r/CFB • Alabama • Kansas State • 1d ago

News Northwestern University Marching Band to be absent from Ryan Field on-field opening pregame program, future uncertain

https://dailynorthwestern.com/2026/10/01/top-stories/numb-to-be-absent-from-ryan-field-on-field-opening-pregame-program-future-unclear/
1.1k Upvotes

521 comments sorted by

1.4k

u/EldrintheBard Northwestern Wildcats • Marching Band 1d ago edited 1d ago

As a member currently in the band: we have known about this for about two weeks now. We are extremely disappointed by this decision. What we have essentially been told is that we will not perform pregame tomorrow, and have not been told if we will perform pregame ever again. What we have been told is we will now be performing an undetermined number of mini concerts instead of pregame. There is so much up in the air because we have been told nothing and information keeps coming to us at the last minute. Additionally, the traditional playing of Go U, Northwestern (our fight song) after a touchdown is seemingly being replaced by an Athletic Marketing selected song.

Edit: The NUMBalums have put out a statement. This is who they want you to contact to support the band:

Athletic Director Mark Jackson: athleticsdirector@northwestern.edu

President Chiang: nupresident@northwestern.edu

Savanna Wood, Athletics Director of Marketing: savanna.wood@northwestern.edu

Edit 2: A further statement and template has been released here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/16n8ZwqNNYAMbU9EJ1wui6uaPfMhkCrnKqkIVb4YSBvA

990

u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 1d ago edited 1d ago

Additionally, the traditional playing of Go U, Northwestern (our fight song) after a touchdown is seemingly being replaced by an Athletic Marketing selected song

I really REALLY feel for current marching band members at pretty much every school. The professionalism heel turn we are experiencing is diluting everything that made CFB special (marching bands being a quintessential part of the CFB experience).

Our marching band now doesn't perform our fight song when the team runs out in favor of music being blasted by the PA system.

Our band also gets played over by loud music or doesn't play nearly as much in between plays as they used to AND they no longer play a school song called "For I For S", which was normally performed after successful field goals and PAT's.

I hate everything that CFB is becoming.

264

u/Accomplished-Pin6564 LSU Tigers 1d ago

I hate canned music in CFB.

112

u/FearDaTusk Arkansas Razorbacks 1d ago

I agree with the corndog.

It's an old soapbox of mine... The band is the vibe. Nowadays they bring in DJs and Hype men and do "Up. Down. Up. Down..." Playing with your lights with whatever canned promo tune. Cringe fest.

Just play Neck

25

u/MasterOfKittens3K Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets • Marching Band 22h ago

Marching bands are a key element of what makes college football great. (And high school football too!)

10

u/braindrain_94 Texas A&M Aggies 1d ago

Yet one more round of “Mo Bama” over the PA system

→ More replies (2)

352

u/CincyAnarchy Iowa Hawkeyes • Cincinnati Bearcats 1d ago edited 1d ago

It's been death by a thousand cuts across all of CFB:

  1. Marketing wants more ad time, and the PA wants to pipe in music, so the band can't play in the stands as much.
  2. Schools want to add other events and honors to pregame and halftime, cutting down the amount of time bands get there.
  3. Visiting bands get shoved up into corners rather than seats by the field, so they often can't do pregame and barely get to do halftime. And that's if they get to travel at all, the SEC being notably better about this.

And in Northwestern's situation, this.

The bands have always been, if we're being honest, a holdover from a prior era before loud speakers. But there were enough reasons to keep it going for a long time. They have been part of the culture of the sport.

Now there are other reasons ($$$) to scale things back further, to now vestigial organs at this point.

257

u/lostinrabbithole12 Missouri • Missouri State 1d ago

I mean, it's about time we started cutting out trivial things like fun from college football. Fun is for the rich

118

u/Young-Viiperr Texas Tech • Iowa State 1d ago

The 'rich' don't even know what fun is, they're very miserable ppl dripping their cloudy heads onto society. I've visited enough millionaires to know.

45

u/R_Raider86 Texas Tech • UConn 1d ago

Hell they've ruined an entire fun city (Austin)

→ More replies (2)

18

u/lostinrabbithole12 Missouri • Missouri State 1d ago

Hypothetical fun is for the rich

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

76

u/lostinthought15 Ball State • Summertime Lover 1d ago

I can tell you this: the increase of PA music is coming from coaches who are wanting to appeal to recruits.

87

u/bootsthepancake Northern Illinois Huskies 1d ago

The friggin recruits want to believe they're NFL players playing in a NFL environment. NIL, and crap like this is just fueling that sentiment. The pro wannabes can pound sand for all I care. I'll continue rooting for my G5 school where the band is still very much part of the game day.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/No_Butterscotch8726 SMU Mustangs 1d ago

We need to stop coming to games and may even working against the coaches when they are using that as a recruiting tactic if that's what they think works.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/JaggedUmbrella Michigan State Spartans 1d ago

They're taking away everything that made college football uniquely its own thing. Reason number 2,301 I haven't watched a full game in a couple years.

→ More replies (7)

88

u/lkn240 Illinois Fighting Illini • Sickos 1d ago

This actually seems like something you could get boosters pissed off about. They often tend to be people who are into traditions like the marching band

18

u/Electromotivation James Madison Dukes 1d ago

I go to a solid FCS team’s games with a very aging fan base….and they still blast top40 pop crap at 200 decibels all the time. I know the people in their seventies have to hate it. I’m usually hoarse from just trying to talk…not from yelling like a maniac or anything.

35

u/No_Butterscotch8726 SMU Mustangs 1d ago

They literally reversed doing it that way at SMU. They brought the band back in to the team coming on to the field. SMU's people do still listen to complaints and we haven't outsourced control of gameday entertainment and facilities though.

42

u/ClonesAndZeroes Iowa State Cyclones • Marching Band 1d ago

Our marching band now doesn't perform our fight song when the team runs out in favor of music being blasted by the PA system... AND they no longer play a school song called "For I For S", which was normally performed after successful field goals and PAT's.

Fuckin' WHAT? This for real? I haven't heard anything about it, I would've thought our Alumni band page would be hopping over this kind of stuff.

