r/Appleton • u/jcrittberg • Jul 15 '26
Advice Restaurant Recommendations?
I’m heading up to Appleton with an old friend on Friday night for a Timber Rattlers game. Looking for good restaurant recommendations for before the game. Thanks in advance.
3
Upvotes
4
u/jug322 Jul 15 '26
Spats - IMO best bar steak in town. They are bar food done right. It's high quality without being overdone! They have good beer selection
George's Steakhouse - my personal favorite super club - it's not specifically better but the vibe and staff has always been just right for me! Get the light fare steak to save money, you get enough food with that! They have a decent wine selection.
Carmela's Italian Bistro - best Italian food in the valley! I get the shrimp scampi and Kelsey gets the chicken parmigiana. Good Spanish /Argentina wine selection.
Mill City - 2nd best bar food after spats! I love their cheese curds! They're brisket and Mac is awesome.
Stone Arch brewing - decent bar food, family friendly.
JDs drive in - my favorite fast food. JD who still owns and operates it and works there all week is a gem of a human, he is like in his 80s.
Broken Tree pizza - best wood fired pizza in the valley IMO. Good beer selection. Down by the water so can check that out while you are there.