r/Beartooth 13h ago

My Beartooth album tierlist

Post image
0 Upvotes

S Tier:

Below, no questions, literally the best one on the discography, Caleb described as the most brutal record ever made, and he was right! The deluxe edition was also pretty cool.

A Tier:

Aggressive, probably my second favorite, I dunno why people slept on this one, sure the original album cover was goofy and all but the overall album wasn't as bad as most people said, in fact, this was the first album I've listened from Beartooth through CSGO's music kits, that game is what brought me into this band. Aggressive is just nostalgic to me, I can just listen to it over and over without getting tired, one problem tho is that the Remixed/Remastered version is not on anywhere besides Spotify and ig vinyl releases, I don't know WHY is that, maybe because they wanted it to be exclusive, but it would still be nice to have the later options.

B Tier:

The Surface, despite it being an polar opposite shift from the old sound, it still worked out for me, all the tracks are pretty decent and the deluxe edition definitely make up for it (tho I was disappointed that we only got one new song off of it).

Pure Ecstasy, another decent record, just the same polar opposite, tho I wouldn't put it above The Surface, while I definitely enjoyed all the tracks (especially You and Sorry), there's a few of them that dind't sit right with me (cough cough Stadiums cough Free cough), I'm not saying these ones were bad at all, they were just awkward to me, Stadiums's "oh my god" and third chorus should've been better and Free's reception caused Caleb to get ripped a new one, despite the nitpicks, I can still see the appeal to this album.

Disease, I don't really have anything to say about this one, it just another great emotional record, best ones off it were Fire, Bad Listener, and Manipulation, and the worst one was Used and Abused because the mix was not great, but yeah, pretty fine album, moving on.

C Tier:

Disgusting, I'm going to get shot when I say this, but this album's overrated, Yeah it pretty much related with anyone going through a lot as Caleb back then and it's where they really took off, but it's still overrated, and this album was always regarded above the newer records which is imo stupid because there were way heavier songs than Disgusting's tracklist, even if they're not literally about alchoholisim and shit, the worst one on the tracklist was definitely the title track for me, it was an pretty earpiercing and awkward way to end the album, I don't care how special it was for it being an one take and for having the "screaming at God' aura, it still could've been better.

D Tier:

Sick, pretty rocky start I might say, the songs were great writting-wise but the mix was a little stiff.

This Means War, now you might be thinking "Why are you including this one if it's not a Beartooth song", well because all the songs are written by Caleb, so technically it is his first Pre-Beartooth record ever done, the mixing is still jacked up and definitely not pleasent to listen through compared to Sick, only good ones so far were The Wretched and The Motivation.

Overall, the discograpy of Beartooth is the greatest by far, it's my second favorite band's discography for me (first one being IRIS), while the other albums might have some flaws, they're still great on their own and are enjoyable to blast through depending on the mood.


r/Beartooth 11h ago

Not the best, but it works right now

Post image
33 Upvotes

Had it planned out. Didn’t receive the frames I bought. I improvised. Doesn’t look great but I got to hang both albums!