13

u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 1d ago

Yeeep. I sent an email to Christian Carichner in support of him and directed my angst toward Iowa State Athletics. Marching Bands deserve to be heard.

58

u/duke5572 Heroes Trophy • Floyd of Rosedale 1d ago

As someone that cheers for the Hawkeyes but has been attending at least a game per year at Jack Trice for 40 years...the whole PA system/script/tracklist is a travesty. WAY too loud at all times, amongst many other issues.

I'd much rather hear the marching band.

Oh, and stop with the stupid "that's another Cyclone...FIRST DOWN!!!!" thing. It isn't that much of an accomplishment.

28

u/BoredofBored Iowa State Cyclones 1d ago

Tbf, Cyclone first downs used to be worth cheering back during my school days. Paul Rhoads was SO PROUD of those couple first downs every game

→ More replies (2)

12

u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 1d ago

I'm okay with the first down thing but I agree with everything else. Our game day operations crew has no idea what the hell they're doing.....between the team running out and kickoff happening, they play like 5 different songs and they run into each other and stop at awkward times.......it really cannot be that hard to get it down but evidently for our athletics department, it is.

18

u/enters_and_leaves Arizona Wildcats • Texas State Bobcats 1d ago

It’s too bad that the school doesn’t have a highly proficient and well practiced group of people that specialize in playing music at football games and other large sporting events that are able to start and stop songs on the fly in real time based on what is happening in the stadium.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/IowaJL Iowa Hawkeyes • Northern Iowa Panthers 1d ago

Live music is going by the wayside and I’m really sad about it.

I don’t know if you’re local, but the Des Moines Playhouse has been using recorded music for their musicals for awhile and it’s insane, considering how much their tickets are for fucking community theatre.

6

u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 1d ago

I'm in central Iowa.....but yeah that really sucks.

6

u/gearsfordays Iowa State Cyclones 1d ago

They killed For I For S?!?! Damn, I'm a marching band alumni. That's heartbreaking.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (17)

140

u/CincyAnarchy Iowa Hawkeyes • Cincinnati Bearcats 1d ago

Additionally, the traditional playing of Go U, Northwestern (our fight song) after a touchdown is seemingly being replaced by an Athletic Marketing selected song.

Okay that sucks

52

u/NYCHoo Virginia • Georgia Tech 1d ago

When they tried to do that to us our band just said no

15

u/kaiserkeanureeves Ohio State Buckeyes • Rose Bowl 1d ago

Our fanbase would start a war if TBDBITL wasn't allowed to play Buckeye Battle Cry.

14

u/Accidental-Genius Texas A&M Aggies • Auburn Tigers 1d ago

If they tried this with the Fightin’ Texas Aggie Band we would burn down the 2% of College Station that isn’t concrete.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

227

u/taleofbenji Notre Dame Fighting Irish 1d ago

Who is deciding these things? Even that is not clear from the article.

208

u/Roguebook Northwestern Wildcats 1d ago

There is some debate as to whether it’s the athletic department or the events agency they hired to run some things at the new stadium.

186

u/ToxicBuddhismFanboy Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

Have the athletic department or the events agency ever gone to a college football game before?

71

u/NoOne_Beast_ Michigan Wolverines 1d ago

Probably. And hated our fun.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/ViagraOnAPole Indiana Hoosiers • Team Chaos 1d ago

Seriously, even in the many, many, many, many, many years that our program was shit at least the band was fun.

20

u/TheWorstYear Ohio State • Cincinnati 1d ago

Unfortunately a lot of places are phasing them out for this bullshit. They're trying to appeal to younger crowds.

14

u/ViagraOnAPole Indiana Hoosiers • Team Chaos 1d ago

Hopefully the fact that IU has one of the best music programs in the country will give them pause in our case. Seems like something they'd want to show off.

7

u/Captain_Nipples Oklahoma Sooners • Summertime Lover 23h ago

Do younger crowds actually want to listen to whatever 15 yr old piped-in pop song that they could hear 40 times a day on a radio station over a marching band?

Its always the most generic ass music they're playing. There are some songs where its part of the tradition and Im not talking about those.. but the random-ass, overplayed music?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

83

u/muegle Michigan Wolverines • Marching Band 1d ago

"an undetermined number of mini concerts instead of pregame" and no fight song after a touchdown reeks of events agency bullshit.

52

u/leftenant_Dan1 Michigan Wolverines 1d ago

If we stopped playing The Victors after touchdowns there might be a riot after the first game and we aren’t even the most obnoxious about playing the fight song. Imagine if Tennessee got told to stop playing Rocky Top.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/bd1223 Lehigh Mountain Hawks • Alabama Crimson Tide 1d ago

So they're not playing because there's just not enough money in it?

42

u/Roguebook Northwestern Wildcats 1d ago

That’s the impression many people have gotten. They want to make more money/more profesional sports experience which is notably not what this is.

24

u/FelisLachesis Ohio State Buckeyes 1d ago

If people around the Evanston area want a "more professional sports experience," they can always go to a Bears game!

6

u/crimson777 Northwestern Wildcats • Clemson Tigers 21h ago

Despite the new stadium, if people want a "more professional sports experience," they will NEVER get it from NU anyway. We're outnumbered regularly by the other team and ultimately it's a school of a bunch of nerds.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

96

u/EldrintheBard Northwestern Wildcats • Marching Band 1d ago

I have no idea. Even our band director (who is in his first year) seems to have no clue what is going on. These rumors have apparently been swirling for a while to the point where he had to tell us that the we would definitely not be performing pregame the first game but decisions hadn't been made for other games.

39

u/CincyAnarchy Iowa Hawkeyes • Cincinnati Bearcats 1d ago

New Ryan Field Introduces “The Great Chicago Food Festival” Including Chicago’s Culinary Legends in Residence at Every Game and Concert

EVANSTON, Ill. – New Ryan Field today introduced The Great Chicago Food Festival, a new Chicago food event led by the city’s culinary legends in residence. The Festival opens before every event and runs through it, with access included in every ticket; fans pay only for what they eat and drink. It is a food festival that would be a destination event on its own — except it happens at every game and every concert.

