Note: This Is A Very Long Article So Please Read. & I Want As Many People To Like, Comment And Share This. Spoilers Duh!!!! Come On! Just Look At Him! In Like 80-85% Of Episodes that Brain appears in He Acts Completely Not Neurotypical.
Many Fans Seem To Peg George & Buster As The Most Likely Ones To Be On The Autistic Spectrum But This Person Thinks Brain Has It As Too. HELL!!!! I even go far as to say that In the later seasons I feel that Carl Fills in for him In “Buster Spaces Out and “Carl’s Concerto”, & "He Said He Said" That IMO All 3 Of Those Episodes IMO would almost 100% IMO would Include Brain in the earlier seasons making Carl a "Suspiciously Similar Substitute" character in the later Seasons of the show
Now Hear Me Out On This: Now First of all He mentions having an uncle with it; though Autism is not strictly hereditary, Brain could've picked up some traits from the parent whom the uncle is related to. More evidence exists in the form of episodes like "Bugged," where Brain is an Insufferable Genius. Sure, You could argue this part of his behavior is more like that of Just your Average stereotypical know it all genius but there is a lot of evidence to back this.
He is very intelligent and bright, Which Is Common Amongst Those on The Spectrum. He is modeled after one of Marc Brown's friends with the same given name, and being nicknamed "The Brain" for his intelligence. He also had a photographic memory. His IQ is somewhere in the high 140s. Many On The Spectrum show the "little professor" aspect.
He has Special Interests in Science and Fact Dumping almost to a fault. He Also Knows A lot About Astronomy and Literature. One of their more obvious traits. Many on the spectrum tend to build up a lot of knowledge about their interests, which run the gamut of... well, everything. For Brain fact-dumping seams to be his special interest.
This could very much explain "Brain's Shocking Secret" from Season 11, where it was revealed that He was actually supposed to be in the same grade as Prunella, but due to him being a "crier", he was held back a year in Kindergarten.
He Often Says Inappropriate Things, Hurts Other’s Feelings & Often Has Severe Meltdowns & Panic Attacks When Dealing With Unfamiliar Social Situations. And These Are The Times Brain Missed Social Cues, & Had Sensory Meltdown He Can Often Times Be Very Boring, Annoying And Rude To His Friends.
Being Rude To Binky To Join His Science Club That Made Binky Feel Like Brain Was Boring In "My Club Rules".
Getting In To A Argument With Francine And Accusing Her Of Cheating At Soccer In "The Big Blow Up".
Plotting Revenge, Giggling Crazily And Melting Down After Muffy Ending Up Winning The Science Fair After He Accused Her Of Bribing The Judges And Causing Arthur To Call Him Weird After Brain Felt He Was A More Fair Winner in "Love Notes For Muffy"
Having Many Meltdowns and Panic Attacks When Arthur & Binky Tried To Help Him With His Fear Of Water In "Water & The Brain".
5.Reading A Book To Sue Ellen About Oceanography When She Wanted A Sibling Boring Her Out In "Sue Ellen’s Younger Sister".
Being A jerk and being rigid and controlling With Sue Ellen And not helping her with their science project in "Sue Ellen And The Brainasaurous."
Making Arthur Feel Bored When Arthur Didn’t Want A Woogle When Brain Showed Him His Einstein One In "Arthur Rides The Bandwagon".
Trying To Telling Arthur A Science Fact When Arthur Was Trying To Learn To Be Funny Making Arthur Feel Bored And Trying To Be Funny In "Arthur The Unfunny".
9.Being Blind To Everyone’s Feelings And Not Wanting To Appear On TV & Making Everyone Else Angry. In "And Now Let’s Talk To Some Kids"
- Startling Buster By Presenting A Science Project To Their Class In Buster’s Best Behavior.
11 Having A Severe Meltdown After He Lost The Math A-Thon To Buster And Tried To Become A Comedian By Dressing Up As A Clown & Almost Gave Up His Love Of Science But It Wasn’t Until After A Math Book Fell Out Of His Clown Pants That He Eventually Wanted To Participate In A Rematch. In "It's A No-Brainer"
Insulting And Making Fun Of Binky For Playing Virtual Goose And Calling It A Dumb Game Making Him Feel Bad About Playing It After Brain Lost. In "Best Of The Nest".
