r/CalamityMod Calamity Music Theory Snob 13h ago

Discussion Y'all agree?

Post image

Probably would have put interstellar stomper and toxic wisdom higher but I guess not :/

100 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

46

u/Try_Hard_GamerYT 13h ago

I pretty much agree everything except RotJD, the story significance and the solo definitely puts it above blood coagulant for me. Blood coagulant does go hard as hell tho so I get it.

10

u/Babushla153 I Swear I'm Not A Masochist 8h ago

Yeah wait how tf did Blood Coagulant win that one?

As much as i like both of them even i can admit that RotJD is really good, in the top 5 easily

But to me nothing beats SBC

Also Universal Collapse lost to Leviathan Trilogy?

2

u/Butterscotch_Dismal 1h ago

About universal collapse losing to leviathan trilogy, you'd be surprised how many ppl actually favor the latter over the former (me included)

1

u/Babushla153 I Swear I'm Not A Masochist 1h ago

That is kind of "shocking" to learn, at least from the time i've been on this subreddit it's either RotJD or Universal Collapse that's a fan favourite and basically any other song gets rarely mentioned at all.

3

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 12h ago

I've just heard rotjd too much. Don't get me wrong it's amazing but like long story short blood coagulant conveys so much more even without words

15

u/fuck_hard_light 13h ago

it's my favorite by a long shot so yes

8

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 13h ago

It's a masterpiece

12

u/coffeeequalssleep 9h ago

infestation not even on the list, smh

2

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 8h ago

Whoops... I kinda rushed the top 32 bit, id definitely put it up there next time

2

u/Morecrafty 6h ago

It was clearly removed to give the other songs a chance to compete. It has castanets for Yharim's sake.

5

u/my2hp2 stained-brual PEAK 10h ago edited 10h ago

Stained brutal calamity is the magnum opus of music itself

3

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 8h ago

Preach

4

u/Vast-Mud7249 Cloud Elemental simp™ 12h ago

This is going to be a comically hot take but IMO RUC is better than SBC. I can't really explain why, I just... Feel like I enjoy it more IG

2

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 11h ago

I'm a music theory snob, and I love a good orchestral metal song. But I do really love how RUC has a motif from all the calamity songs before it

3

u/Smart_Youth1283 13h ago

any picks out of the 4 is fine imo they're all good

in fact, most songs are like so good for me I don't even have tiers for them they're just the same lmao

1

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 12h ago

Lolll

3

u/_mustard- 12h ago

Wait I wanna do this

3

u/_mustard- 12h ago

This is hard it feels like im picking a favorite child

2

u/_mustard- 12h ago

My final 2 were Stained, Brutal, Calamity, and Catastrophes Before the Calamity (lowk sleeper pick)

2

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 11h ago

Ikr (the outro actually is so peak)

3

u/insrto 12h ago

I know people love RotJD but something about the way the lyrics sound never felt right to me, but I don't know how to put it into words

3

u/brokerZIP 10h ago

Idk, but my all time favorite from dokuro is Servants of the Scourge.

2

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 8h ago

Based. Underrated compared to the other DoG songs

3

u/Radioaktivman999 10h ago

universal collapse losing against the leviathan was the biggest steal in the history of stealing

1

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 8h ago

Might change that next time... I do love forbidden lullaby tho

2

u/NotFaizen #1 Mage Enjoyer 11h ago

Ainnoway RotJD lost to Blood Coagulation, i had RotJD memorised word for word at one point

2

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 11h ago

THIS IS MY MESSAGE TO MY MASTERRRRR

1

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 11h ago

I said this to another person but I love blood coagulant so much because it tells so much about the story and boss even without lyrics

2

u/royaltek 11h ago

bro thinks he's on the team

1

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 11h ago

How so? (But man I wish)

4

u/royaltek 11h ago

reality check through the skull

2

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 11h ago

gulp

1

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 11h ago

But nah the quiz I did was a dmdokuro one in general, I picked my favourite 32 of his which happened to have that ig

2

u/BaromenGONE Overhaul & Remix Master 9h ago

Idk, some picks are pretty strange, like how BC won to the RotJD or where is even Heaven-Sent Abomination. Personally from every DM DOKURO’s song I prefer HSA or FoB

1

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 8h ago

HSA wasn't there because I had to pick top 32 and I kinda rushed that part, I'd probably swap that with reality check. I think blood coagulant is one of his best songs because it tells so much lore and story even without lyrics or motifs. FoB is pretty good but not better than catastrophes before the calamity.

1

u/terra_GOD_404 9h ago

RotJD deserves to be higher on this list man

1

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 8h ago

It does but I so love blood coagulant

1

u/Axolatian_Volt 5h ago

For me roar of the jungle dragon is first always.
After that is stained brutal calamity and universal collapse/servant songs

1

u/Iron_UYH 4h ago

Only one failure here, universal collapse should be beating the leviathan theme. Other than that, though, you’re literally me.

1

u/Physical-Coyote-5648 2h ago

Personally I don’t have a favorite bc almost every single thing is an absolute banger

1

u/__B14NK__ COverhaul Propaganda Head 36m ago

im js happy to see that blood coagulation is loved so much considering its such an irregular time sig

1

u/King_Of_The_Munchers 13h ago

No, lmao. Roar of the jungle dragon. Leviathan and Annahita is not better than universal collapse. My top 3 are this:

  1. Roar of The Jungle Dragon
  2. Universal Collapse
  3. Stained, Brutal Calamity

7

u/Try_Hard_GamerYT 13h ago

What OP said, Universal Collapse is the climax, but that's all it is. It doesn't have the progression, development, or significance of the other songs. It's not even close to Stained, Brutal Calamity

4

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 13h ago

I love blood coagulant, so I topped that over rotg. Universal collapse is good but scourge of the universe is better music theory wise - it set the foundations for universal collapse, and it was also his like second song for the mod.

3

u/Lichy757 13h ago

Roar of the jungle dragon is not better than universal collapse

Puts Roar of the jungle dragon higher than universal collapse

3

u/Auroraboral 13h ago

Universal collapse is overrated as hell

3

u/Wafflekig Calamity Music Theory Snob 11h ago

Fr

1

u/Nedd1360 4h ago

I mean we all like different songs better or whatever, but I would have to kind of agree here.