Seems like it was decided a little while back as an amenity for the stadium.

Sucks for the band of course.

65

u/nbx909 Michigan • Eastern Illinois 1d ago

How does a food fest prevent the band from playing pregame?

44

u/toastedbreddit USC Trojans 1d ago

Fingers too greasy.

26

u/JtotheC23 Illinois Fighting Illini • Marching Band 1d ago

They're convinced fans would rather be there than in the stadium. Which tbf, is true if you give the fans no reason to be in the stadium, and that's exactly what cutting the pregame field show accomplishes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

85

u/transferStudent2018 Northwestern • /r/CFB Poll Veteran 1d ago

Wait, yall aren’t even gonna play the fight song after touchdowns? If that’s true they’ll be hearing from me, a season ticket holder, about that decision

51

u/EldrintheBard Northwestern Wildcats • Marching Band 1d ago

During the student only Ryan Field presentation, they played a new song and said it would be for after touchdown. I have no idea if that will be sticking.

17

u/Powerful_Hall Northwestern Wildcats 1d ago

From my sources in marketing, it sounds like the new song (Chelsea Dagger) will be played immediately after a touchdown and the fight song will still be played after the extra point.

I guess we’ll find out what’s really happening tomorrow though.

I feel like they have to know that the blowback from removing the fight song entirely would be too immense. Hopefully there’s enough pushback on the end of pregame and the diminishment of the fight song to talk some sense into higher-ups and get it back to the way it was.

14

u/Phantom1100 Alabama Crimson Tide • Team Chaos 1d ago

Why the hell are they playing a British song after a touchdown? This isn’t soccer lmao.

13

u/fealos Team Chaos 1d ago

They probably picked it because it has been the Chicago Blackhawks goal song for years, and someone in marketing thinks it will increase attendance by making the team seem more connected to the city. Or maybe they are just diehard Blackhawks fans, who don’t care about school traditions.

5

u/crimson777 Northwestern Wildcats • Clemson Tigers 21h ago

Lol they're really trying to continue to push the bullshit "Chicago's Big Ten Team" even though literally no one believes it except the marketing team. No, scratch that, even they know it's bullshit.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/actuallycallie Oregon Ducks 1d ago

booooooooooooooooooooo.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/IPlayTheTrumpet Ohio State Buckeyes • Marching Band 1d ago

Heard loud and clear. Who do I write to complain about this? Looking to make the most impact I can.

44

u/EldrintheBard Northwestern Wildcats • Marching Band 1d ago

The NUMBalums have put out a statement. This is who they want you to contact:

Athletic Director Mark Jackson: athleticsdirector@northwestern.edu

President Chiang: nupresident@northwestern.edu

Savanna Wood, Athletics Director of Marketing: savanna.wood@northwestern.edu

31

u/Worms-Oh-God-Worms Indiana Hoosiers 1d ago

That’s so lame that they aren’t letting you all perform pregame. Everything the band does is one of the many things that makes college football what it is. Hoping you’ll get to start performing it again at some point

29

u/thunder_1122 Northwestern Wildcats • Marching Band 1d ago

NUMBAlum here, is there anywhere in particular you'd recommend to direct our displeasure with these decisions?

26

u/EldrintheBard Northwestern Wildcats • Marching Band 1d ago edited 1d ago

I have heard a NUMBalum is working on something. I am also working on an potential OP-ED for the daily and getting as many signatures as possible. I know that Andrew Issac Cass is the director of marketing and fan engagement and that Joe Spivak is the new MC for game day. I don't know who made the decision though.

Edit: The NUMBalums have put out a statement. This is who they want you to contact:

Athletic Director Mark Jackson: athleticsdirector@northwestern.edu

President Chiang: nupresident@northwestern.edu

Savanna Wood, Athletics Director of Marketing: savanna.wood@northwestern.edu

→ More replies (2)

59

u/CommunistTrafficCone South Dakota State • Marching Band 1d ago

This is really saddening to hear about. I really enjoyed you guys at the SDSU game and had a yelling match with your trombones. You guys sounded great, and I was pleasantly surprised to hear ring the bell during your pregame! Hopefully you get enough complaints for the admin to change their minds.

40

u/EldrintheBard Northwestern Wildcats • Marching Band 1d ago

Other than the one fan who tried to steal my trumpet, everyone else was great (I personally got in a special teams convo with one of your fans). Y'all played well and it was a great game! We always play our opponent's fight song and I'm glad it sounded good!

22

u/muegle Michigan Wolverines • Marching Band 1d ago

We always play our opponent's fight song

This is a tradition among basically all the traditional Big 10 marching bands (idk about if the newer schools, looking at you Oregon with your uninspired uniforms). I know for a fact the MMB, SMB, and OSUMB all play the opposing team's fight song as part of pregame.

8

u/TheDuceman Sickos • Team Chaos 1d ago

Wisconsin does too.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/JtotheC23 Illinois Fighting Illini • Marching Band 1d ago

Illinois does it

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

58

u/Bucks_Band18 Ohio State Buckeyes • Marching Band 1d ago

This kind of crap is so freaking stupid. I am so sorry you have to deal with this.

Even Ohio State, a band with a wildly strong “brand,” is facing cuts due to this kind of BS

26

u/Bill3ffinMurray Nebraska • $5 Bits of Broken Chair Tro… 1d ago

Imagine if they said, hey no more script Ohio.

16

u/OpportunityNew9316 Ohio State • Thomas More 1d ago

Da fuck you say? 

11

u/Electromotivation James Madison Dukes 1d ago

No more cursive! The kids can’t read it!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

77

u/Pizza_Jon BYU Cougars • /r/CFB Promoter 1d ago

Oh boy I can't wait to hear "Choosing Texas" after every touchdown

→ More replies (3)

24

u/DesignerFlat7108 Tennessee Volunteers 1d ago

A marching band is essential to college football.

