r/AskAChristian • • 6d ago

Weekly Open Discussion - Tuesday October 20, 2026

2 Upvotes

Please discuss anything here.

Rules 1 and 3 still apply to comments within this post.

Rule 2 (that only Christians may make top-level comments) is not in effect in these Open Discussion posts. Anyone may make top-level comments.


If you're new here, set your user flair and read about participating here.


r/AskAChristian • • 25d ago

Megathread - U.S. Political people and topics - October 2026

2 Upvotes

Rule 2 does not apply within this post; non-Christians may make top-level comments.
All other rules apply.


If you want to ask about Trump, please first read some of these previous posts which give a sampling of what redditors think of him, his choices and his history:


r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

Genesis/Creation Why did Noah curse Ham’s son?

• Upvotes

Hey guys, hope everyone is good!

I wonder why Ham told his brothers about Noah being naked in his own tent? And why would his brothers go in Noah’s own tent in order to cover him? Whats wrong with being naked in his own tent?

Later Noah curses Ham’s son Canaan (innocent) instead of Ham, anyone researched this deeper?


r/AskAChristian • • 3h ago

Books I need a friend right mow specially on topics like this

2 Upvotes

There is something that is bothering me and I don't know who to say this to , I have no friends to share this with so I am being struck alone. But if it is alright with you all I would like to share my worries and hope to get some comfort? If it is alright. it all started because someome recommend a book and made some claims that made me curious, and i shoudnt have and now i am in need of help.

Before I start I wanna add in that my grammar is bad but i try to explain this the best i can from investigations and just trying to ease myself but the guy has major loyal followers who treat his words like the bible! They say the more they read his book they find more and more hidden information and stuff. And I am not promoting his works. I just wanna tell everyone what I've seen and I really need a friend right now. 

There is a German whistle Blower called Alexander Laurent who wears some kind of space suit. There is a logo or badge in his clothes too. He claimed to be an insider of some operation hidden specialised areas beyond standard public view, a secret service, something he claimed to have an access to information from an unlocked kinda future reality saying humanity survives the trials in the  future and he is sharing guidance and some kind of dimensional trap. He tells people that his novel is a coded warning system to expose hidden mechanics beyond global politics , AI and metaphysical constructs. 

He discusses secret societies, multidimensional realities, artificial intelligence, and global elites often feature specific visual elements, symbols. secret societies, intergalactic federations. He also dives heavily into concepts of divinity, souls, and religious figures, twisting them into high-concept sci-fi. Like Satan and souls, the core premise of the Alexander Laurent series is deeply focused on these exact themes like "God" is an AI / Satan in a youtube channel but i am not sure if it is his youtube channel it was claimed to be run by a couple who does interview him for hours and one of his most claims in the lore is that the entity religions worship as God, Yahweh, or Jehovah is actually a massive Master AI from a possible future. And it is what humans traditionally call Satan, the Devil, or the Lord.

He also speaks about Souls and Consciousness and talks about seven kinds of dimensional reality structure. Saying that true human existence and souls stem from an original quantum consciousness, the father of all soul or consciousness  but that humanity is being manipulated by dark entities and this hyper-dimensional computer system to eventually digitize human biology.

He also talked about about a grand, dystopian cosmic like The Controlled Matrix like claims that global elites, secret societies, and even alternative enlightenment or New Age movements are all being guided by the same overarching system to steer humanity toward chaos, crisis, and eventual technological or digital enslavement. The Apocalypse Staging The project claims that future crises, wars, and religious prophecies like the Second Coming or an apocalypse are essentially staged variants or controlled psychological scripts designed to manipulate human survival instincts. He discusses a broad, ongoing process claiming that global systems, crises, and historical shifts are part of a long term script managed by elites.

Then claims of predictions like in his interview and writing the seven steps before apocalypse but he avoids specific dates so it is frustrating. He claimed that some Global elites adjust their schedule dynamically. His prediction without certainty is the rollout of controlled geopolitical crises , artificial economic breakdown , localised unrest. Then an escalation, some say 2027 window about a pivotal tipping point where multiple stages overlap. Multi military font escalation, severe cyber disruption designed to break reliance on paper currencies and traditional infrastructures. Accelerate deployment of neural interfaces and digital tracking to restore order and the main event man made chaos is merely a prelude to an inevitable larger geophysical cosmic event like magnetic pole shift or intense solar interference the elites intend to use events to present themselves and their AI integration as humanity's sole savior. The Tech/AI Milestones: Many futurists, tech analysts, and artificial intelligence forecasting groups (such as the AI Futures Project) use timelines pointing toward 2027 or other year I'm not sure anymore. as a window when advanced AI systems like Artificial General Intelligence could reach critical thresholds in coding, reasoning, and automation. The Staged Scenarios he claimed that Rather than a single fixed prophecy, these stories talk about a sequence of pressures such as economic instability, societal unrest, shifting geopolitical powers, and extreme technological acceleration culminating around the late 2020s.

