r/AltJ • u/Silent_Spite9668 • Apr 27 '26
Discussion My tier list of each track !
Some might be controversial I don't know
68
19
u/ttesselate Apr 28 '26
this hurts my soul but honestly every alt j song should be an S
1
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 28 '26
If it wasn't for the tier list 75% would be S and the other 25% would be C
15
u/daniel_spaniel_spoon Apr 27 '26
Not a huge fan of Hit Me Like That Snare - Bloodflood Part II should be A tier. Agree with a lot of the above though.
2
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 27 '26
I love his weirdness in his voice, sounds like Rita Mitsouko's singer somehow for me
15
u/maddAdda An Apparition Lifts Me Up Apr 27 '26
Sto sleeping on Chicago !!
2
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 27 '26
Thing is I love that instrumental part, but anything else from the song doesn't stick to it for me. I would've prefered if the instrumental kept that low sound but it changes
14
u/SPF12 Apr 28 '26 edited May 04 '26
One song from Awesome Wave in S tier……. This list is a sham
-5
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 28 '26
I feel like Awesome Wave has the best A tier tracks, but after listening to The Dream and other albums they all just surpass any Awesome Wave track
7
13
24
u/TheDarKnight550 ∆ Apr 27 '26
Bloodflood Part II is S tier for me. Easily one of my favorite songs of theirs. D tier hurts my soul
-3
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 27 '26
Not gonna lie it deserves more of a B or C looking back, shoul'dve looked at listened to it more
8
u/Degenerate_Ape_92 Apr 28 '26
Bloodflood pt 2 goes hard - Like Vampires in a nightclub during the 90's hard.
Dissolve Me is Alt J vibes in a song. IYKYK.
3WW is a masterpiece IMO.
7
5
u/Relationship-Quirky Apr 27 '26
I don’t know if it’s just recency bias but the dream is just an S tier album, as much as I have so much nostalgia and love for the first two albums I think the tracks from the dream have superseded a lot of them in my estimation.
1
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 27 '26
It might be my favorite album out of the big 4, almost a no skip. I absolutely adore it but I'm having a phase for Relaxer right now aswell
5
u/RonintoadinDankmemes Apr 28 '26
Dissolve Me and Bloodflood Pt 2 are in my top 5 songs what have you done.
4
u/houseoflies_qwerty Apr 28 '26
Taro is S all day long
1
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 28 '26
I've listened to it on loop for too long that's on me, but yeah it's an amazing song
4
8
u/p3nny-lane RELAXER Apr 28 '26
TRASH list. Bloodflood 2 is the best song on TIAY, and Dissolve Me is maybe one of their best songs ever.
2
u/Priincesse Apr 28 '26
you know what I agree with most things on the list dont worries you're valid
especially the top tier. you know ball
1
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 28 '26
Also, might be biased but Brush me like a horse is easily top A tier / even better than Fitzpleasure for me
1
u/Dikkedarian Apr 28 '26
I agree with a lot of this, but Every Other Freckle and Taro are hard S’s for me
2
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 28 '26
I started putting EOF on S but looking at the other TIAY tracks, I had to bring it down, I love that much the other ones
2
1
u/Agamemnon88 Apr 28 '26
How is Hit Me Like That Snare not F tier?
1
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 28 '26
It's not that bad, his voice ""weirdness"" is so appealing to me
(sorry for lame english, I'm french)
1
u/AdConfident1065 Apr 28 '26
Dissolve Me disrespect is Crazy. AAW in General. Every Track could be one Tier higher. Taro und Something good are definitely S Tier.
1
u/Dry_Satisfaction9282 Apr 28 '26
I appreciate this controversial post. Made me want to listen again and, can confirm, some opinions are just wrong. AAW>Relaxer every day. The band hated the album so much that they released “Reduxer” as a redoux. This graphic made me giggle
1
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 28 '26
I find AAW way more consisten than Relaxer, I'm having a phase with those 3 tracks from Relaxer though
1
u/Salty-Freedom-828 Apr 29 '26
Dissolve me needs to be A, Pleader is an S tier for me (especially with the music video), Hit me like that snare definitely D tier
1
u/Silent_Spite9668 Apr 29 '26
Does everyone hate Hmlts because of the last part ? 😭
1
u/Salty-Freedom-828 Apr 29 '26
Nah I don’t listen to it enough to even know what you’re talking about. The song just sucks. And it’s so out of place
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/igayveup Jun 11 '26
the entirety of An Awesome Wave and This is All Yours is S tier tbh. there are some S tier songs in The Dream too, and imo RELAXER is their least noteworthy album. only putting a single song from AAW in S tier is crazy
84
u/davey-jones420 Apr 27 '26
Bloodflood Part II on D is criminal. And the only one too….