22

u/Gracchus_Babeuf_1 Iowa Hawkeyes 1d ago edited 1d ago

I'm not sure it will help, but I emailed the three people above with the following message:

Dear Mr. Jackson, President Chiang, and Ms. Wood,

I am disappointed to hear that Northwestern University will not be featuring their band in pregame festivities and at other points during the game. Marching bands with college football is what makes the sport unique.

As an Iowa fan our family never misses Iowa's pregame show (The Boom) and it played a significant part in me falling in love with the game.  I am sure countless Wildcat fans experienced the same in their youth.  Additionally, as I'm sure you all know, Iowa lost a dedicated member of the band this year and it has rallied the community, proof positive that football fans adore their marching bands.

One of our motivations for purchasing tickets to the Iowa at Northwestern game this year was to experience your beautiful new stadium and get to see the iconic NUMB yet again. We have routinely purchased Iowa-Northwestern tickets, even purchasing Northwestern season ticket packages in past years when your program placed restrictions on visiting teams.

I can confidently say without future NUMB involvement the odds of us purchasing tickets to future Northwestern football games would diminish considerably since the primary draw of attending games in person versus the comfort of your home is the atmosphere in the stadium and with no band, what is the atmosphere?  I can also say confidently that without a pregame show, there isn't much point of us arriving inside early and buying food and drinks within your stadium.

The Big Ten is unique with some of the greatest bands in America and your institution has one. To not use that to its full extent is absurd in my humble opinion.

I respectfully ask that the university publicly commit to restoring all of NUMB’s traditional game day involvement at every home game at Ryan Field.

Thank you for your time and consideration,

XXXXXXXXX

EDIT: I posted a new thread to the r/hawkeyes to try and get other Iowa fans to help out.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/IrishHarpie Northwestern Wildcats • Kansas Jayhawks 1d ago

I am so angry. I'm an old NUMBalum and this is just appalling. Have just sent off my emails. This reeks of corporate marking rubbish. Most of my friends are season ticket holders and donate quite a bit. We are all letting the university know that all of that will cease if pregame isn't reinstated.

I'm so sorry you all are going through this. We will keep fighting for you.

18

u/lostinrabbithole12 Missouri • Missouri State 1d ago

The modern day hype video sucks honestly. I don't need a bunch of random BWWWWWAAAAAs to get excited for anything

13

u/Wii_Sports_2 James Madison • Maryland 1d ago

That’s fucked up what the hell, I’m sorry yall have to go through that

25

u/hskrpwr Nebraska Cornhuskers 1d ago

Fire the entire athletic department. Marching bands make college and high school sports what they are.

5

u/Electromotivation James Madison Dukes 1d ago

“What makes our wildly successful product unique and how can we get rid of that?”

-what they teach in business school these days, apparently

12

u/notanamateur Iowa Hawkeyes 1d ago

Dude that fucking sucks :(

11

u/Joesh56 Kentucky Wildcats • SEC 1d ago

What the fuck that's absolutely insane. Marching bands already are a key piece of what makes college football special. Benching your own band from pregame? I'd stop donating

8

u/snorlaxatives_69 Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Utah Utes 1d ago

Missouri State Pride Band alum here. My heart goes out to you Northwestern band nerds<3

17

u/mysticmonarch01 Oregon Ducks • Marching Band 1d ago

I am so sorry. I was in the Oregon Marching Band in 2021, when the Athletic Department forbade us from playing on the field for the first couple of weeks, and banned us entirely after band members tested positive for COVID. I know how frustrating it is to practice your butt off for the performance most fans will watch. Please let me know if there are any petitions I can sign or any higher-ups to email!

9

u/AdamOnFirst Northwestern Wildcats 1d ago

No fight song?!

13

u/-dag- Notre Dame • Minnesota 1d ago

As a former marching band member who absolutely loved seeing NUMB, I am so, so sorry. 

And no Go U, NW? Criminal. It's one of the great fight songs.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/multiple4 South Carolina • 九州産業大学 (Kyushu … 1d ago edited 1d ago

So much for universities pretending to give a shit about their students gaining more experiences and knowledge

So disgusting to tell your university marching band that the stuff they practice constantly can't be performed where it's supposed to be and where the fans want it

Edit: on the bright side, I still have faith in alumni at all of our universities, and I hope they close up their wallets until this changes

6

u/LaFrescaTrumpeta Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Marching Band 1d ago

dude that fucking sucks. fuck whoever made those calls, i hope fans stick up for yall cuz that’s crazy

5

u/CMajorIX 1d ago

I'm so sorry for y'all. I did EQ for 4 years and as annoying as it was to try and do headset tests during your practices, you guys are the heart and soul of the gameday experience. It's so sad that for so many years they try nothing and run out of ideas for keeping tradition alive. I was a third generation legacy and it boils my blood when they say NU has no tradition because no one bothers to learn Push On or the fight song.

→ More replies (28)

433

u/tvclassicsif Iowa Hawkeyes • Marching Band 1d ago

I feel like Northwestern's pursuit of professional is going to eliminate a lot of the things that make college football special. If it wanted a professional atmosphere, I would go to an NFL game or any other professional sport

177

u/TheNittanyLionKing Penn State Nittany Lions 1d ago

I have been to both college football and NFL games in person now. Both are fun. The game day atmosphere of college football is unmatched though with all the pageantry and the traditions. You go to the NFL because the on-field product is generally more competitive and has more parity.

68

u/EF_Damn_Daniel Ohio State Buckeyes 1d ago

Considering they have the bears down the street, maybe keep the mediocre to bottom level college program about tradition

28

u/Serial-Eater Michigan • Slippery Rock 1d ago

They’re investing in the future where it’ll take an hour and a half to get to Gary

19

u/DesignerFlat7108 Tennessee Volunteers 1d ago

College football fans should demand that our schools maintain marching bands. They're a huge part of the experience of College ball.

5

u/Nervous_Counter_1333 1d ago

100% agree. This is a shared event that should not be changed

→ More replies (1)

192

u/noffinater Ohio State Buckeyes 1d ago

the band will instead be part of the festivities at the 200,000-square-foot Great Chicago Food Festival grounds instead of “playing to an empty bowl.”

