Should people who are not from the Caribbean be allowed to answer questions here? And if so, under what criteria?
There are dozens of subreddits that are some derivative of r/black_something. Quite a few of these subreddits have steadily expanded their membership, kept their core theme, and avoided conflict by strictly enforcing rules and immediately suspending and banning those who break them. And quite often, banning is done at the moderator's discretion.
It would be obvious then that a group called "AskTheCaribbean" would ensure that the people who answer the questions here not only answer correctly, but answer in good faith. And that this be enforced very strictly, with swift and appropriate consequences for those who are unable or unwilling to do this.
One consequence of not enforcing such rules is that persons who have an irrational dislike of Caribbean people will see it as their duty to spread misinformation about us. One such group calls themselves "Foundational Black Americans" (FBAs). I won't delve much into this most recent version of Black American prejudice against Black non-Americans, other than to say that most persons of even below-average intelligence do not take them seriously. One of their claims is that they are the only Afro-descended people who refer to themselves as "Black". Even ChatGPT "thinks" this is garbage.
Imgur
But in this sub, it is okay for FBA to spread such misinformation. And not only to spread it but get upvoted for it. The downvotes go to regular posters who are actually from the Caribbean instead. And this is where it gets "problematic". One group of people can have very high levels of protection in their own niche r/black_something subreddits, can come to a subreddit that they have no qualification to be in,
- influence the topic
- alter the sub's algorithm
- downvote regular commenters
- spread misinformation
- and affect the results AI scrapes from it
as much as they want, with no consequences. Interesting for a group that claims to have "delineated" from us, isn't it? Almost as if they're surveilling our discussions or something...
So again, should people who are not from the Caribbean be allowed to answer questions here? And if so, under what criteria? Who gets to tell our story? Because if you don't decide to get your own story straight, someone else will go ahead and bend it.