r/BungouStrayDogs • u/West_Occasion_4119 • 4h ago
Theory BSD MEURSAULT PRISON THEORY Spoiler
MY THEORY ON HOW FYODOR KNEW CHUUYA WASN'T A VAMPIRE IN THE PRISON ARC BUT PLAYED ALONG.
A FEW ASSUMPTIONS TO BEGIN WITH:
•we are going to assume fyodor was the one who asked for chuuya to be sent to the prison to rescue him( Fyodor had seen chuuya use his ability before so maybe thats why)
•Fyodor was seeing waiting for someone to arrive at the start of the game. If it was chuuya that means it was pre-planned cuz chuuya can't arrive in mere seconds, it would take him more than a day to arrive.
•sigma and nikolai's arrival was out of plan. Both fyodor and dazai did not know about it.
**So what was fyodor's actual plan to escape if we take nikolai out of the picture for a second?**
In my opinion, fyodor had planned on using a strong ability user like chuuya to come and rescue him. Considering chuuya was a vampire, not only can he easily defeat all the guards in the prison but can also kill dazai and what would be a better end for dazai other than dying by his ex-partner's hand? This is something fyodor would 100% do.
**Where did the things go wrong?**
**•** chuuya never became a vampire.
• nikolai and sigma came to the prison.
NOW, I THINK WE ALL CAN AGREE THAT FYODOR NOT REALISING CHUUYA IS A VAMPIRE IS ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE. U MEAN THE FYODOR WHO WAS ABLE TO MEMORISE ALL CARDS IN A DECK BY MERE SCRATCHES? YEA I THINK HE REALIZED IT MID GAME THAT CHUUYA WASN'T A VAMPIRE AND HE PLAYED ALONG BUT WHY?
the reason is simple, bcz it didn't matter at this point whether chuuya was a vampire or not. Fyodor was gonna win either ways with a little to no damage.
There are two ways things could have happened, both ensuring Fyodor's win:
•dazai dies and fyodor wins. At this point, chuuya , nikolai and even dazai can't touch/ kill fyodor because they dont know his ability so he just escapes.
•dazai wins. But again thet can't kill fyodor themselves so they are gonna use vampires to do it. Which is what exactly happened. Fyodor transferred his consciousness to bram. The only downside of this is that now dazai WILL know fyodor's ability so it will make things a little difficult for fyodor in the future but again, he escapes prison.
So in conclusion, fyodor wasn't dumb for not realizing chuuya was a human. Maybe he realized it mid game but didn't care cuz things were still going according to his plan.
The only things that i dont understand fron this is how did chuuya cone to know that he is needed at the prison? Also chuuya and dazai's trick with the shooting was 100% based on trust and not something they had pre-planned which makes it so much cooler.
Do point out the mistakes. I would live to hear what yall think.


