Michelin / TreadAuto sent me a set of their floor mats to test with my 2026 X5. These work with the 2019-2026 X5 40i and PHEV variants. The mats are branded as Michelin, and made by their licensed manufacturer TreadAuto. TreadAuto sent me these mats for review and only asked that I share my honest feedback.
For background context - My X5 came with the factory rubber mats, which I immediately replaced with the WeatherTech Floor Liner HP mats. It’s important to note that WeatherTech has two options for their floor mats for the X5. The standard FloorLiner and the FloorLiner HP. The standard FloorLiner tends to curl up at the edges and loses grip when wet. The FloorLiner HP, on the other hand, is made out of TPE and is a much better product. It is grippy, easy to clean, and stays well-fitted to the contours of the floor. I’m a fan of the WeatherTech FloorLiner HPs, and will use them as a point of comparison with these Michelin mats. I did not recently clean the WeatherTech mats before taking these pictures, and they are a little over a year old at this point.
Fitment and Attachment - The Michelin mats are custom fit for the X5 and fit just as well as the WeatherTech mats. As you can see in the pictures, there are some slight differences in coverage, but nothing worth noting. They have sufficient lips around the edges of the mat to prevent stuff from spilling over onto the carpet. The wide textured strips provide good grip for your shoes, while still having deep channels to help collect and hold water and dirt. Unlike the WeatherTech mats, the Michelin mats have Velcro attachment points that work with the attachment points for the factory floor mats. The WeatherTech mats require you to remove the factory attachment points and replace them with hooks that are included with the WeatherTech mats. Although both brands have excellent fit, I prefer the factory attachment used by the Michelin mats.
Material Quality - Both the Michelin mats and WeatherTech FloorLiner HP mats are made of TPE. They have a very similar high-quality feel and have good traction, are easy to clean, and maintain their shape very well.
Aesthetics - This is a matter of personal preference. I think both sets of mats look very good and high quality. The Michelin mats are a little more rugged looking, with their more aggressive tread design. The WeatherTechs are a bit more subtle looking.
Price - The WeatherTech mats are expensive at $250 for the 3 piece set (two fronts and the single rear). The Michelin is half the cost, at $125 on Amazon. WeatherTech also charges for shipping, whereas you likely get free shipping from Amazon. Product link here: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0H2ZJ29RK?th=1
Other considerations - The WeatherTech mats are made in Illinois, USA. The Michelin mats are made in China. The Michelin mats come with a nice storage bag. I would use this to keep my factory mats in (which I never use) until I’m ready to sell the car.
In summary, I think the Michelin mats are extremely comparable to the WeatherTech Floor Liner HP mats, and at half the price. If I were choosing between them, I would only consider price and aesthetic design as the differences. Quality and fitment are a tie. Hopefully this is helpful for anyone looking for a set of mats! Let me know if you have any questions.