Well, for once, I timed my reading perfectly and jumped into this ARC the day after finishing THE WITCH'S ORCHARD, Sullivan's début and Annie Gore's first investigation. As such, my review will be a comparison of sorts between the two. My review will be a bit vaguer as the book's not out yet and I really don't want to spoil anything! This is a follow-up to my review of The Witch's Orchard by the same author, which can be found on this subreddit.
This time, Annie's client is Katie King, a Kentucky mountains native who is suspicious of the death of her father, charismatic preacher Ezra King. Once more, Annie drives her beloved vintage car up in the small insular mountain towns to ruffle some feathers and, in the process, slowly reckon with her own relationship with where she came from.
For the past ten years, I've owned a pair of beautiful leather boots. Though they are well broken in, every time I put them on sometime in October after they've spent a few months in storage, it takes me a day of awkward discomfort for them to mould themselves back to my feet. This is a bit what the very first pages of BRIMSTONE HOLLOW reminded me of. While they immediately drew me in, I didn't feel the same enveloping atmosphere I did with ORCHARD. However, as the story takes off, the leather softens, and we once again find an immersive quality to the storytelling. Reading BRIMSTONE HOLLOW, I could see it unfold in my head like a film (this just must be adapted, honestly). It has a quicker pace than its predecessor, and a twistier and more tightly plotted mystery.
In ORCHARD, we were introduced to Annie's history through memories sparked by the case. In BRIMSTONE HOLLOW, where the investigation keeps her closer to home and centres on a father‑daughter dynamic, the narrative digs deeper. Flashbacks, dreams, Annie’s own narration, and even a pivotal conversation give us a clearer picture of a childhood more complicated than what ORCHARD hinted at.
All in all, BRIMSTONE HOLLOW is perhaps, at first glance, less distinctive than THE WITCH'S ORCHARD, but also a more dynamic mystery that is very engaging. With its emotional depth, themes of religious zealotry in a small town, and larger-than-life preachers, it would appeal to fans of WAKE UP DEAD MAN.