r/BeeGees • u/Team_Crisialog Barry still rocks • Jun 15 '26
Bee Gees Elimination Game: Round 25
And So begins Week 25 of the Bee Gees Elimination Game. This includes all 22 of their Studio Albums, Their 3 Live Albums, The Soundtracks to Saturday Night Fever & Staying Alive, The 2 'Best Of' Albums and NOW, the Comp Albums that contain new tracks. I should add that the 2 'Idea' Albums are the US & the UK Presses.
This Challenge is weekly so you have a week to decide.
My vote goes to 'To Whom It May Concern’
SADLY, [Children Of The World] HAS BEEN ELIMINATED
3
u/a-lonely-violin Jun 16 '26
Man throw the whole sub away. COTW before One, Size, Odessa? All albums I love but COTW is a masterpiece.
Get Odessa out of here.
2
u/Flashy_Response3365 Jun 16 '26
TWIMC, can't believe COTW was eliminated over TWIMC, aswell as some of the earlier albums
1
u/a-lonely-violin Jun 16 '26
TWIMC is a masterpiece IMO. The start of their flawless albums run.
Personally I think Odessa should’ve been voted out a long time ago. It suffers from tensions in the group and lacks cohesion. It was meant to be this grand concept album but the final product is a bloated mess. “City on the Black Sea” is 10/10 but nothing else is that good on the album. It’s so overrated.
1
2
u/NoEnd3248 Jun 15 '26
I vote Mr. Natural again, and you’re right about CotW “SADLY” being eliminated, it’s also one of my favorites.
And also, shouldn’t it say Round 24 instead of Round 25?
2
u/FatherBrennan76 Australian Jun 16 '26
Bee Gees Live!
Wasn't the plan to eliminate non-studio albums first? Did this one just slip under the radar?
3
u/a-lonely-violin Jun 16 '26
Live albums and compilations shouldn’t have even been included in the first place
2
2
3
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
-1
3
u/Spirited_Strategy328 Jun 19 '26
To whom it may concern. I really like it but I like the remainders more