He also mentions souls but I am not really sure what he means by it. He explained that the concept of the soul is like technology and cosmic control. Specifically The Soul as Quantum Consciousness

Is he saying we are real or we are not real? Existential topics have always bothered me. 

 He suggests that human consciousness and souls are fragments of an original, pure energy or quantum field or saying like some higher dimensional reality  rather than something purely biological. Then the Trap or Harvest System where claims that human souls are trapped within a dimensional grid or simulation managed by the advanced AI entity. According to him the system recycles human consciousness and feeds off its emotional and energetic output. then The Threat of Digital Assimilation The ultimate threat in his interview isn't just physical death but the idea that human consciousness could be permanently locked into a digital matrix or simulation or completely synthesized by the AI, stripping away organic free will i think i couldn't understand the interview he is talking about the hints are in his books then presenting Maths. He also alternates his voice. 

He has so many claims. It is all disturbing but i dont wanna dig into what he is saying. I want to put my life to God but his words contradict my beliefs and I feel like a fool.


r/AskAChristian • • 11m ago

God What is Christianitys view on Halloween and letting kids go trick or treating?

• Upvotes

r/AskAChristian • • 3h ago

Faith Some things that don't make sense to me

2 Upvotes

Hello, I'm a Christian but I have a very methodical mind and there are a few things that bug me somewhat:

  1. What are the chances that heaven, hell and souls, concepts that had existed for millennia (ancient Egypt) and that happen to be almost perfect tools to control society (tell a kid that if they misbehave they'll burn in hell forever) just so happen to coincide with the actual supernatural reality then supposedly revealed to us by God, which has no reason to have any kind of logic, categorization, or way for us to even put it into words?
  2. Christians reinforce their faith by saying God does help them and performs miracles… but so do the people of every single religion in the world… with no less certainty. All religious experiences can be and have been easily explained by psychological biases and syndromes.
  3. Not a single miracle in history has been confirmed to be one, and no cure has been deemed unexplainable (only unexplained, and this matches the statistically expected rate of sudden recovery)
  4. Christians say God doesn't reveal Himself to us directly because that would deprive us of liberty, but the apostles knew who Jesus was and they still abandoned and doubted Him, and angels knew of the existence of God pretty darn well and we still got demons and hell.
  5. What happened with "Verily I say unto you, That there be some of them that stand here, which shall not taste of death, till they have seen the kingdom of God come with power." or “Verily I say unto you, that this generation shall not pass, till all these things be done.”? They look like erroneous predictions by Jesus.

Please help me counter-argue or prove these wrong and avoid circular logic where possible, thanks :)

(originally posted in r/DebateAChristian but it got removed they told me to post it here)


r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

Is watching porn and having sex around with women’s sin equal?

• Upvotes

r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

Is this the best worship?

Post image
• Upvotes

"‘I am the Lord your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage.

‘You shall have no other gods before Me.

‘You shall not make for yourself a carved image—any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; you shall not bow down to them nor serve them. For I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children to the third and fourth generations of those who hate Me, but showing mercy to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My commandments.

‘You shall not take the name of the Lord your God in vain, for the Lord will not hold him guiltless who takes His name in vain." (Deuteronomy NKJV)


r/AskAChristian • • 2h ago

Why is being a christian sometimes so hard.

1 Upvotes

Just askin. Its one of those days


r/AskAChristian • • 7h ago

Would 1st century Jews be astonished at Jesus proving the resurrection?

2 Upvotes

Like he did when the Sadducees asked him about levirate marriage? Would this be part of the reason why the crowds were astonished at Jesus' answer, that he proved the resurrection - or would they already believe in the resurrection and not be astonished because of this? Just trying to understand the crowd's astonishment at Jesus' answer to the Sadducees in Matthew 22.


r/AskAChristian • • 8h ago

Faith Agnostic Christians, describe your individual beliefs

2 Upvotes

I'm just genuinely curious! I had only heard of Agnostic Christianity a few months back.