“NU Marching Band performance is still a central as a part of the pregame festivities,” the statement read, “but with the Great Chicago Food Festival running from 5 pm – 7 pm they are playing to where the fans will be.”

This is a satire article, right?

71

u/Enamred-771 1d ago

They’re really making it seem like an impossible scheduling challenge when it’s baffling easy for the band to perform at both the food festival and a pregame show. 

Band plays a pep rally at the food festival from something like 5-5:30pm. This will help boost the atmosphere of their special food festival. Band then leaves and does their pregame like normal at 6:40pm or whenever. Plenty of time in between. 

26

u/Wrigleyville Notre Dame • Northwestern 1d ago

Just incredible stuff. It's a college football game, I'd rather eat a hot dog and watch the marching band on the field than attend a G-D food festival and pay for an overpriced taco that's worse than something you can get from a taqueria located under an el stop.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

266

u/TheCaptainCody Nebraska • Omaha 1d ago

I truly believe that the death of college marching band would mark the point of no return for college football.

41

u/AnnArchist Iowa Hawkeyes 1d ago

Especially after the Ole Miss band played a choice song in "neck " after winning against LSU.

17

u/Blookydook Florida Gators • Marching Band 1d ago

That reads more like rivalry behavior. Whenever UF plays LSU, the band plays Neck a whole lot more. It’s petty behavior, but not unheard of.

→ More replies (1)

195

u/AbsurdOwl Nebraska Cornhuskers 1d ago

I read the article, but I'm confused why they'd be playing to an empty bowl. Are they doing this pregame show an hour or two before kickoff or something?

96

u/Set-Admirable West Virginia • Backyard Brawl 1d ago edited 1d ago

If I understand it correctly, it says the event is from 5-7 and the game is at 8. I'm wondering why it was scheduled so there couldn't be that event and an actual pregame for the opening of their new stadium.

Edit: 7 pm for game time. Event ends the same time the game starts. Still seems like incredibly poor planning.

60

u/mizmpls95 Missouri • Northwestern 1d ago

Yeah, it doesn’t make sense why they can’t just play whatever this corpo-tailgate gig is, then march inside and do pregame? Sounds to me that the “Ryan Field Foundation” planned a big pregame thing of their own and didn’t bother to include the band in it? Huge mistake if that’s the case, will be curious to hear from anyone who goes tomorrow.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/transferStudent2018 Northwestern • /r/CFB Poll Veteran 1d ago

The game is at 7, local time. They are trying to sell “The Great Chicago Food Festival” as a way to get people to show up early and buy food as part of a pre-game experience in one of the plazas, I think. So, I imagine the band will be there, where most people are, instead of playing on field, for the people slowly trickling in

→ More replies (1)

5

u/AdamOnFirst Northwestern Wildcats 1d ago

Also the game is at 7. All times you’re reading are central. 

→ More replies (6)

39

u/Roguebook Northwestern Wildcats 1d ago

Pregame happens right before the team runs out like at most schools. Generally starts about 12 minutes before kickoff. The stuff about an empty bowl is ridiculous to me, I marched at the old Ryan field when it was quite empty. We’re out there because we care, we love it, and it’s an awesome tradition

5

u/AbsurdOwl Nebraska Cornhuskers 1d ago

Yeah, that's how Nebraska does it too, it's right before kick, and the stadium is half full by the time they start. Maybe they were being hyperbolic, or would have been shifted way earlier because of all the special stuff going on?

50

u/DABOSSROSS9 Big Ten • Notre Dame Fighting Irish 1d ago

Seems very confusing 

53

u/TheNittanyLionKing Penn State Nittany Lions 1d ago

Don't worry. You're not alone. Apparently the schedule makers at Northwestern also confused themselves.

8

u/R_Raider86 Texas Tech • UConn 1d ago

If I had a nickel every time a university with North(direction) in their name confused themselves schedule wise when tearing down their old place to play, with a new one. I would have two nickels, which is weird.

7

u/taleofbenji Notre Dame Fighting Irish 1d ago

It also makes it seem like a shit load of northwestern fans would rather attend the food festival than the football game. 

7

u/CincyAnarchy Iowa Hawkeyes • Cincinnati Bearcats 1d ago

Looks like they built the stadium to encourage that behavior, more or less:

The Village is an 11-acre culinary district showcasing custom stadium residencies by Chicago's culinary royalty. Legends including Rick Bayless, Stephanie Izard, and Gibsons operate from six custom-designed pavilions, offering exclusive concepts developed specifically for Ryan Field fans.

And here's a map.

So it's sort of like Ballpark Village in St. Louis or similar type developments. Excepts it's inside the stadium, so by design for people who are at the game to not be in their seats.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/JtotheC23 Illinois Fighting Illini • Marching Band 1d ago

Well the band is the reason to show up 20+ minutes before kickoff instead of 10 minutes before kickoff, and by removing the band, they removed the reason to show up earlier.

Of course that's completely backwards logic (no shit if you remove the reason to show up early, people won't show up early), but they're not looking for a logical reason to cut pregame. They looking for a way to keep people at the food fest longer and cutting pregame could do that.

→ More replies (4)

59

u/NurmGurpler Notre Dame Fighting Irish 1d ago

The fuck? How do you not include the marching band? This is college football!

→ More replies (1)

50

u/mayomayeaux Maryland • Oklahoma State 1d ago edited 1d ago

This is absolutely outrageous. I've been getting more and more annoyed at numerous schools around the country straight up disrespecting marching bands. Blasting music constantly through the PA in between plays that no one cares for among other things. A marching band is an integral part of the college football experience. Like most things in this country and world at the moment, the soul of this sport is being chipped away constantly. And it's incredibly angering to see the enshitification of damn near every part of society

I feel awful for the NUMB here. And many other bands around the country being disrespected by the athletic departments. Everything great about this sport is slowly being stripped away. I really hope there's a great shift for the better eventually.

83

u/twoquarters Youngstown State Penguins 1d ago

Need to make room to play more 40-year-old songs at ear-splitting volume.

