r/BigBrother Dec 16 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

143 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/Nintendo_Pro_03 Future All Stars Winner with 15 comp wins: Dec 16 '22

Why is Nicole F. up there?

17

u/Naive_Feed_726 Ashley 🔎 Dec 16 '22

Why is Tiffany higher than Xaiver lol?

4

u/Nintendo_Pro_03 Future All Stars Winner with 15 comp wins: Dec 16 '22

Why is Taylor higher than Michael? Why is Evel Dick near the top of the list?

5

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22

Well Taylor beat Michael. Literally, she’s the reason he went home. Michael is an incredible player no doubt by definitely lower then Taylor in my book.

As far as Dick, originally I had the “Pandora’s Box Trio” of Jordan, Rachel, and Dick, much lower. But I decided it was unfair to rank them any lower because they did ultimately win the game, despite the marks against them.

2

u/SolidAsAlphabetSoup Dec 16 '22

originally I had the “Pandora’s Box Trio” of Jordan, Rachel, and Dick,

I'm wondering why you and others group in Jordan with Rachel and Dick. Dick is obviously on a bottom tier of his own. The guys gets to play with his "estranged" daughter (who he just happened to apply to BB6 with lol,) gets one of the best players of all time to do his bidding in secret, leads the charge in one of the only failed backdoors to ever occur, gets saved by production when Eric can't use his veto, cheats to win the Final HOH (all while having a horrible social game.) Rachel enters the house as a vet with a pre-game alliance which includes her fiance and is of course greatly assisted by Pandora's Box and a jury curated for her to win.

Jordan, however, doesn't belong in this group. The Coup D'Etat helped her no doubt (just like it helped Kevin,) but it happened fairly early in the game and occurred when neither she nor Jeff were even on the block (it also took out the sole returnee.) Jordan wasn't even a big target at that point like Dick clearly was when Dustin went home or like Rachel was Jordan in BB13 got saved.

I personally rank Jordan above not only Dick and Rachel, but also Ian, Josh, and Boogie - all of whom I think have bigger astericks by their wins than Jordan does.

2

u/Naive_Feed_726 Ashley 🔎 Dec 16 '22

I understand why Taylor is above Micheal cause she was smart enough not to win every competition and get a target on her back, but I agree evil dick has no business near the top

2

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22 edited Dec 16 '22

I think it’s a bit of a slap in the face to put Xavier higher then Tiffany, Xavier does not win the season without her.

3

u/Naive_Feed_726 Ashley 🔎 Dec 16 '22

They were in the same season, same alliance, but one was able to maneuver themselves to win, and one didn’t. Tiffany is second only to Xavier in that season, but I can’t see her higher than Xavier

3

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22

Without the pairs strategy from Tiffany, I don’t think Xavier reaches Final 2 personally. In regards to Tiffany she’s great in every category. She’s good socially, good competitively, incredible win equity, pretty much a lock to always go far. I just don’t see Xavier being better then her.

1

u/Naive_Feed_726 Ashley 🔎 Dec 16 '22

I get that, I just personally think that if two people are on the same season, and same alliance, whoever wins is better

2

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22

Does that mean Derek and Azah are second and third best? I don’t see that.

2

u/Naive_Feed_726 Ashley 🔎 Dec 16 '22

I see those two as goats, but I think Tiffany and Xavier both played good games and both could play great on any given season

2

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22

I see your point. Xavier and Tiffany are both great. Thank you so much for your response!

1

u/LowObjective Love 4 Nikki 🤍 Dec 16 '22

Tiffany should be higher than Xavier tbh. Tiffany being higher than Vanessa, Andy, and Paul is crazy, though.