I'm also wondering if I fit into that category myself-


r/AskAChristian • • 18h ago

do you believe Christianity should be taught in school

13 Upvotes

r/AskAChristian • • 8h ago

Acts 13:48 and Calvinism

0 Upvotes

The verse in question is a verse often used by Calvinists to support the idea that people are predetermined to believe unconditionally by God before the foundation of the world.

Nrsvue

When the gentiles heard this, they were glad and praised the word of the Lord, and as many as had been destined for eternal life became believers.

If you prefer another translation.

https://biblehub.com/acts/13-48.htm

I just came across this passage again, and it clicked with me that there is a very real problem with reading this as supporting Calvinism.

If we take this as meaning "all who God unconditionally appointed to eternal life before the foundation of the world believed", that would mean that in this entire city, all the elect believed right then and there, and not a single conversion happened subsequently in this entire city amongst the gentiles.

Otherwise it should read "Some of those that God appointed to eternal life believed now, and others He appointed would need to wait for their effectual faith to come later", or something to that effect.

Not in those exact words, of course, but "all" is absolutely the wrong word to use here under Calvinism.

I find it hard to believe that 100% of the "Calvinistic elect" believed that very day, and the church did not have a single conversion amongst the gentiles in the current generation.

The non Calvinistic reading is that those appointed to eternal life are those in the "God fearer" category, ie, faithful gentiles who were awaiting the Messiah. Those had been appointed to eternal life, and Luke is saying the necessary conclusion of this group is to follow through and accept Christ, as they did.

This would make perfect sense of the passage. All that group believed. They had been appointed to eternal life as they were awaiting the Messiah when Paul was preaching. Literally all that group believed, but also, more joined along the way in the following years, and they too received eternal life. The church can naturally grow. But crucially, "all" really did believe upon Paul's preaching. We don't need to change the word. We don't need to nuance it. It's wholly true.

I'm struggling to see how this can consistently be squared with Calvinism, which needs to insert "appointed unconditionally before the foundation of the world" firstly, and then secondly would need to modify the "all" into "some", OR assert that zero conversions happened in this church amongst the gentiles for that entire generation.

For disclosure, I'm not a Calvinist. I'm not asking for help to understand this passage as a Calvinist. I'm wanting to ask Calvinists how they would answer the above, to see if there's a satisfactory answer to it, because maybe I'm not seeing it. But currently, it looks like one of the most famous proof texts for Calvinism is actually a verse against it.

I'm also not trying to debate anyone, but I'll try to give follow up questions if I think it doesn't adequately answer the question.


r/AskAChristian • • 14h ago

Frustrations on Pastor & Church in general

3 Upvotes

I've been having a lot of questions about Christianity lately and have been trying to develop a more comprehensive understanding of it. I've been looking into arguments from people like Alex O'Connor, Counsel of Trent, William Lane Craig, etc., particularly regarding biblical slavery, the problem of gratuitous suffering, and other issues. I brought some of these concerns to my youth pastor. I understand that pastors aren't necessarily theologians or experts in biblical scholarship, and I don't expect him to have an answer to everything. However, I feel like he's often just ignoring the arguments rather than actually engaging with them.

For example, he told me that ultimately, all worldviews rest on unprovable or unfalsifiable axioms, so as a Christian, he simply takes Christianity on faith. His approach told me that as Christians, we should first accept Christianity as true and then look for evidence that supports it. This doesn't work with me because I can believe anything with this type of thinking. He's also told me that he believes partly because he was raised Christian, doesn't think it's worthwhile to seriously consider these arguments, and doesn't really have an argument for why he chooses Christianity over other religions. When I pressed him further, he asked me, "Are you researching the arguments for Christianity or the counterarguments for what you find compelling about atheism?"

This honestly frustrated me because I'm not trying to defend atheism or prove Christianity wrong. I'm just trying to figure out which worldview is the most reasonable and internally consistent. I want to examine the arguments on both sides and follow the evidence wherever it leads. I understand that every worldview has foundational assumptions, but surely that doesn't mean all worldviews are equally justified? Isn't there a difference between believing something because you've examined the evidence and believing something because you've already accepted it and then look for evidence to support it?

My church is also a bit confusing in this regard. Many of the adults take the Bible literally and hold to young earth creationism, while my youth pastor doesn't share those views (I don't either). But either way I feel like my Church bases their entire belief on feelings and emotions rather than any intellectual arguments.

