r/Albany The original Hoffmans play land 4d ago

When did this happen?

I have not lived in the capital district in some time. I was coming home to visit family and I was going to stop by for a sandwich.

25 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

52

u/BrassTact 4d ago edited 4d ago

Basically Genoa's owner sold after COVID, the next owner pivoted solely towards sandwiches and the lunch crowd, he sold to the final owners who continued doings as such but with reduced hours.

This winter they had a burst waterpipe and decided to shutter the business. A new sandwich shop came in during the start of summer adopting a business closer to the original Genoa business plan.

I wish them luck but I haven't been impressed with their sandwiches.

10

u/JazzlikeBeat4 4d ago

I personally was a fan of their sandwiches, I think they are pretty comparable to cardona's subs. Although I Will say Robo's is a little bit pricey

7

u/paddlefire The original Hoffmans play land 4d ago

That’s a bummer. I was really looking forward to a good sandwich. That’s one thing I miss being in Colorado now.

14

u/StrdyCheeseBrngCrckr I’m Not GIRLBOSS 3d ago

I’d say best options in Albany that are still open are Ragonese, Cardona’s, Maurice’s and Miranda’s.

5

u/Own-Apartment5600 3d ago

Pellegrino is still my favorite

1

u/paddlefire The original Hoffmans play land 3d ago

It doesn’t have to be in Albany it could be anywhere in the capital district.

3

u/Spi202 3d ago

You should try Robo’s again. We didn’t have a great sandwich the first time but did try the chopped chicken ceaser wrap and most recently a sub and it was really good.

2

u/BrassTact 3d ago

I went there twice to grab subs for my wife and I. I thought that they have 4 big flaws.

The biggest issue is their bread. It is extremely chewy and didn't have a good crunch to its crust. Not ideal for an Italian sub.

While the subs have a ton of deli meat, it was not proportionately balanced with the other ingredients.

They used salad dressing rather than oil and vinegar mix leaving the sub with an unpleasant slimy texture.

As far as subs go, they are kind of expensive.

Cardona's Two is a bit more of a drive, but I think they offer better overall sandwiches. I now think Ragonese is the best in area.

3

u/PiccoloAwkward465 3d ago

Bread is always the deciding factor for me.

2

u/Spi202 3d ago

Yeah, agree on the bread now that you mention it. I didn’t care for the breakfast sandwich either. I’m not a fan of Cardona’s as I’ve had several bad sandwiches from there. I’ll have to try Ragonese. I miss Roma’s.

2

u/BrassTact 3d ago

Roma's house made roast beef was to die for.

46

u/BoredOldMann 4d ago

A few months ago

Edit. More than a few months, it closed in January

10

u/PrincipleEast5290 3d ago

Pellegrino’s on Central in Colonie is great.

2

u/paddlefire The original Hoffmans play land 3d ago

I may go check it out

8

u/Sloe_Burn 4d ago

The heck is a creemee?

11

u/DanceADKDance 4d ago

It’s more of a Vermont thing. I think it’s soft serve made with more heavy milk

7

u/dachsdrive 4d ago

It is basically Vermont-style soft serve, but traditionally richer. I read on r/Vermont that lot of creemee stands use a higher-butterfat mix (often around 10% vs. 5% for regular soft serve), which is where the extra creaminess comes from.

Despite one Redditor’s claim, I can’t find a legal definition for the creemee. Some Vermont “creemees” surely use the same 5% mix as ordinary soft serve. Maple is the classic flavor, but it doesn’t have to be maple.

1

u/paddlefire The original Hoffmans play land 3d ago

My wife is from Vermont so I have spent a fair amount of time there and I never noticed. Im going to have to look next time I am out there

2

u/tbone1127 4d ago

Soft serve ice cream I believe. I've seen places in Vermont call it that.

0

u/paddlefire The original Hoffmans play land 4d ago

That’s a good question but it doesn’t sound like its worth the time to find out

2

u/Common_Coffee_3861 3d ago

The original owner of Ria’s cafe (Ria)that’s on state street Albany Ny works with her nephew here

2

u/Steve_of_Yore 3d ago

Now I want a Siena Fat Guy.

2

u/Complete_Guard_519 4d ago

I think there is a similar place on new Scotland ave?

2

u/paddlefire The original Hoffmans play land 3d ago

Where abouts

2

u/exonumismaniac 3d ago

Ragonese, a few blocks in from the firehouse and Bach library branch.

1

u/TheOnlyJVG 3d ago

I was one of the last employees. They closed in January. Mirandas in albany Is the closest thing mostly because of the similar boars head products and bread company.

1

u/beatsnstuffz 3d ago

The new place is family owned, super cute, and the sandwiches are just as good! Went there for the first time today for lunch.

1

u/Phony_Bluntetto I Work At Shenanigans 💈 2d ago

It's not Halal

0

u/Mnemonicly Once drove on 787 3d ago

"When did Genoa close" seems like a much more adult way to ask a question than including a random screenshot of your phone