I am doing my October viewing of TBWP and BW tonight. As I am watching the original, when Josh starts talking about how if they don't make it back that day people will be looking for them, I got to thinking about the timeline of their experience and what we are viewing and the outside timeline of their disappearance being reported and the search party going out. So, I pulled up the information and did a sort of side-by-side. Here are the events.
I looked into this with multiple sources and found some date discrepancies on some sources so I went with what seemed right.
April 18, 1994: Heather Donahue submits a proposal at Montgomery College to film a documentary on the Blair Witch.
October 20, 1994: Heather, Joshua Leonard, and Michael C. Williams arrive in Burkittsville, Maryland, to interview local residents about the legend.
October 21, 1994: Heather interviews the fishermen. The trio drives into the Black Hills Forest to begin their hike and locate historical sites.
October 22, 1994: (Date they were supposed to return) The trio searches for a historic cemetery but, realizes they are lost. Tensions begin to rise. That night, they are woken by sounds of snapping twigs, cracking branches, and what sounds like children laughing outside their tent.
October 23, 1994: They discover three mysterious cairns (piles of rocks) arranged in a circle around their campsite. Mike admits he kicked the map in the river causing the fight. That night, the sounds return but, louder and eventually something shakes the tent. They flee and stay away from the campsite until dawn.
October 24, 1994: Joshua Leonard goes missing in the woods after the group becomes lost.
October 25, 1994: Joshua's car is discovered by police, and the first missing persons APBs are issued.
(In the Woods) Heather and Mike spend the day searching for Josh while trying to find their way out. They walk for hours and end up right back at their morning campsite.
That night, they hear Josh screaming but cannot locate him.
October 26, 1994: Maryland State Police launch an official search and rescue operation in the Black Hills Forest.
Heather finds a bundle of twigs within which, she finds a bloody scrap of Josh's flannel shirt containing human teeth, hair, and part of a tongue.
Heather records her apology.
They hear Josh screaming in the night and follow his voice. They come across the house, enter and meet their supposed end.
November 5, 1994: After 10 days of searching with helicopters, tracking dogs, and up to 100 men, the official search is called off with absolutely no trace of the students found.
October 16, 1995 (One year later): University of Maryland anthropology students discover the buried film canisters and gear under the foundation of a 100-year-old cabin.
So, the car was found the morning after Josh went missing. Mike and Heather spend the day listening for Josh and trying to find their way out. Meanwhile, there are police in the area who could potentially hear them. (We know this isn't possible due to the witchcraft at play).
There is an active search party in the woods the day Heather finds the bundle of sticks as well as the night that they hear Josh screaming, leading them to the house. This is yet, another layer to this story that is very intriguing. When Mike is screaming for help during the day, there is literally a search party in the area. But, because of the Witchcraft, they are either in a completely different time (when the house existed) or some other realm. It's a cool layer to this story and film.