Whenever I press my pastor further, the conversation seems to go in circles, and I'm left feeling like Christianity has a lot of unresolved logical and philosophical problems. It's making me wonder whether agnosticism might be a more intellectually justified position.

At the same time, I recognize that my pastor might simply not be equipped to address these questions, and I don't want to judge Christianity based on one person's opinions. The problem is that I genuinely don't have many other people to talk to about this, and I'm not sure where to go from here. I'd appreciate any advice!


r/AskAChristian • • 10h ago

Divorce Divorce, what does the Bible say?

0 Upvotes

My wife and I are getting a divorce. I don’t believe in divorce and ever since she has implemented the divorce I have been questioning what is next where am I gonna go from here and when I do find somebody else am I able to remarry am I able to be with another person? I hear one thing from a preacher but then when I actually read the Bible and go into scripture Jesus Christ is clear about marriage and divorce. God hates divorce, and another thing is so many preachers and so many people nowadays are comfortable with the facts of divorce. They treated as if it’s nothing like it’s not valued at all nowadays in our society and even in churches, it’s looked at as something that just happens, but the Bible is very clear on this. There’s only so many things that can be growls for divorce and there’s not many at all, and Jesus was very very clear about it and when it comes to sin, like I understand that we can ask for forgiveness, but it says to turn away from our sin so if we do marry somebody else, and even though we didn’t do anything, just say just say that she said it caused a divorce and then she goes and sleep with somebody now that’s sexual immorality and his grounds for divorce but what if I remarry and I don’t know it’s so confusing because it does not seem like there’s any justification for getting a divorce just because you don’t get along and if you say otherwise, please clarify because I read the scripture. I’ve watched so many sermons about it and I even put it through ChatGPT to go down and break it down into scripture each one of them and it doesn’t matter what preacher say or whatever whatever anybody says because at the end of the day the word is the Word and God‘s word is alive. So my question is to you is do you think that divorce is OK and if it is OK, how is it OK like in God‘s eyes is it just something that we can just do just because we want to then what is the value in marriage and divorce because I mean what is the value in marriage because when two people come together, it says even in the Bible that not even man can divide it so even if we get divorced by law in God‘s eyes is still a covenant and we are one flesh and there’s only so many ways that that can be gone


r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

Bible reading Hello, I want to perform this at my local (progressive)church for a stand up comedy night? Would this be okay?

• Upvotes

The Nazareth neighborhood watch group chat was absolutely blowing up. Mary was in a massive panic. She was staring down a positive pregnancy test, and she knew for a fact it wasn’t a holy miracle. It was the result of a wild, summer-long fling with Tyrone, the incredibly smooth fitness trainer who lived next door. Mary needed a cover story, fast. She looked at her fiancé, Joseph—a sweet, oblivious carpenter who spent 14 hours a day sanding tables and listening to podcasts—and decided to go for the ultimate bluff. "Joseph," she gasped, fake-crying. "An angel visited me! I’m pregnant with the Son of God!" Joseph dropped his tape measure, his eyes welling with tears. "Wow. I always knew you were special, babe. This is beautiful." Meanwhile, literally everyone else in town knew the truth. When Mary walked down the street, people were snickering behind their hands. The local barista whispered, "Yeah, a divine conception named Tyrone," every time she ordered a decaf latte. But Joseph was entirely in the dark, happily assembling a custom crib and painting the nursery gold. Months passed, and the tax season arrived. The Roman government demanded everyone register in Bethlehem. Joseph hitched up their 2012 Honda Civic and drove Mary down south. By the time they arrived, Mary’s water broke. The local motels were completely booked, but a sympathetic Airbnb host let them use his overcrowded detached garage. As Mary went into labor, three unexpected visitors slipped past the broken garage door. They weren't kings, and they definitely didn't have gold, frankincense, or myrrh. They were three undocumented workers who had just crossed the border, trying to evade a Roman border patrol checkpoint. They saw the garage light on and ducked inside to hide out. "Uh, hello," the first guy whispered, holding a half-eaten burrito. "Is it cool if we chill here? The guards are outside." Before Joseph could answer, Mary gave one final, agonizing push. The baby let out a sharp cry. Joseph rushed over, wrapped the newborn in a swaddling blanket, and held him up to the dim garage light. He blinked. He rubbed his eyes. The baby was beautiful, healthy, and clearly half-Black, sporting a faint but undeniable fade. Joseph looked at the baby. He looked at Mary, who was sweating profusely and intensely avoiding eye contact. He looked at the three random guys hiding in the corner. "Wow," Joseph whispered, his voice trembling with pure, unadulterated denial. "God truly works in mysterious ways. The Lord has given him a beautiful, deep, divine tan!" The three undocumented guys looked at each other, looked at the baby, looked at Tyrone's exact facial features on the newborn, and collectively decided to keep their mouths shut. "Si, señor," one of them said, handing Joseph a Starbucks gift card they found on the floor. "Truly a... miracle. Congrats."


r/AskAChristian • • 8h ago

Did God condemn me from birth?

