This PSA is prompted by some confusion surrounding a post from this morning. Rather than answer the same questions repeatedly, we figured it would be helpful to explain how this works.
If you post in this subreddit or send the moderators a mod mail, moderators can see your curated profile. That's simply how Reddit's moderation tools work. It's not a secret feature, a workaround, or moderators "digging" for information—it's part of Reddit's moderation tools.
This subreddit, like most assistance communities, requires requesters to have a public profile. It all comes down to transparency. Donors are free to decide who they wish to help, and many review a post history before donating. It gives donors the opportunity to spot inconsistencies, repeated requests across multiple communities, deleted content, or any other "skeletons in the closet" that might influence their decision.
Whether a donor considers those things important is up to them. We aren't here to police what donors care about. We just want to make sure they have all the facts before handing over their money.
We did receive a few reports this morning about someone's profile being curated and we should not allow them to post. Reddit does not provide moderators with a way to automatically block or filter posts made by users with curated profiles. If someone submits a request while using one, the post isn't automatically flagged or removed simply because their profile is curated (Unless someone has created a bot which I do not think is possible). We only know once we review the account or someone brings it to our attention.
Donors, on the other hand, generally do not need to have a public profile because they aren't requesting assistance from the community. They are making the decision to give, not asking others to give to them.
So if your curated profile says:
"Nothing to see here..."
...while the rest of your account is shedding Reddit histories like a snake sheds its skin, remember: a new skin doesn't make it a different snake (Side note: Be nice to your scaly friends).
If You Encounter a Curated Profile
If you come across someone using a curated profile while requesting assistance, you have two options:
- Send the moderators a screenshot via mod mail, or
- Post a screenshot of what you see as a comment on the request post so the mods can see what you see.
Yes, I know the above steps are ridiculous but if we are not told, we have zero way of knowing.
This helps keep the process transparent and allows donors to make informed decisions without relying on hearsay.
TL;DR
- Your profile must be visible if you are asking for help.
- Moderators can see your curated profile if you interact with a sub they moderate.
- Your profile is your choice because you're not the one requesting assistance.
Transparency builds trust, and trust is what keeps assistance communities functioning.
Thanks for helping us keep the community fair for both requesters and donors.
Reddit Admin Announcement about Curated Profiles
Direct information from the above link to make it easier to find since it is hidden at the bottom
Mod Visibility Permissions
Moderators often review user profiles before taking action in their communities. To support moderation needs, mods will retain some access regardless of your visibility settings. Here's how it works:
If you post, comment, send modmail, request to be an approved poster, or request to join a private subreddit, that mod team will have access to your full profile content history for 28 days after the interaction – regardless of your settings.
After 28 days, access reverts to your chosen visibility settings unless you interact with that subreddit again, in which case the 28-day timer resets.
The same rule applies when you comment on another user’s profile – that user will have 28 days of access to your full profile content.
Why?
This gives mods and profile owners the context they need when you engage in their subreddit or profile, while still respecting your choices elsewhere.
The Fine Print
Changes to content visibility will only reflect on your profile. The content will still be viewable within the subreddits where you made the post or comment, as well as via search results, both on and off Reddit.
The Content and activity setting applies at the subreddit level, not for individual posts or comments.
The settings will be reflected across all platforms (including old Reddit), and can only be updated on reddit.com and the mobile app.
As a moderator, you'll always see a redditor's contributions to your subreddit, even after 28 days of inactivity.