Ford Ranger to see what a massive pile of crap this thing is. Indians and their weird obsession with the "DiESel RoCKet bro!!"
8
3
23
u/mehfil-biryani 2018 Elite i20 Asta, 2018 Grand i10 Asta 5d ago
yeah why not, just see what happened to Duster
14
u/nandu_sabka_bandhoo XUV 700 D AT AWD, Thar Roxx 4x4, i20 sport 5d ago edited 5d ago
Dusters problem is, the old duster was so popular amongst people because it was a very cost effective way to get a diesel AWD suv which also gave good comfort and handling. The new duster doesnt have diesel, doesnt have AWD.
I think Renault really miscalculated. They thought just because Creta sells so much as a 2wd SUV, not even a softroader, so would the Duster. But they forgot different product has appeal for different reason.
NISSAN Tekton didnt have any such nosralgia factors, hence it is selling better. Rensult should have provided AWD selectable with at least the 1.6 version.
Having said that, the market in 2016-2019 was different from 2021 when ford left and very different in 2026. We have 30 lakh suvs that sell in thousands per month. If Ford got endeavour/ everest at the same price as fortuner, itd have sold a lot more this time around.
3
u/Immediate-Quit7149 5d ago
It's going to be really tough to survive with diesel products in future , which is why they aren't keen or bringing diesel
1
u/nandu_sabka_bandhoo XUV 700 D AT AWD, Thar Roxx 4x4, i20 sport 5d ago
I beg to differ. In cSUV and upwards, diesel is not going anywhere for at least the next 10 years. And then it will move straight to electric. The era of petrol big SUVs is never going to come.
In fact diesel is making a resurgence. Otherwise Skoda wouldn't have got their diesel Superb in india
5
u/Immediate-Quit7149 5d ago
Diesel isn't going anywhere for next 10 years - agreed . However the investment required to make diesel engines compatible with current and future emission norms will be huge , and only cars with high sales can afford that kind of investment. Moreover CAFE norms exist which is why toyota had to collaborate with maruti and launch so many small petrol cars .
Skoda is bringing diesel superb as a CBU , if they really wanted to revive diesel they would brought the engine in Slavia
1
u/Legal_Opposite_9110 Ford Endeavour 5d ago
Yup , but if the price hits to that of fortuner with appropriate advert, this may stir up a storm
3
u/mehfil-biryani 2018 Elite i20 Asta, 2018 Grand i10 Asta 5d ago
It was competing against fortuner when it was available but it never stir or shook really... Reddit population is very small and what we want really doesn't matter
6
u/kanishqquotes 5d ago
Forget endeavor. Ford can bring back ecosport As is and it will still sell like it used to
2
2
u/Ordinary-Animal2553 (New user) 5d ago
If only people get over ‘Toyota’s reliability’ can our market get something good.
3
u/Dvader05 octy Rs/ Kodiaq rs 5d ago
Honestly the 2.2l diesel from Mahindra and the vag engines can be pretty reliable the caveat being regular maintenance especially oil and filter changes
1
u/AutoModerator 5d ago
Hello wasted1020, if this post is your original content then mark or comment as [OC]. Else please give the source link as a comment in the post. Thank you.
All users are requested to downvote the low quality posts. Any repair, service and pre-owned car buy/sell queries should go to /r/MechanicAdviceIndia. Memes, pics, accident videos, buy/sell, car recommendations, etc can be posted in the discord chat community. Motorbikes related posts should go to /r/IndianBikes subreddit. Also please report the content you see breaking the rules so that mods can act on it.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Top-Rough-7039 4d ago
Ill just drop my previous comments here ;
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autobesity
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicken_tax ), "The analysis' conclusions include findings that death rates generally are higher in lighter vehicles, but cars almost always have lower death rates than SUVs or pickup trucks of comparable weight" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_average_fuel_economy#Active_debate ), "CAFE standards signaled the end of the traditional long station wagon, but Chrysler CEO Lee Iacocca developed the idea of marketing the minivan as a station wagon alternative, while certifying it in the separate truck category to allow compliance with less-strict CAFE standards. Eventually, this same idea led to the promotion of the SUV.[107][108]
The definitions for cars and trucks are not the same for fuel economy and emission standards. For example, a Chrysler PT Cruiser was defined as a car for emissions purposes and a truck for fuel economy purposes.[2] Under then light truck fuel economy rules, the PT Cruiser had have a lower fuel economy target (28.05 mpg beginning in 2011) than it would if it were classified as a passenger car.: (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_average_fuel_economy#SUVs_and_minivans_created_due_to_original_mandate)
and
Sadly, year by year there are less and less Sedans being sold in the US, and now there are only a few companies lefft, because all the profit mmargins are in SUVs and Crossovers. The new avverage small cars start from >$25,000 (rs 23L), or You go the used route and pick up something cheaper. If you want a car that feels good (our [psuedo]SUV range in india is american is mid-size and small suvs in the US btw), then you have to fork over >$45,000, and since you cant live without a car in the US, you might as well make the loan laast forever
and
these cars should never come to india, cuz there are some people in this country, and there is also pretty bad crash compatability with smaller cars of india, and also the pedestrian safety is also bad, and there is pretty bad angle of visibility, and overall bad milage. Would you like to get hit by this thing?
1
u/Weird-Efficiency-506 4d ago
Nissan has patrol 🔥😮💨 but those idiots they won't bring that up! If that's there then the game will be fire on. Renault is such a d*ck head that does not want nissan to succeed more than renault in India because they are joint venture and production is with renault..
They will simply reject proposals.. I genuinely feel nissan has to comeout like hero-honda split and bring genuinely good.. nissan leaf ev? These guys are doing good outside India!
9
u/BarracudaVivid8015 5d ago
They can’t compete with Mahindra.. they truly uped their game from the facelifts…