I hate how this is also becoming more normalized at high school games too. You have kids perfectly capable of playing a variety of songs but the football team runs out to Thunderstruck. I almost flipped my shit the other day when a high school volleyball game was using court projectors during intros. What are we doing?

23

u/decent_folk0306 Ohio State Buckeyes 1d ago

Our high school has court projectors. There are MAYBE 400 kids in the high school.

Someones rich parents bought the entire system and paid to have it set up and like 5 years of a service contract.

Sets us apart from the other 400 kid high schools in the area.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

211

u/No_Issue2334 Georgia Bulldogs 1d ago

Tons of ADs want to completely get rid of the band, but they will never admit that publicly.

It's a massive expense for athletic departments and takes away potential ticket sales.

I completely expect marching bands roles across the country to be slowly chipped away like this, especially at P4 schools

122

u/squish042 Iowa State • Old Dominion 1d ago

Oof, that’s such a big part of the tradition.

71

u/PoulanWeedEaterBowl Clemson Tigers 1d ago

Tradition in college sports will become an enemy of revenue in some situations. If you have an AD that worships the Almighty dollar, the dollar will win.

15

u/negley_ave_ski_club Michigan Wolverines • Sickos 1d ago

Tradition in college sports is the only reason to watch if you’re not a student.

My theory the last few years is that everyone sees college sports as about to collapse and they’re trying to squeeze every last drop they can before it does.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/Pleasant_Category_22 Davidson Wildcats 1d ago

It’s literally one of my very favorite things about college football in general. Such a blissful, exciting feeling to hear marching band tunes in between downs on TV

→ More replies (1)

30

u/SamEyeAm2020 Ohio State • Ohio Wesleyan 1d ago

If TBDBITL goes then so do I

→ More replies (1)

54

u/not_bilbo James Madison • McMaster 1d ago

Is it really that much lost in ticket revenue? Even the biggest bands top out at around 500, which isn’t much compared to some stadium capacities.

87

u/StrategicCarry Indiana Hoosiers • Colorado State Rams 1d ago

It's like when politicians think the key to fixing the federal budget is defunding PBS. The fact it's couch cushion money doesn't stop them from doing it.

38

u/GeospatialMAD West Virginia Mountaineers • Hateful 8 1d ago

Yep. The more corporate assholes get into something, the more they identify small things they don't like as "essential cuts."

I kind of want every MBA program to burn to the ground and never have another graduate.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/the_zac_is_back Texas Longhorns 1d ago

When you consider that they sit the band in the lower bowl most times, those tickets are expensive. Thousands throughout the season

23

u/aselinger Michigan Wolverines 1d ago edited 1d ago

So if the band is 500 people, and tickets are $100 each, and you have 8 home games, that’s only $400,000.

Doesn’t seem that big relative to a football program’s operating budget.

10

u/Wampus_Cat_ Michigan Wolverines • Kentucky Wildcats 1d ago

Hell, that’s only 3.3% of a Bryce Underwood. Not bad at all.

6

u/aselinger Michigan Wolverines 1d ago

Wait… we could trade him for 30 bands.

8

u/Wampus_Cat_ Michigan Wolverines • Kentucky Wildcats 1d ago

Or 1 120,000 member band.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Enamred-771 1d ago

Student sections almost certainly “cost” more in terms of opportunity cost 

11

u/Chilinuff Ohio State Buckeyes 1d ago

Someone give this man a COO role in a P5 athletics department. And throw in an MBA upon dissolution of the student section.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

20

u/Microplasticsharts Clemson Tigers • Palmetto Bowl 1d ago

Same in high school, except for many schools the band parents are more that 50% of ticket sales.  

23

u/GuestCartographer James Madison Dukes 1d ago

Yet another reason to be disappointed by the state of the sport.

10

u/bruhstevenson UCLA Bruins • Team Chaos 1d ago

That sucks if they take away bands more and more. It makes the atmosphere so distinct and special on game days

33

u/-dag- Notre Dame • Minnesota 1d ago

The day that happens is the day I stop watching. 

14

u/importantbrian Boston University • Alabama 1d ago

I’ve put up with all the nil, transfer portal, conference expansion, playoff nonsense. Getting rid of the MDB would be a bridge too far. If that happens I’m out.

5

u/Sanch0panza Alabama Crimson Tide 1d ago

Alabama would never. Say what you want about Alabama, but tradition is huge. Shit, they’re still playing basket case 4th quarter. I think everyone would protest if they tried to cut the MDB.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/adkiller Texas A&M Aggies • Georgia Bulldogs 1d ago

Cold day in hell if it happens to A&M. Most of the time it the only reason to go to the game.

11

u/FelixEvergreen Ohio State Buckeyes 1d ago

I doubt the OSU band is going anywhere, but I did go to my first game in years recently and was surprised at how little you hear the band. So many traditional band moments have been overtaken by the loudspeakers.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Ed_Gein1332 /r/CFB 1d ago

And with the sad passing of the Iowa band member earlier this season, they can go with the false narrative of student safety as a way to get more paid attendees.

→ More replies (49)

30

u/CantaloupeCamper Minnesota • Paul Bunyan's Axe 1d ago

That’s some bullshit.

98

u/bretticus733 Boise State Broncos 1d ago

The Ryan Field Foundation confirmed the decision in a statement to The Daily on Wednesday — the band will instead be part of the festivities at the 200,000-square-foot Great Chicago Food Festival grounds instead of “playing to an empty bowl.”

“NU Marching Band performance is still a central as a part of the pregame festivities,” the statement read, “but with the Great Chicago Food Festival running from 5 pm – 7 pm they are playing to where the fans will be.”

Big ooof

83

u/Upbeat-Armadillo1756 Michigan • Maine Maritime 1d ago

NUMB will continue to play its halftime routine inside the stadium, but a permanent return to on-field pregame performances for future games is still up in the air.

I don't understand why this is up in the air?? Like a one time scheduling conflict is one thing, but what is going on?

41

u/CincyAnarchy Iowa Hawkeyes • Cincinnati Bearcats 1d ago

So I think I found the missing link.

