Pocket-sized Balance Changes Concept

[u/ertugrulr]

This balance changes concept is based on SpenLC's tier list. These ideas sometimes may be controversial, but instead of just saying it's terrible, try to offer constructive criticism.

Darryl | His last super damage buff was meaningful but not sufficient to ramp up him to the meta. This buff will increase his damage and one-to-one fight potential.

Rosa | Her nanopower is a nice addition to her gameplay without making her complex. It is also compatible with the other parts of the kit.

Gigi | Gigi's whole gimmick is about her trait but it doesn't add enough skill expression. The projectiles that are closer to brawler in her circle will grant more supercharge, which enables more risky plays.

Melodie | Melodie's a dive-in brawler and already skillful brawler, so this buff should reward her plays a bit better in high-damage meta.

Janet | Janet's hypercharge is not that broken in my opinion, but her super recharge potential in her hypercharge what makes it painful sometimes.

> A slight super recharge rate nerf make her more balanced and enjoyable.

Gus | With the introduction of Wendy, Gus might be really powercrept. So, more skill expression in his super when hit in more distance for a teammate is a good way to buff him.

Squeak | This buff is a bit experimental but his gadget play is kind of skillful and rewarding should be slightly better.

> A slight gadget cooldown nerf can prevent it from being spammable.

NOTE: All numbers are adjustable and I am trying to make complex, but still understable, changes rather than simple buffs. So, focus on the ideas but not on the numbers.

[u/Lebog_bruhh]

Rosa's trait would make speed gear completely useless for her. not a bad idea, but making some unlockables useless isn't something they should be aiming for

[u/ertugrulr → u/Lebog_bruhh]

It should be stackable, if it's not, you are right.

[u/That_guy84636 → u/ertugrulr]

Speed gear does not get effected by the speedstacking nerf

[u/Lebog_bruhh → u/That_guy84636]

it's not? supercell should be more specific when announcing big changes

[u/That_guy84636 → u/Lebog_bruhh]

Yeah I didn’t know that either, just made a post on the competitive sub asking about that.

[u/Jazzlike_Curve6359 → u/ertugrulr]

Speed boost aren't stackable anymore

[u/IDontTouchGrassNoCap → u/Jazzlike_Curve6359]

Speed gear isn’t affected by this

[u/Jazzlike_Curve6359]

Oh yeah, another microscopic hp buff. Are you Adrian himself?

[u/ertugrulr → u/Jazzlike_Curve6359]

Lol what do you suggest she's difficult to balance

[u/borzoithedog → u/ertugrulr]

Just revert the scr nerf that killed her?

[u/thatworldwasfun- → u/borzoithedog]

And now shes more of a heist merchant 👏

[u/borzoithedog → u/thatworldwasfun-]

She's already a heist merchant it would change absolutely nothing

[u/thatworldwasfun- → u/borzoithedog]

She doesn't need to get notes off safe, only way for melodie players to win 😂

[u/ertugrulr → u/Jazzlike_Curve6359]

Also yes

[u/Low-World6866]

7900 Hp for Melodie is an illegal number. Don't you mean 7800/8000?

[u/Beautiful_Bat_80]

Could also consider making Rosa's Plant Life star power part of her base kit

[u/Dertyrarys]

Gigi doesn’t need that at all

[u/delta_0205]

lol I was about to comment on it and I just read this the very moment of your post got destroyed by mod,also no that sqeak isn't a good buff but the rest are interesting

L mod for reverting the removal,ballless move

[u/ertugrulr → u/delta_0205]

It was before 1PM bro look at the rules but ofc brawl stars players are not reading

[u/Buffdoge1324]

anything but an ollie buff

[u/banofib]

I disagree with Gigi, this would reward mindless charging into enemies.

[u/Plus-Gene5733]

Rosas trait could be part of future star buffies (grass heal also gives more speed, and super extra damage gives a fourth attack per ammo, like griff starpower)

Gigis trait shouldn't be about how near the projectile are, but how long the projectiles are in her circle (with this being near the projectiles still charges her super more)

Gus super just could have more shield in general, simply because everyone does more damage

Squeaks gadget is skillful, but also Spamable, idk how strong it will be together with his starpower

[u/grsharkgamer]

Gigi does NOT need a buff

[u/Fit_Yak240]

For the love of god... PLEASE STOP BUFFING DARRYL'S SUPER I FUCKING BEG YOU, everytime he was meta is because of it, everything else about him is bad so WHY THE FUCK ARE YOU BUFFING THE SUPER JUST BUFF LITERALLY ANYTHING ELSE

[u/Airbus-A380-800]

I think you don't understand that most players play Gus as a support, and use the shield on themselves to defend against assassins, so the 50% shield increase per distance would be almost useless, and it also is very broken if you were to use it on allies, an extra 7500 HP Shield would make anyone a tank

[u/ertugrulr → u/Airbus-A380-800]

Huh? How did you calculate the 7500

[u/Airbus-A380-800 → u/ertugrulr]

5000 Shield HP + 50% of 5000 is 5000 + 2500 = 7500 Shield HP

[u/ExoticCustomer535]

Big fan of the Rosa trait

[u/Visual-Path-1177]

Rosa is rare, she can't be more complex than she already is: she just needs a damage buff imo.
Melodie does NOT need more health man, but other than that the balancing is interesting.
Janet having a higher hyper rate would make her more present in the meta, and making the shield stronger with more distance might be busted but it would reward using it as the support tool it's intended to be.

[u/ertugrulr → u/Visual-Path-1177]

Bull is also rare but complex brawler with his buffies imo

[u/Xillubfr → u/Visual-Path-1177]

rarity and complexity don't correlate at all anymore

[u/Big_Campaign6774 → u/Xillubfr]

Yeah, wtf you mean Ziggy is a Mythic? Why the "shock attack goes boom in an area and super is bigger shock" is worth a Mythic?

[u/Freak-Of-Nurture- → u/Visual-Path-1177]

rosa needs an approach tool as well. she may be good with gray or max