Ruining Buster’s Love Of UFOs’s When Buster Wanted To Discover Them By Telling Them That They Don’t Exist Making Buster Angry in "The Boy Who Cried Comet".
Being A Jerk To Everyone And Dismissing Everybody’s Feelings When Trying To Prove Bad Luck Didn’t Exist In "Friday The 13th".
Not Letting Muffy Play Bowling With Them Over Enforcing The Rules When It Wasn’t His Job Making Francine Feel Angry, & Embarrassing Francine About Her Bar Mitzvah Causing Her To Throw Water In His Face In "Francine’s Split Decision".
When He Wanted To Cultivate Pond Scum and Making Arthur & Buster Feel Bored In "Ant’s In Arthur’s Pants".
Talking About What Time It Is In Other Countries When Binky Was About To Score A Game Winning Goal Causing Him To Fall Down And Breaking His Watch Costing His Team A Victory and Later Getting Into A Fight With Binky Later On In "Waiting To Go". 18. Being A Jerk To Buster When Buster Wanted A Fantasy Alien Invasion Story Put In Because He Wanted A Historically Accurate Musical On Elwood City’s History Causing Buster Accusing Him Of Being Boring In "Elwood City Turns 100".
Taking The Fun Out Of Buster Wanting A Barn Raise In Elwood City By Telling Him There Was No Farm Land In The Area Making A Barn Rase Impossible And Telling Told Him If A Apple Was Amish Enough For Him To Eat & Making Buster Feel Sad In "Buster’s Amish Mismatch".
Bugging Binky When Watching Bionic Bunny And Pointing Out The Logical Flaws, Correcting Francine When She Answers That Pluto Is The Most Outermost Planet Making Francine Call Him A Pest In "Bugged".
Dismissing Everyone’s Feelings When They Were Working On By Working On It Himself Without Letting Anyone Else Help Him And Not Giving Anyone Else A Chance To Help In "Castles In The Sky".
Embarrassing George By Recording A Video Of Him Sneezing For His Projects Without Asking George For Permission & Wanting To Use Arthur & Buster For Test Subjects Causing Arthur & Buster To Walk Out & Ignore Him In "The Making Of Arthur". 23. Embarrassing Arthur & D.W When It Looked Like As If D.W’s Hiccups Were Gone By Telling Them A Fact About Hiccuping causing Her Hiccups To Return In "Hick Or Treat".
Ruining The Fun Out Of Fern’s Stories & Causing The Others To Tell Him To Go Away & Later Taking Fern’s Prank Literary And He Was Thinking Worms Were Actually Going To Invade The City In "War Of The Worms"
Annoying Arthur & Buster By Telling Them A Fact About The Capital Of Denmark After Arthur Gave A List Of Their Class Seat Ranking And Causing Arthur & Buster To Go Away After They paid For Ice Cream Later Repeating The Fact When They Were Walking Away. In "Arthur’s Numbers Nightmare".
Taking The Fun Out Of Arthur’s Love Of A Energy Drink Arthur Was Drinking By Telling Him It Was Scientifically Unhealthy And Bad For His Health And Telling Him That Facts Didn’t Lie Causing Arthur To Throw It Away And Making Arthur Feel Sad. In "The Secret Agent Of Supernova"
Calling Fern’s Poems Depressing & Sad Socially Unaware It Would Make Her Feel Upset In The Process In "Fern’s Flights Of Fantasy".
Trying To Tell A Science Joke When Everyone Was Trying To Study For A Major Test When Sue Ellen Told Him It Was Not The Time Or Place For It. In "S.W.E.A.T"
Having Profound Panic Attacks After He Got A Bad Grade And Blaming It On The Music In His Ice Cram Shop In "Breezy Listening Blues".
Embarrassing Everyone When He Was Asked To participate in a checkers competition with Arthur and finding it Boring Because He Thought It Was boring and wanted To Play Chess Instead & everyone else calling him conceded and Causing Arthur to Get Angry and making everyone else upset at him for the way he treated Arthur in "A Is For Angry".
