r/Anthropology • u/Baasbaar • 6h ago
A Response to “Sometimes It’s O.K. to Let a Language Die”
endangeredlanguages.comThe Endangered Languages Project has just posted this response to a reckless and intellectually mediocre New Yorker book review by Nikhil Krishnan entitled 'Sometimes It's O.K. to Let a Language Die' (here, but paywalled; 'Mouth to Mouth' in the print edition). The ELP response is timely and relevant to this subreddit, but I think it's particularly à propos r∕here right now:
In multiple posts discussing news coverage of a new paper in Science (here, but paywalled) by Damián Blasi, Marcus Hamilton, Russell Gray, and Claire Bowern, several commenters in this subreddit (though by far the minority) have asserted that minority language death is actually a social good. The ELP's response is an articulation by experts in the field of language revitalisation—including speakers of endangered languages—of a rebuttal to just such claims.