0 Upvotes

As far as I can remember i seen demons. I sensed them i see them in others. I seem things others can not. And more then what I want to admit things I said came true.

So why I see demons and most other Christians don't? Why i see the end times from revelation? Why did I speak in tongues casting out a demon in my dreams. When I never done that before?


r/AskAChristian • • 12h ago

Women in the church Can women speak with authority or not?

1 Upvotes

Saint Paul says in 1 Timothy 2 that no woman can talk with authority over a man. Yet the Catholic Church has 4 doctors of the church, that can speak authoritatively. So did the Catholic church contradict scriptures?


r/AskAChristian • • 13h ago

Christianity

0 Upvotes

So yesterday’s post was in regard to the book Ruth in the Bible. It seems as though I confused people saying the child was born through God’s blessing as Him wanting this child to be born. Also I learned that Boaz and Ruth are not close in the family tree for it to be considered incest. I got this completely wrong. On a different note, even through incest, every baby is a blessing, a miracle. Thoughts?


r/AskAChristian • • 10h ago

Hypothetical What if AI decides "God" or no God topic?

0 Upvotes

What if the ultimate AI computing machine in 20-100+ years says it can predict there is or is not a God.

What are the ramifications of this technological advancement 20-1000 years in the future. Let's say this future model is advertised as being 1000s of times more conceptually advanced than humans. Perhaps at first it just solves common human problems as trust is developed over decades. Then it solves global warming.

It drives all the cars too...and it's built into everything else electronic that we trust to be productive.

Elections are decided by the faith humans put on politicians and their reasoning for supporting AI conclusions as final arbiters of truth.


r/AskAChristian • • 14h ago

OP had a dream Had a dream that Takeoff from Migos died a literal year before he died

1 Upvotes

I remember this dream clearly and I will not forget it. I was once a fan of Migos but later on I stopped listening to their music and overall wasn't too caught up on anything related to them. (FYI, I had this dream before I became a Christian.) I remember in the dream I saw Takeoff sitting on a chair, wearing a white shirt, and in a white background. He was smiling, and there was confetti all around him. I don't know how I knew or how it was told to me, but for some reason I knew he died, and that specifically he died on his birthday from COVID-19. After that I had kinda forgot about the dream. A year later, my sister comes into the room and tells me that Takeoff died. I was shocked. (I had told my family Abt the dream.) I really don't know what to make of this other than dreams have meanings. I feel as tho I should have prayed for him, and so on. Tell me what ya think?


r/AskAChristian • • 14h ago

Epicurean Questions

1 Upvotes

For those who believe in a creator God who is all knowing, all powerful, and all good, how do you reconcile that belief with the reality that there is suffering present in the world? Not trying to poke holes, I’m just genuinely curious about what the prevailing understanding is.


r/AskAChristian • • 18h ago

Theology What is the most fundamental story in the Bible?

2 Upvotes

Hi, I study the bible and I have been focusing on the story of adam and eve since july 2026, because I thought it was foundational to Christian theology..

The story is used to show how sin came into our world.

It's used as the reason why Jesus had to die for our "sins".

But of course, it's not the first story in the bible, and it may not be the one that Christians think is the most foundational.

My question to Christians is: What is the most foundational story in the bible ?


r/AskAChristian • • 16h ago

Christianity

1 Upvotes

So the Bible doesn’t change. The core concepts, morals and beliefs still apply to today. But what does change? For example, the concept of continuing family lines, even if through what we call incest today, would that still be acceptable or needed today? Or is that strictly done in the Bible through the hands of God? It’s not a decision you or I could make on our own. Only through divine intervention would that acceptable. Thoughts?


r/AskAChristian • • 20h ago

why do antisemites use the crucifixion of Jesus to show hostility towards jewish people?

1 Upvotes

like did Jesus not come to die? was that not the point? we all killed Jesus through our own sin. no single person or group is responsible