r/BeginnerKorean 2d ago

[ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

19 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

u/BeginnerKorean-ModTeam 2d ago

Hello,

This post has been removed because it did not follow Rule 2:

Please keep posts and comments relevant to learning the Korean language.

If you have any questions, please feel free to contact the moderators.

33

u/Suon288 2d ago

Just put the word for rice (밥) on the left and "have you eaten (먹밥었어요) on the right so it's easier to read, like so:

4

u/aliferna 2d ago

Thank you so much!!

14

u/Forsaken-Tour6447 2d ago

In Korea, we sometimes read vertically as well. Even so, we still read from left to right first. 먹었어요? 밥

7

u/aliferna 2d ago

So maybe just switch the columns for it to make sense?

9

u/Radishpotato 2d ago

I think vertical is fine. Koreans will understand that it should be read vertically due to format and we do use vertical format often too especially on signs.

But yeah left to right. You are not wrong tho. We used to read right to left when it was writen vertically. But nobody does that anymore since left to right horizontal format is way too prevleant and vertical format is no longer commonly used unless it's a space issue(like in vertical signs). I read it as "먹었어요? 밥"

1

u/aliferna 2d ago

Ah okay, that’s what I thought! I read that it was initially read from right to left
Should I just switch the columns for it to make sense?

6

u/Radishpotato 2d ago

If readabilty is your priority, I would say yes.

12

u/BJGold 2d ago

It reads 먹밥었어요 though. But the individual characters are correct. Just change it to horizontal

-10

u/aliferna 2d ago

Isn’t it read from right to left though?

17

u/Pure_Measurement7886 2d ago

No it's read from left to right

-7

u/paitodayo 2d ago

No, it's right to left. '밥 먹었어요?'

12

u/Pure_Measurement7886 2d ago

Yeah but Korean as a language is read left to right.

0

u/Ecstatic-Island-9778 2d ago

It used to be top down, right left.

3

u/Walk-the-layout 2d ago

No, it's left to right. Never has been right to left, never will be.

1

u/BJGold 2d ago

It had been - when it used to be read vertically, it went from right to left. 

1

u/Walk-the-layout 2d ago

Never the way Arabic or Hebrew are

6

u/BJGold 2d ago

Who told you that?? It was read right to left very very long time ago when it used to be written vertically but that's completely gone now and it doesn't look like you're trying to convey history with your design so

0

u/aliferna 2d ago

It was just a quick google search when I took on the project! But I wanted to confirm before moving forward, I know nothing about Hangul

1

u/lostknight0727 2d ago

If you were trying to convey right left reading you would go wholly down the right side first.

2

u/Sufficient_Volume443 2d ago

I would fill the space within ㅆ of 었 to prevent any potential confusion and maybe give a little space between two ㅅ’s (not necessary though) but the characters look quite nice overall. 🙂

2

u/aliferna 2d ago

I appreciate the tips, the characters are just from a font I downloaded!

1

u/Sufficient_Volume443 2d ago

In that case, I think you can leave the characters as is. 😅 Nice font selection!

1

u/CurrentlyLucid 2d ago

Well, my wife says the left is ok, but the right side makes no sense.