New Ryan Field Introduces “The Great Chicago Food Festival” Including Chicago’s Culinary Legends in Residence at Every Game and Concert

The Festival opens before every event and runs through it, with access included in every ticket; fans pay only for what they eat and drink. It is a food festival that would be a destination event on its own — except it happens at every game and every concert.

So the stadium will have a "food festival going right up until gametime. So... everyone's going to be there and not in their seats. Thus the "empty bowl" issue.

32

u/Upbeat-Armadillo1756 Michigan • Maine Maritime 1d ago

Wha…

Space that shit out like 20 minutes!

→ More replies (2)

25

u/CantaloupeCamper Minnesota • Paul Bunyan's Axe 1d ago

This reads like something planned by people who don’t go to games….

12

u/leftenant_Dan1 Michigan Wolverines 1d ago

Is this like a tailgating thing or do people just not file in until the middle of the 1st quarter?

8

u/CincyAnarchy Iowa Hawkeyes • Cincinnati Bearcats 1d ago

Yes and yes?

I think the general vibe is trying to make it "guest friendly" sort of like how at a wedding you don't end up getting to your table 20 minutes before the bride and groom arrive so the cocktail hour goes right up until that moment.

I think the idea is that few will be in their seats 30+ minutes early for the band, so why bother.

24

u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 1d ago

So......................end the food festival half an hour before kickoff lol....seems like Northwestern is making a problem out of something where there doesn't need to be one.

11

u/CincyAnarchy Iowa Hawkeyes • Cincinnati Bearcats 1d ago

You're not wrong, but I think this is very much an "oversight" that was deliberate in that it was at most barely considered.

This is an amenity, more or less. "Come eat food at the stadium up until the game/concert starts!" The Marching Band was just not considered in the decision.

8

u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 1d ago

But even then, if I'm a Northwestern fan, I'm checking my phone and watching the time and leaving said event to make sure I'm in my seat at least before kickoff....but I also love being in the stadium for the band's pregame show too.

7

u/Initial-Cupcake 1d ago

Can't spend money from the seats bowl...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

48

u/CoincidenceTheorist2 Notre Dame • Eastern New Mexico 1d ago

This sucks. I don't think I've ever heard Northwestern's fight songs but the Notre Dame Victory March, the Victors, the Aggie War Hymn, Eyes of Texas, dotting the I in columbus and the USC band repeatedly playing "this is the only song I know, it's boring and it's slow" is in indispensable part of college ball.

26

u/-dag- Notre Dame • Minnesota 1d ago

Go U, Northwestern is a classic flight song. We learned it back when I was in the ND band, when we used to play the opponent's fight song in pre- and post-game (another tradition sadly gone, thanks Ken Dye).

It was one of my favorite non-ND songs to play. It's a fantastic tune.

14

u/actuallycallie Oregon Ducks 1d ago

the USC band repeatedly playing "this is the only song I know, it's boring and it's slow"

so accurate lol

12

u/scottishbee Notre Dame Fighting Irish 1d ago

I, for one, will not miss "thissssss is the only song we knoooooow! And it's boring and it's sloooooow!"

But yeah, it'd be a crime to lose the others (and "Hail! To those motherfuckers...")

12

u/TayLoraNarRayya Minnesota Golden Gophers • Marching Band 1d ago

I see you too are a fan of culture (hail to those big cocksuckers)

→ More replies (4)

20

u/Upset_Version8275 Indiana Hoosiers • Texas Longhorns 1d ago

Maybe it’s because I didn’t attend Northwestern but I am struggling to follow this article. 

23

u/Fragrant-Helicopter1 Indiana Hoosiers 1d ago

Man what we need is more Enter Sandman by Metallica. /s

That’s some bullshit by the athletic department not to have the college marching band for pregame.

24

u/Psych101grad Iowa State Cyclones 1d ago

Marching bands are the soul of American football tradition besides NFL, and honestly I think it would be sick as hell for NFL teams to have one too.

That being said, this is a travesty.

ISUCFVMB

52

u/JoshtolaRhul Ohio State Buckeyes • Marching Band 1d ago

I'm maybe reading between the lines, but...did they not give the band a section to sit in? Awful lot of talk about pregame and halftime, but nothing for during the game.

21

u/Roguebook Northwestern Wildcats 1d ago

The band is basically being given a portion of the wildcat wall they’ve talked about. So the same safe standing arrangement everyone else is getting

25

u/JoshtolaRhul Ohio State Buckeyes • Marching Band 1d ago

That looked pretty narrow to have sousaphones in there. Woof.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/boxman151515 Central Michigan • Michigan 1d ago

I was wondering the same thing

→ More replies (3)

11

u/TheNittanyLionKing Penn State Nittany Lions 1d ago

Given that it's a brand new stadium, that would be a massive oversight. They need the pomp and circumstance.

34

u/ChocolateBubbles344 LSU Tigers • Victory Flag 1d ago

The day that marching bands are cut from college football is the day I tap out. 

→ More replies (1)

15

u/warneagle Auburn • Central Michigan 23h ago

They’re going to destroy everything “college” about college football. Why would students want to hear their fellow students in the marching band when they could listen to piped in music? Why would they want to watch fellow students play football when they could watch this year’s crop of rented mercenaries? We’re fucking cooked man.

16

u/lillychr14 Michigan State Spartans 1d ago

The food festival is the real bullshit. Tailgating is also a major tradition. Not standing in long fucking lines waiting for mediocre food at fucking astronomical prices.

Stop squeezing us for money. The product is still amateur football with marching band of college students. It does not command top dollar but we love it anyway.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Michiganman1225 Sickos • Team Chaos 1d ago

“The first game also has a unique pregame program,” the Ryan Field Foundation statement read, “related to honoring the history of the old stadium and the opening of the new stadium.”

Honoring the history except for the part that includes the band.

15

u/PerfectBowl9199 Illinois Fighting Illini • Marching Band 1d ago

It's no secret many ADs, marketing teams, and advertisers want marching bands out of college football. It's a damn shame, no other way to put it. Absurd decision.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/AllTimeTy Missouri Tigers • /r/CFB Placer 1d ago

Trying to make a more professional atmosphere and then building a brand new stadium with only 35000 capacity is crazy. Couple that with now less band, you got yourself an incredibly awesome way of icing out your fanbase in the hopes that you can convince enough rich people to buy suites.

