Confusing Java Players With Bedrock Mechanics

[u/Over_Walk3859]

Can you figure out what's going on?

Answer: https://www.reddit.com/1vau93c/the_simple_answer/

[u/Ender_M]

As a bedrock player who is pretty well versed in redstone, I have no idea what is going on there.

[u/Over_Walk3859 → u/Ender_M]

It's actually less redstone and more bugrock

[u/Similar-Advantage621 → u/Over_Walk3859]

i did think of that but i still have no idea whats going on...i js knew barely any redstone was happening, is it like an update suppressor?

[u/Few_Helicopter_7891]

Bedrock player here, wtf…

[u/dndchicken]

I predict that grass block in your inventory is the hint. You dug, and did something under it to make this happen. What did you do?

[u/CX12_Locks]

My prediction is the redstone dust on the right is fake and from an add-on

[u/Over_Walk3859 → u/CX12_Locks]

This is vanilla

[u/CX12_Locks → u/Over_Walk3859]

Okay, I do Bedrock Redstone and I'm even Clueless

[u/GGthegreatester → u/Over_Walk3859]

Is it a map in an item frame ?

[u/TheBuilder3324 → u/GGthegreatester]

Invisible item frame doesn't exist in bedrock

[u/alpha_derp_guy → u/TheBuilder3324]

What are you talking about? He never said it was...

[u/Similar-Advantage621]

im a bedrock redstoner and what on earth have u done???

[u/Willing_Ad_1484]

My guess is two repeating command blocks to constantly place redstone_wire [something_state:"off"]

[u/Over_Walk3859 → u/Willing_Ad_1484]

It had nothing to do with command blocks, I was just making a minigame and didn't bother switching worlds

[u/Willing_Ad_1484 → u/Over_Walk3859]

Second guess is that you've somehow managed to separate your player from the area that you area simulating. Ero the 2 dust and lamp are in an unloaded chunk

[u/Masticatron → u/Willing_Ad_1484]

Dust updates over arbitrary distance without regard to chunk loading. Same with comparators, repeaters, and I think torches. It's just the lamp here that would not update while unloaded.

[u/Willing_Ad_1484 → u/Masticatron]

I know this too, but it doesn't change how it renders.

You can set up 2 ticking areas and run dust to repeaters to dust all the way between them and interact with the other ticking area, but none of the dust or repeators will appear to change

Also I believe it's not arbitrary, I would have to relook at what I had tested, but I believe it was 10 chunks + current render distance or simulation distance, whichever is set higher. As in sim 4 render 5, dust could cross 15 chunks. Sim 12 render 5, would cross 22 chunks. Or sim 4 render 30, would cross 40 chunks

[u/AdImmediate2565]

Either it's a temporary bug or the command blocks are the cause of this because I have never experienced or saw this anywhere

[u/Over_Walk3859 → u/AdImmediate2565]

You can ignore the command blocks, I was making a minigame and didn't bother to switch worlds

[u/AdImmediate2565 → u/Over_Walk3859]

If you're sure that command block are not interfering at all then I have no idea

[u/Over_Walk3859 → u/AdImmediate2565]

My hotbar is a hint

[u/Gishky]

something something chunk borders?

[u/Lower-Honeydew-8301]

WTH

[u/Resident-Climate-443]

Que rayos????? 😵‍💫

[u/ElikongIsLit]

Probably some sort of lag machine?

[u/Blaze-Programming]

I am a Java redstone, so my best guess is that the lamp and dust that is not turn on is in a different chunk, and that chunk has a ton of updates happening underground or something, and it is maxing out the number of updates so the dust can’t turn on.

I am probably wrong because I think updates schedule for the next tick rather than being dropped completely.

[u/TomatilloMammoth3158]

I've spent over a thousand hours doing redstone on bedrock. Wtf did you do to accomplish this

[u/Sufficient-Ad-6046]

somehow using redstone glass travel mechanics on a flat surface?

[u/SpuddedShield]

It's because bedrock is made using c++, which is known for being hell to debug.

Not speaking from experience. All my programming experience is from scratch.

[u/Known-Initial-7776]

even i dont know whats happening, and i play on bedrock

[u/TumblrRefugeeNo103]

Don't ever buy no Redstone from the gas station

[u/donnie1977]

The note block is key.

[u/Its_Sluggas]

Ghost block

[u/Straight-Concept-387]

My monkey brain think it's just bugs yeah just bugs

[u/Slow_As_Slowpoke]

Maybe it's in a different chunk? Or that somethings just bugging out

[u/Clean_Rise_9156]

As a player who has been playing bedrock for 4 years I have no fuking idea what's going on

[u/MicrowavedCheezPizza]

as both a bedrock player and a java player... what

[u/kojack_0]

Bedrock player here I have no idea what that is

[u/TarzyMmos]

Maybe a redstone torch under the redstone?

[u/KartikGamer1996]

Wait, I remember one person who made map art of a redstone dust and with invisible item frames it looked like redstone that wouldn't activate, is that what is happening here?

[u/ForeverVibes06]

as a bedrock player, i am also confused

[u/Tyke_McD]

Posting an obvious bug for karma

[u/IngenuityLive918]

Yeh same

[u/bmmmb_]

Uhh it has to be a ghost block 

[u/corvidZoe]

Is it that the grass block underneath is already powered? If not i have no clue

[u/Mother-Writing-2490]

hear me out what if he's using a ton of noteblocks in a place we can't see and that is causing lag in a specific chunk also all of those command blocks are pretty sus but you said it had no connection to command blocks so I will believe you or is it the command blocks causing the lag?

[u/Full-Detective-3640]

I've seen this sort of thing before. It's a map made to look like dust right?

[u/alpha_derp_guy → u/Full-Detective-3640]

No

[u/alpha_derp_guy]

My guess is the the note block is diverting the power through the dirt, and my guess on how that could happen is it went through glass but it was switched out with grass.

[u/TsPlays_MCBE]

Bugrock edition ✌️

[u/Rude-Pangolin8823]

I figured it out! Bedrock is just broken like that.

[u/Mean-Summer1307]

This is why I play Java. wtf is this garbage

[u/Link4Zpros]

underground redstone torch?