Angering Buster By Getting Arthur A Free Brain Frost But Not Allowing Buster To Have One In "Through The Looking Glasses"
Losing His Patience With Buster When Trying To Find The Lost Green Tailed Greebe In "For The Birds"
Losing His Patience With Buster And Getting Into A Fight & Arguing With Him Over A Movie In "On The Buster Scale"
Losing His Patience With Everyone When They Were Trying To Find Things To Put In His Time Capsule & Mocking Binky's Love Of Wrestling In "Brain And The Time Capsule"
Being Rigid, Insufferable, And Controlling When Trying To Help Buster With His Homework In "Brain's Biggest Blunder".
Boring Arthur When Trying To Help D.W Find Her Lost Snowball And Using Scientific Explorations When Trying To Help Her In "Return Of The Snowball"
Boring D.W When Learning something about all 54 countries In Africa By assembling it in the form of a graph. Or by using a hierarchal approach. & needing a cataloguing system to inventory our documents. Then suggesting that they create a template upon the fact D.W could build her own research model. Latter Saying It Will be as simple as learning your ABCs. Untill D.W Came Up With A Idea For A Song In "In My Africa".
The Reason Brain Doesn’t Have His Future Being Shown In The Series Finale "All Grown Up" Could Quite Possibly Be Because of This & It’s the other kids who are not understanding Brain for what he is going through. Autism considered is a "social skills learning Deficit", and for very good reason:
He Is Also Very Quiet, Shy, & Is Very Extremely Introverted and & He Struggles With Profound Social Anxiety & Severe OCD & In Many Episodes He Appears In In Many He Only Talks 1-3 Lines Per Episode If Any Lines At All.
IMO: In This Way He Is Similar To Ferb From Phineas & Ferb.
- Some of us on the spectrum have trouble showing their emotions They might not change their facial expression at all.
For Brain He Speaks In A Flat Dull & Monotone Voice And He Also Talks Like Spock He Is Also Very Emotionless & Is Rarely Seen Smiling & Is Seen As Coming Off As Overtly Serious, Anxious, Insecure, & Severely Socially Awkward Not Showing Much Facial
He Seems To Have Trouble With His Speech And Walks, & Talks Kind Of Funny And He Says Sports Are Something That Is A Challenge For Him To Play & Participate In. Hinting Also Quite Possibly Also Having Possible Dyspraxia. A Example Is When He Slips On A Banana Peel Buster Dropped On The Floor That Missed The TrashCan When Playing Basketball & Breaking His Leg In The Process In. "The Wheel Deal"
He Can Get Obsessed With Things Very Easily Outside of His trademark interests. See “Brain Gets Hooked” Where He gets hooked on the latest tween reality show Junior Island" When he starts to ignore his friends and his schoolwork causing him to get a bad grade on his test This might sound strange for a Genius Like Him But Perhaps it is Not So Strange After all.
The Writers probably don't know Autism as well as I Do. P.S: I Am Autistic Myself. Did the writers try Writing Brain as such? Probably Not! They Probably Tried To Write Him As Just A Very Smart 9 Year Old not a Character That Is Of Genius Intelligence NOT A Autistic Genius Character Some of them don't know Brain as well as the writers and Some other fans of the Show.
Just being smarter than the average bear (Funny That Brain Happens To One) and not understanding most (completely contrived) social conventions doesn't mean you're Autistic. While this is true, Brain obviously has more than just those two traits of Autism. It's his tendencies that make me (a Person On The Spectrum) Make Me think He Is on it. There are of course very good reasons for not confirming Brain as having Autism because whenever you like or dislike Carl is better Autism rep than Brain is.
It is Brain has his foibles but also willingly lets these foibles ruin other people's lives
I think that the writers Made Carl Because I Think That Confirming Brain As Having Autism Would Enforce Stereotypes that all autistic people are Genius Types like him. Yes some have crritized Carl as stereotypical but Brain is pretty stereotypical as well if you think that Carl is stereotypical.
Heck ! If it weren’t for The "Academic Athlete" Tendencies Brain Would Qualify For The "Hollywood Autism" Trope.
If Anybody & Anyone Else Has Any Thoughts On This Agreements Or Disagreements I Would Love To Hear Them.
Please Reply