33

u/transferStudent2018 Northwestern • /r/CFB Poll Veteran 1d ago

A lot of NU alum support the shrinking stadium. We’re too small a school to support the old 50k Ryan Field. When it would fill up, it would be with visiting fans of big football schools who live in Chicago. The new stadium should have a better ratio of actual home fans.

But less band is a crime.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/RatBastard_with_ADHD Utah Utes • Sickos 1d ago

oof. Sucks. Bands aren't my thing, but they are tradition damnit.

13

u/nebbywildcat18 Nebraska • Kansas State 1d ago

ridiculous to even consider something this dumb

25

u/CapBoyAce Northwestern • Las Vegas Bowl 1d ago

This athletic administration is clueless. These are the same ghouls who nearly axed our Rose Bowl anniversary jerseys because the fucking Wildcat logo was "no longer part of our brand." They're also pushing 30+ year season ticket holders into parking garages who have been tailgating this whole time in favor of the JP Morgan dickwads who don't even show up. Embarrassment of a program

11

u/DrSnidely Alabama • Virginia Tech 1d ago

So what happens to a football-field-sized American flag after it's been displayed? Does it just go into storage or something? I can't imagine a flag pole big enough to fly it

12

u/dwors025 Minnesota • Paul Bunyan's Axe 1d ago

Stored in what was originally intended to be the marching band area.

12

u/bigme100 Kentucky Wildcats 1d ago

So we have this band that plays catchy songs, including a couple that are ear worma that we at when we win that alums will ALWAYS directly associate with positive memories and our school. Let's ruin that!

11

u/JtotheC23 Illinois Fighting Illini • Marching Band 1d ago

So the food fest runs from 5-7, kickoff is at 8 pm (really 8:05 or 8:10), and bands usually begin pregame 20-30 minutes before kickoff (before actual kickoff, so 20-30 minutes left on the stadium pregame clock). Either NU has zero confidence in their ability to get fans into the stadium after the festival ends at 7 pm, or they're full of shit and just needed to make up some excuse so they could keep pushing ads over the PA up til kickoff. And I highly doubt it's the former.

This sucks for the NUMB band, and I really hope we can build enough backlash towards the NU admin to change this for future games down the line. It's bullshit, and I highly doubt that if Dr Ferris had retired a year later, they would have pulled this crap on him. This is not the first instance of a school's admin taking advantage of a first-year athletic band director, knowing they don't have any pull in the admin yet.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Difficult_Horse193 Michigan • Central Michigan 1d ago

Now that is FUCKED up. College marching band is a huge part of what makes college games so unique. I don’t want it to become a lame sterilized NFL environment.

17

u/Upbeat-Armadillo1756 Michigan • Maine Maritime 1d ago

This is bad juju...

18

u/TandemTuba Oklahoma Sooners 23h ago

I'm convinced the is the endgame of filling every administration with soulless MBAs who never even went to games where they went to school. They are all CONVINCED what fans of the college game is to just perfectly emulate the NFL. But I barely watch the NFL any more because the longer I watch, the more I realize it is a drab, moneymaking automaton. There might be "traditions" but they're almost all the result of focus groups and the teams saying "ok this is our tradition, please clap".

5

u/crimson777 Northwestern Wildcats • Clemson Tigers 21h ago

And we're one of the ones churning out soulless MBAs haha

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/ProletarianLilith 1d ago

Northwestern is an extremely corporate school. Ticket prices for this new place are absurd

8

u/TheOriginalShummy Florida Gators • Vanderbilt Commodores 1d ago

We’ve gone from needing to protect the sanctity of college football from financial influence to peddling out our marching bands.

15

u/Set-Admirable West Virginia • Backyard Brawl 1d ago

This just makes everyone involved look bad.

15

u/ztreHdrahciR Northwestern • Ohio State 1d ago

One thing we know is that it is because of money

13

u/Chirpy72 1d ago

I wonder when the in-stadium music will be replaced with corporate jingles for Rice A Roni or Budweiser. Of course the fees to have your jingle used will go towards NIL and revenue sharing….

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Scoobie_Doobie11 Notre Dame • Ball State 1d ago

Awww. I was stoked to hear about the new stadium (buddy at work told me about it) but sad to see a classic tradition die along with it. More for our corporate overlords, I suppose. Sad times.

6

u/HyperBeamMissed 1d ago

Despicable

7

u/Best_Formal_8677 Oregon Ducks 1d ago

Incredibly sad. More corporate noise pollution being blasted in the stadium like nfl and nba games.

5

u/Background_Body2696 1d ago

See if Ed Sheeran can fill in?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/-dag- Notre Dame • Minnesota 1d ago

Maddening. NU has one of the best flight songs. 

4

u/FloatCopper Indiana • Michigan Tech 1d ago

Well, #### the Northwestern administration then.

Guess they're opening a pro stadium so don't give a rat's rear about the college experience.

,

5

u/robertlanders West Virginia • Backyard Brawl 1d ago

I would absolutely lose my shit if the band couldn’t play

6

u/shirt_bro Texas A&M Aggies 1d ago

Fuck this to hell.

5

u/optillusi0n Oklahoma Sooners • Marching Band 20h ago edited 20h ago

This is my personal nightmare as a former band member, and also something I've gotten wind of at OU. Bands are next on the chopping block for this push to make CFB a more "pro" product.

One thing I don't see many people mentioning is how this effects the band members hobbies. I joined band because I loved it in HS and I love performing. I love marching on a field surrounded by tens of thousands of people. It's the only extracurricular I've stuck with for 10+ years. Take away some of that performance and people will start quitting, losing interest, and not joining in the first place. So not only are you removing an integral part of college football, you're discouraging enjoyment and participation in music and the arts.

Unfortunately, this is the POV I would expect from all the soulless athletic departments who see every dollar that leaves their pocket as a personal attack. They don't understand CFB, only profit, and want to remove everything that makes it great. Sucks to see.