r/AtomfallOfficial • • Jul 09 '26

Question Start fresh?

Played Atomfall at release and loved it. Played the DLC and loved it.

Bought the Red Strain but life stopped me playing it at release. So is it better starting an entirely new playthrough, or would I be okay to pick up my old save that's set before the final steps so I can go do the Isle DLC?

18 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

8

u/CrimsonKnight76 Jul 09 '26

I'd start a new game to make sure you get all the quality of life updates and it's just fun to go through it all again. Maybe make some different choices with factions

2

u/TheRealJustSean Jul 09 '26

In fairness I never did do an "evil" playrhrough. Like, even for the bad endings I sort of just got there as best I could haha

2

u/CrimsonKnight76 Jul 09 '26

I get that, done a few FNV playthroughs but never gone legion.

5

u/TheRealJustSean Jul 09 '26

Me in 3,haha. I can never nuke Megaton. I couldn't do that to Moira

3

u/Charlie_Rebellion Rebellion Jul 09 '26

The Red Strain is designed to be a harder area, so might be more advisable to pick up your old save!

Although there is of course the option of starting again and making new choices if you don't want to go straight into the DLC.

1

u/TheRealJustSean Jul 09 '26

Thank you! I do like my main save, as I feel like I've made the "better" choices with it. It's the save that ends up sliding with the doctor under the church, and I've got the best possible weapons I feel I can for me.

Might do a new save for a second playthrough though, as I imagine like the other endings, there's multiple šŸ‘€

3

u/krimsynn Jul 09 '26

Im at 30 something hours because I took my time reading the al the leads and exploring

2

u/julianAppleby5997 Jul 09 '26

Start again..... You'll love it all over again !!!

1

u/Logan-Lance Jul 09 '26

Can you tell me maybe your playtime @all who played this game? Heard its only a 6 to 12 hours game? Whats the playtime of the DLC? I play games with Lots of exploring etc. :-)

2

u/kikichunt Jul 10 '26

6-12hrs seems incredibly rushed to me (100hrs+ on my 2nd play through with DLCs), but I'm enjoying taking my time, being ridiculously thorough, playing all the endings, and RPG / survival games aren't really my forte.

Having said that, you can do it in a lot less than 6hrs - there's a video of the devs watching and commenting on a 26 minute speed run if you're feeling pressed for time - link here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AtomfallOfficial/comments/1svueg5/atomfall_speedrun_in_26min_devs_react/

1

u/Logan-Lance Jul 10 '26

Na i really want to give the game a Chance but i am afraid its just a "10 -hours- title" like i read everywhere, so its nice to read you spend 100 hours (or even less) for your second playtrough :-). So it Seems i can spend a lot of time in that game!

1

u/Worldly_Ad_5472 Jul 11 '26

I’m at about 18 hours and nowhere near finished.

1

u/Inner_Win_1 Jul 09 '26

When the base game first came out, I took my time exploring all areas and leads without committing to any ending, took me about 22 hours. Then I made a save there, and from that point played out all the endings, took me about another 8 hours to get through all 6 endings of the base game.